U.S. COIN AUCTION OCTOBER 7 & 10, 2021 | LONG BEACH | DALLAS
a Th eee
rey.)
BOVLISH
S¥i1¥a| HOVIa DNOT | 107 ‘01 ® £¥380190 | FeELY NOLLSAY NOD “s'n
U.S. COIN AUCTION OCTOBER 7 & 10, 2021 | LONG BEACH | DALLAS
Signature® Auction #13834
U.S. COINS
Featuring: The Wabash Collection of Liberty Double Eagles | The Ed’s Treasures Collection The James E. Blake Collection | The Dr. Brian J. Baldwin Collection
October 7 & 10, 2021
Long Beach | Dallas
Heritage Auctions
2801 W. Airport Freeway | Dallas, TX 75261-4127 NW Corner of W. Airport Freeway (Hwy. 183) and Valley View Lane
FLOOR Sessions 1-2 (Floor, Telephone, HERITAGELive!®, Internet, Fax, and Mail)
Session 1 Thursday, October 7 * 1:00 PM CT « Lots 3001-3453
Session 2 — PREMIER SESSION Thursday, October 7 * 6:00 PM CT « Lots 3454-3640
Session 3 (HERITAGELive!®, Internet, Fax, & Mail only Session)
Sunday, October 10 « 2:00 PM CT « Lots 7001-7264
PRELIMINARY LOT VIEWING By appointment only. Please contact Matthew Tinsley at 214-409-1779 or MatthewT@HA.com to schedule an appointment
Heritage Auctions | 2801 W. Airport Freeway | Dallas, TX 75261-4127 NW Corner of W. Airport Freeway (Hwy. 183) and Valley View Lane
Monday, September 13 — Friday, September 17 | 9:00 AM — 5:00 PM CT Monday, September 20 — Tuesday, September 21 | 9:00 AM — 5:00 PM CT Heritage Auctions | 9478 West Olympic Blvd. | Beverly Hills, CA 90212 Saturday, September 25 — Monday, September 27 | 9:00 AM — 5:00 PM PT LOT VIEWING
Long Beach Convention Center | Room 104A 300 E. Ocean Blvd. | Long Beach, CA 90802
Tuesday, September 28 | 11:00 AM — 6:00 PM PT Wednesday, September 29 — Friday, October 1 | 8:00 AM — 6:00 PM PT
By appointment only. Please contact Client Services to schedule an appointment.
Heritage Auctions | 2801 W. Airport Freeway | Dallas, TX 75261-4127 NW Corner of W. Airport Freeway (Hwy. 183) and Valley View Lane
Tuesday, October 5 — Friday, October 8 | 9:00 AM — 5:00 PM CT
View lots & auction results online at HA.com/1334
LOT SETTLEMENT AND PICK-UP
Available weekdays 9:00 AM — 5:00 PM CT starting Friday, October 8 by appointment only. Please contact Client Services to schedule an appointment.
Heritage offers extended payment plan options up to six months to qualified, pre-approved clients on select items. Please email eppgroup@HA.com or call Client Services for more information. We also accept Bitcoin and Ethereum on invoices over $5,000 subject to approval. Please email Bid@HA.com or call Client Services for details.
his Auction is catalogued and presented by Heritage Numismatic Auctions, Inc., loing business as Heritage Auctions.
© 2021 Heritage Numismatic Auctions, Inc. All rights reserved
HERITAGE is a registered trademark and service mark of Heritage Capital Corporation, registered in U.S. Patent and Trademark Office
‘Patent No. 9,064,282
BIDDING METHODS
HERITAGE Live!”' BIDDING Bid live on your computer or mobile, anywhere in the world, during the Auction using our HERITAGELive!® program at HA.com/Live
IVE FLOOR BIDDING Bid in person during the floor sessions.
IVE TELEPHONE BIDDING (FLOOR SESSIONS ONLY) Phone bidding must be arranged 24 hours before your session begins. Please contact Client Services.
NTERNET ABSENTEE BIDDING
Proxy bidding ends 10 minutes prior to the session start time.
Live Proxy bidding starts seven days before the live session begins and continues through the session. HA.com/1334
FAX BIDDING Fax bids must be received 24 hours before your session begins. Fax: 214-409-1425
Lots are sold at an approximate rate of 125 lots per hour, but it is not uncommon to sell 100 lots or 150 lots in any given hour.
Buyer's Premium Per Lot: This auction is subject to a Buyer’s Premium of 20% (minimum $19) per lot.
Direct Client Service Line: 214-409-1150
Email: Bid@HA.com
Fax: 214-409-1425
Mail: Heritage Auctions | PO Box 619999 | Dallas, TX 75261-6199
TX Auctioneer Licenses: Teia Baber 16624; Ed Beardsley 16632; Sarah Davies 17505; Nicholas Dawes 16784; Sophie Duncan 17901; Christopher Dykstra 16601; Fiona Elias 17126; Francesca Felgar 17902; Samuel Foose 11727; Alissa Ford 17104; Kathleen Guzman 16142; Emily Hartman 17922; Gregory Francis Kopriva 18107; Roberta Kramer 17439; Peyton Catherine Lambert 18223; Brent Randall Lewis 17881; Jennifer Jayne Marsh 17105; Marina Medina 17512; Sarah Miller 18098; Rochelle Mortenson 17898; Michael Provenzale 17157; Samantha Erin Robinson 18104; Michael Sadler 16129; Barry Sandoval 17649; Nathan Schar 17365; Kimberly Serrano 17657; Anthony Singleton 17507; Tracy Sherman 18214; Rebecca Elise Van Norman 18103; Andrea Voss 16406; Jacob Walker 16413; Brian Wiedman 17894; Adam Williams 17893; Phillip Wooten 17656.
60608
SESSION ONE
COLONIALS
1652 Oak Tree Threepence, XF40 Noe-25, No IN on Obverse
3001 1652 Oak Tree Threepence, No IN on Obverse, XF40 PCGS. Noe-25, W-280, Salmon 3-Ai, R.6. Significantly scarcer than the usually seen Noe-27 and -28, but not as prohibitively rare as Noe- 24.5 or -27.1. This piece is slightly off center on the planchet, with strong detail and pleasing gunmetal-gray, russet, and olive-gold patina. No significant abrasions distract from the eye appeal. Listed on page 33 of the 2022 Guide Book.
NGC ID# 2ARF PCGS# 45357 Base PCGS# 18
1652 Oak Tree Shilling, VF Details Rare Noe-13.3 Variety
»*s Bs 5 558
3002 1652 Oak Tree Shilling, IN at Bottom — Scratches — NGC Details. VE. Noe-13.3, W-520, Salmon 10-G, R.6. 70.1 grains. Noe-13.3 and Noe-13.6 are intermediate die states documented by Eric P. Newman in 1959. Unlike Noe-13, the right shrub is a filled triangle. Unlike Noe-13.6, the first S in MASATHVSETS has an incomplete top, and the tree lacks spines. Die erosion on the central obverse causes a softly defined tree. Both sides display two intersecting straight pinscratches, along with a half- hearted attempt to efface the pinscratches on the obverse near the intersection. Listed on page 34 of the 2022 Guide Book.
From The Errorpalooza Collection.
1652 Oak Tree Shilling, AU Details IN at Bottom, Noe-5
3003 1652 Oak Tree Shilling, IN at Bottom — Damage — PCGS Genuine. AU Details. Noe-5, W-470, Salmon 3-D, R.2. 68.8 grains. An attractive silver-gray and sea-green representative. The legends are close to complete, with only the tops of IN MA and EW ENGLAN off the flan. The obverse border is slightly granular, and a few peripheral letters are lightly impressed, though the tree is richly detailed. A narrow horizontal mark is noted to the right of the center of the tree, and accounts for the strictly assessed designation by PCGS. Listed on page 34 of the 2022 Guide Book. Ex: Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 6/2017), lot 3504.
1652 Pine Tree Shilling, XF45 Noe-9 Rarity, Large Planchet
DN
3004 1652 Pine Tree Shilling, Large Planchet, Reversed N, XF45 NGC. Noe-9, W-750, Salmon 7a-Diii, R.6. 72.0 grains. Die alignment: 360°. An exceptional example of this rare variety. The tree is lightly struck, as always, and the coin as a whole is struck more firmly on the upper half of the planchet than on the lower. The charm of the hand-cut legends is accentuated by the remarkable spelling of EAGLAND, with the first N backwards and the second correct. The golden gray toning with a touch of rose is exactly what one expects in an original piece. Though rated R.6, the Noe-9 must surely be toward the upper end of that rating, closer to R.7 than R.5. Listed on page 34 of the 2022 Guide Book.
Ex: William Sumner Appleton; Bequeathed to the Massachusetts Historical Society (1905); Massachusetts Historical Society Collection (Stack’s, 10/1970), lot 35; Eric P. Newman Numismatic Education Society; Eric P. Newman Collection, Part IX (Heritage, 11/2017), lot 15007.
NGC ID# 2ARX, PCGS# 45372 Base PCGS# 23
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7,2021 | 1:00PMCT = 7
3005
1652 Pine Tree Shilling, XF40 Noe-25, Ex: Hain Family-Partrick
1652 Pine Tree Shilling, Small Planchet, XF40 NGC. CAC. Noe-25, W-890, Salmon 8-E, R.5. 64.7 grains. A pleasing gunmetal-gray shilling. The obverse is glossy, while the reverse exhibits a microgranular texture, as made. Struck slightly off center toward 7 o’clock, with the tops of the lower letters off the flan. The strike is generally crisp, although the right branches of the tree are lightly brought up. The finest of 11 examples in our notes are four XF examples.
The die state is usual for Noe-25 and features a break from the upper left corner of the first I in XII, reminiscent of the break from the clock on the backdated 1789 Mott store card. A second, smaller break is beneath the X, and a pair of narrow cracks pass through N DO. Listed on page 34 of the 2022 Guide Book.
Ex: Vlack Collection; Emerson Gaylord; Hain Family Collection (Stack’s, 1/2002), lot 153; Donald G. Partrick Collection (Heritage, 1/2015), lot 5597.
NGC ID# 2ARZ, PCGS# 24
(1795) Washington Liberty & Security Penny Baker-30, Plain Rims, MS64 Brown
3006
(1795) Washington Liberty & Security Penny, Plain Rims, “Asylum” Edge, MS64 Brown PCGS. CAC. Baker-30, W-11050, Musante GW-45, R.2. A near-Gem example of this contemporary Washington token, which was struck during his presidency. Smooth brown surfaces with mottled red undertones provide good eye appeal, and the strike is only a bit soft on the curl over the ear and the epaulet. These British tokens have been popular since their creation and are collected as part of the Conder token series beside having more obvious appeal here in the U.S. Listed on page 80 of the 2022 Guide Book. Population: 24 in 64 (1 in 64+) Brown, 5 finer. CAC: 5 in 64, 2 finer (7/21).
Ex: Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 5-6/2007), lot 48; Julian Kaufman Collection! FUN Signature (Heritage, 1/2018), lot 3083. NGC ID# 2B7V, PCGS# 767
8
1820 North West Company Brass Token, VF20 Breen-1083, W-9250
3007
1820 North West Company Token, Brass, VF20 PCGS. Breen- 1083, W-9250, R.4. The hole at 12 o’clock is common to all known North West Company tokens with just two exceptions. These pieces were produced in Birmingham, England, and reportedly found their way to the Pacific Northwest where they were exchanged with Native Americans for beaver pelts. This pleasing piece has distinctive greenish brass surfaces with slight weakness at the lower reverse. Listed on page 74 of the 2022 Guide Book. Population: 2 in 20, 7 finer (6/21).
Ex: FUN Signature (Heritage, 1/2016), lot 3580; ANA Signature (Heritage, 8/2017), lot 3023.
NGC ID# 2B6H, PCGS# 952
HALF CENTS
1804 C-11, B-12 Half Cent, AU58 Double Struck
3008
1804 Plain 4, Stems, C-11, B-12, R.2 — Double Struck — AU58 NGC. 83.8 grains. Breen Die State V. Manley Die State 2.0. Fuhrman Die State 2. Glossy olive-brown surfaces display considerable cartwheel luster with a few old scratches and handling marks. Obvious evidence of the double strike is visible on the obverse of this impressive piece with an off-center indent on the reverse. This is an excellent opportunity to start or expand a collection of half cent error types. Our EAC grade VF35.
Ex: Joseph Brobston Collection (Stack’s, 1963 FPL); William Florence (1/17/1967); Donald G. Partrick.
NGC ID# 222F, PCGS# 35170 Base PCGS# 1066
Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
1825 C-2, B-2 Half Cent, MS65 Brown CAC Approved
3009 1825 C-2, B-2, R.1, MS65 Brown PCGS. CAC. Manley Die State 2, with die rust in the obverse field near Liberty’s lips and neck. This CAC-endorsed Gem Brown example displays satiny mint luster with burgundy-brown color that includes tinges of red- amber. The wreath leaves beneath ICA on the reverse are slightly soft, but the devices are otherwise boldly struck. The obverse stars are mostly well brought up. Our EAC grade MS62. Population: 6 in 65 (1 in 65+) Brown, 0 finer. CAC: 10 in 65, 1 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 222T, PCGS# 35249 Base PCGS# 1141
LARGE CENTS
1793 S-2, B-2 Cent, Fair 2 Chain, AMERICA
—
1793 Chain, AMERICA, S-2, B-2, High R.4, Fair 2 PCGS. A glass reveals the microscopic surface granularity that is found on nearly all low-grade 1793 cents, but this piece has a smooth look to the naked eye, with intermingled light olive and blue-steel surfaces. The head and chain are fully outlined with other details indistinct. Our EAC grade Fair 2.
Ex: Summer FUN Signature (Heritage, 7/2018), lot 3331.
From The Dr. Brian J. Baldwin Collection.
NGC ID# 223K, PCGS# 35435 Base PCGS# 1341
3010
1793 Chain Cent, Fine Details S-3, Clear Legends
3011 1793 Chain, AMERICA, S-3, B-4, Low R.3 — Environmental Damage — PCGS Genuine. Fine Details. All legends are clear on this evenly circulated first-year, single-year type coin. The chain is bold, and Liberty’s eye and profile are well defined. The reddish- brown, steel-blue, and sea-green surfaces are moderately granular, but relevant marks are absent, with tiny obverse rim ticks at 4 and 5 o’clock noted strictly as identifiers. Our EAC grade Good 4.
1793 Wreath Cent, VG10 S-9, B-12, Vine and Bars Edge
3012 1793 Wreath, Vine and Bars Edge, S-9, B-12, R.2, VG10 NGC. Breen Die State VIII. The die crack through the CA in AMERICA is well advanced and heavy on this piece, and there is die buckling on the wreath leaves left of RICA. Uniformly chocolate-brown surfaces are finely granular in the fields. A couple of old nicks are visible near the obverse rim at 3:30 and 4:00. The rim is mostly complete around both sides. Our EAC grade VG8.
NGC ID# 223H, PCGS# 35459 Base PCGS# 1347
1793 Wreath Cent, Fine 12 Sheldon-11c, Lettered Edge
3013 1793 Wreath, Lettered Edge, S-11c, B-16c, Low R.3, Fine 12 ANACS. Breen Die State IV. Well defined except for in the central reverse where ONE CENT is weakened by die lapping. Both sides have deep walnut-brown color and uniform granularity, with a small mark also visible in Liberty’s hair behind the neck. An accessible Wreath reverse type coin. Our EAC grade Good 5. NGC ID# 223], PCGS# 35477 Base PCGS# 1350
1794 S-18a, B-2a Cent, Poor/Fair Details Head of 1793
3014 1794 Head of 1793, S-18a, B-2a, R.6 — Damage — PCGS Genuine. Poor/Fair Details. Both sides have intermingled tan and dark brown toning with minor surface marks and apparent lamination on the obverse. The reverse has myriad dark green and deep red pit marks. Our EAC grade Basal State 1.
Ex: Frank Leone; Thomas D. Reynolds; Dan Trollan (11/2000); Phillip W. Clover (Heritage, 9/2012), lot 3019, which realized $4,112.50; Greg Hannigan’s Rare Coins (2/2013).
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7, 2021 | 1:00 PM CT 9
1799 S-189 Cent, Good 4 Celebrated Key Date
3015 1799 8-189, B-3, R.2, Good 4 PCGS. The 1799 is the key date of the large cent series. Three die marriages are known, but S-189 is the usually encountered variety. The pick-up point is a close 99 in the date, relative to S-188 and NC-1. This example exhibits a nearly full date, with only the base of the digits blending into the rim. The tan-brown are lightly granular, and Liberty’s shoulder has a slightly wavy appearance. Substantial hair detail is present, and most of UNITED STATES and ONE CENT are clear. The fraction and AMERICA are softly brought up. Our EAC grade Good 4. NGC ID# 2246, PCGS# 36140 Base PCGS# 1443
1799 Draped Bust Cent, VF Details 8-189, B-3, Key Date
ee =
3016 1799 S-189, B-3, R.2 — Surfaces Smoothed — PCGS Genuine. VF Details. Breen Die State IV, with a narrow rim break above AM in AMERICA. The 1799 is a rare key in the early cent series, along with the 1793 and 1804. This impressive chocolate-brown specimen shows a full date and much interior detail remains intact on the bust and wreath, but most of the letters in LIBERTY have been effaced and the slightly granular surfaces show evidence of smoothing. Our EAC grade Good 5.
1799 S-189 Cent, VF20 Details Clear Date and Legends
3017 1799 8-189, B-3, R.2 — Corroded — ANACS. VF20 Details. The border legends, date, fraction, and central design elements are all clearly legible on this piece despite light wear on each side and moderate corrosion that leaves the surfaces granular with a few small pits. Uniform walnut-brown patina characterizes each side. A collectible, well-detailed example of this key Draped Bust date. Our EAC grade VG7.
From The Dr. Brian J. Baldwin Collection. NGC ID# 2246, PCGS# 36140 Base PCGS# 1443
1804 Draped Bust Cent, VG8 S-266b, B-1, Middle Die State
3018 1804 S-266b, B-1, R.2, VG8 NGC. Breen Die State III, with a break above RTY in LIBERTY. The 1804 Draped Bust cent claims a small mintage of 96,000 pieces, all struck from a single pair of dies. This VG8 example shows considerable wear on the design elements, but the date and all lettering remain legible, though a little weak on STATES OF The steel-brown surfaces show some slight granularity, but no large or distracting abrasions are evident. Our EAC grade Good 6. NGC ID# 224H, PCGS# 36422 Base PCGS# 1504
1839/6 Plain Hair Cords Cent, VF25 N-1, Early Die State
3019 1839/6 Plain Hair Cords, N-1, R.3, VF25 NGC. Noyes Die State a/a. The overdate feature is plain on this piece. Wear is even, leaving most major design elements visible. Uniform chocolate- brown patina shows scattered small marks in the fields, particularly on the obverse, although none are individually significant. A pleasing and important Plain Hair Cords variety. Our EAC grade Fine 12.
NGC ID# 225W, PCGS# 37261 Base PCGS# 1756
1839 Petite Head of 1840 Cent, MS65 Brown Newcomb-8
3020 1839 Petite Head of 1840, N-8, R.1, MS65 Brown PCGS. Ex: Troy Wiseman Collection. First year of issue for the new Petite Head Braided Hair cent. This is the only known die combination known for the date with the Petite Head obverse design. Both sides of the present piece have frosty and intermingled olive and dark brown surfaces, with faint traces of faded mint red color. Our EAC grade MS60.
Ex: Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 9/2006), lot 190; ANA Signature (Heritage, 7-8/2008), lot 1062; FUN Signature (Heritage, 1/2017), lot 3147.
PCGS# 37265 Base PCGS# 1817
10 Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
1843 N-2 Cent, MS66 Brown Petite Head, Small Letters
3021 1843 Petite Head, Small Letters, N-2, N-7, R.1, MS66 Brown
NGC. Ex: Rasmussen Collection. Grellman Die State c. The late die state of this die combination used to be cataloged as Newcomb-7 until it was determined that N-2 and N-7 are actually from the same dies. Positioned quite high in the Condition Census and probably tied for second or third finest known. This is a splendid example with medium brown color, pale iridescent toning, and bright orange luster. Our EAC grade MS63.
Ex: Robert Vail (Superior, 9/1997), lot 630; Bowers and Merena (3/1999), lot 1156; March Wells (Superior, 2/2000), lot 2170; Wes Rasmussen Collection (Heritage, 1/2005), lot 3762.
NGC ID# 2269, PCGS# 405836 Base PCGS# 1844
1853 N-10 Cent, MS66 Red Unfaded Color, Vibrant Luster
3022 1853 N-10, R.1, MS66 Red PCGS. Grellman Die State b.
Diagnostics for this plentiful variety include a horizontal dash from the dentils below the 1 in the date and another die line from Liberty’s curls up toward the E in LIBERTY. This Premium Gem features unfaded mint red color throughout and swirling cartwheel luster. A planchet flake occurs on the neck but does not affect the grade nor the eye appeal. Carbon is practically unseen. Our EAC grade MS66. Population (all varieties): 18 in 66 (1 in 66+) Red, 1 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 226K, PCGS# 406005 Base PCGS# 1903
PROOF LARGE CENT
1855 Cent, PR64 Brown Slanted 55, N-11
3023 1855 Slanted 55, N-11, R.5, PR64 Brown NGC. Aside from its
blatant full strike and broad, square rims, the italic 5s in the date and the positioning of the bust tip right of the flag of the 1 confirm the proof origins of this near-Gem cent. Glossy, deep chocolate- brown surfaces exhibit steel accents. A single contact mark on Liberty’s neck merits mention. Our EAC grade PR60. Census: 4 in 64 Brown, 3 finer (9/21).
NGC ID# 2273, PCGS# 400597 Base PCGS# 1994
FLYING EAGLE CENT
1858 Flying Eagle Cent, MS65 Small Letters Variety
3024 1858 Small Letters MS65 PCGS. CAC. The 1858 Small Letters
Flying Eagle cent is more elusive in high grade than its Large Letters counterpart. Examples are rarely seen above the MS65 grade level. This spectacular Gem example is well-detailed and well-preserved, with lustrous copper-red surfaces. Eye appeal is outstanding. PCGS has graded 22 numerically finer examples. CAC: 37 in 65, 9 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 2279, PCGS# 2020
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7, 2021 | 1:00 PM CT 1
INDIAN CENTS
3025
1859 Indian Head Cent, MS66 Only One Coin Graded Higher
1859 MS66 NGC. The Longacre Indian Head design was introduced in 1859 but its reverse only featured a wreath of laurel for that one year. In 1860, the reverse design was was modified to an oak wreath, creating a popular single-year type. This is a luminous, copper-gold Premium Gem with complete headdress feathers. A couple of microscopic ticks occur in the left obverse field. Two interesting die breaks appear along the left reverse border. Census: 10 in 66, 1 finer (8/21).
From The Ed’s Treasures Collection.
NGC ID# 227E, PCGS# 2052
3026
1889 Cent, MS66 Red Among the Finest Certified
1889 MS66 Red PCGS. Magenta tones complement the fire- orange obverse, while the reverse of this Premium Gem Indian Head cent is uniformly copper-red. The coin is well-struck, if from worn dies, showing crisp detail on the tips of the headdress feathers and the shield. Population: 21 in 66 (2 in 66+) Red, 0 finer (8/21). NGC ID# 228H, PCGS# 2174
1897 Indian Cent, MS66 Red Dazzling Mint Luster
3027 1897 MS66 Red PCGS. Although the mintage of more than 50
million pieces was huge even by Indian Head cent standards, full red 1897 examples become scarce in MS66. One short step up the grading ladder, Superb Gems with full red color number in the single digits. This is a fire-orange blazer with supremely lustrous, smooth surfaces and a needle-sharp strike. There are no distracting marks or significant imperfections — just a few pinpoint freckles. PCGS reports just six numerically finer examples, plus another seven pieces in 66+ (8/21).
NGC ID# 2288S, PCGS# 2198
1909 Indian Cent, MS67 Red Among the Finest Certified
3028
1909 MS67 Red PCGS. The final-year Indian cent is a popular type coin, although Superb Gem Red examples are conditionally rare. This piece is among the finest certified. Frosty copper-red luster adorns each side, and no bothersome carbon spotting is seen. The strike is bold. Population: 21 in 67 (5 in 67+) Red, 0 finer (8/21). NGC ID# 2297, PCGS# 2237
1909-S Indian Head Cent, MS65 CAC-Approved Red and Brown Example
3029
1909-S MS65 Red and Brown PCGS. CAC. From a final year mintage of just 309,000 pieces, the 1909-S Indian cent is one of the keys to this popular series. This spectacular Gem displays well-detailed design elements and mostly red original surfaces, with highlights of crimson patina and no mentionable distractions. Housed in a green label holder. PCGS has graded 11 numerically finer Red and Brown examples. CAC: 77 in 65, 8 finer (8/21). NGC ID# 2298, PCGS# 2239
PROOF INDIAN CENTS
3030
1859 Indian Head Cent, PR66 Flashy First-Year Proof
1859 PR66 NGC. The Mint reported a production of 800 proofs during the first year of the Indian Head cent series, but Rick Snow believes about half that number was actually sold and even fewer survive. Two die pairs were used, this being the second and usually seen variety with deep mirrors and striations near the date. Pale almond-gold with attractive violet, blue, and russet accents. Census: 19 in 66 (1 in 66%), 2 finer (8/21).
Ex: ANA Signature (Heritage, 8/2017), lot 3127.
NGC ID# 2299, PCGS# 2247
Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
1864 Bronze No L Cent Colorful PR66 Brown
3031 1864 Bronze No L PR66 Brown PCGS. The phenomenal Premium Gem showcases fantastic multicolor toning with mixed shades of violet, blue, green, and peach-gold with an overall amber-gold appearance. Curious concentric lathe lines occur over Liberty’s portrait in similar fashion to FS-1401. Population: 14 in 66 (1 in 66+) Brown, 3 finer (8/21).
Ex: Denver Signature (Heritage, 8/2017), lot 3128. NGC ID# 229F, PCGS# 2276
1876 Indian Cent, PR67 Red and Brown Among the Finest Certified
1876 PR67 Red and Brown NGC. From a fairly generous centennial mintage of 1,150 pieces, the 1876 proof Indian cent is decidedly rare at the PR67 grade level. This delightful Superb Gem exhibits sharply detailed design elements and deeply reflective fields on both sides. The flawless surfaces show a mix of light brown, crimson, and original red patina. Housed in a circa-2000 holder. Census: 5 in 67 (1 in 67*) Red and Brown, 0 finer (8/21).
PCGS# 2316
3032
1881 Indian Cent, PR67 Brown Virtually Flawless Surfaces
3033 1881 PR67 Brown NGC. Vivid shades of violet-blue and lilac toning blanket the virtually flawless surfaces of this spectacular Superb Gem proof, with razor-sharp design elements and deeply reflective fields underneath. Overall eye appeal is terrific. From a mintage of 3,575 pieces. Census: 6 in 67 (1 in 67%) Brown, 0 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 22A2, PCGS# 2330
1885 Cent, PR67 Red and Brown Rare This Fine
3034 1885 PR67 Red and Brown PCGS. CAC. Enough mint red survives to qualify this coin for the Red and Brown proof designation, a scarcity among surviving 1885 proof Indian cents. Most of the remaining proofs have mellowed to deep brown. This example displays evenly distributed brick-red color over razor- sharp design elements. Few proofs are of finer quality than the present coin, which earns CAC endorsement for its above-average technical merit and overall eye appeal. Population: 22 in 67 Red and Brown, 2 finer. CAC: 4 in 67, 1 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 22A6, PCGS# 2343
LINCOLN CENTS
1909-S VDB Lincoln Cent, MS65 Red and Brown Surfaces
3035 1909-S VDB MS65 Red and Brown PCGS. From a small mintage of 484,000 pieces, the 1909-S VDB Lincoln cent is the acknowledged key to the series. This attractive Gem displays well- detailed design elements and well-preserved original red surfaces that have mellowed to light brown in selected areas. Vibrant mint luster adds to the overall visual appeal. Housed in a green label holder.
NGC ID# 22B2, PCGS# 2427
1909-S VDB Cent, MS65 Red and Brown Colorful, High-End Representative
3036 1909-S VDB MS65 Red and Brown NGC. CAC. Yellow, orange, rose, and violet colors complement the coppery surfaces of this spectacular key-date Lincoln cent. Luster and strike are similarly appealing and impressive, including full definition on Victor David Brenner’s initials at the lower reverse. In our estimation, this CAC- approved Gem is well-worth a premium bid.
NGC I1D# 22B2, PCGS# 2427
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7, 2021 | 1:00 PM CT 13
3037
1909-S VDB Lincoln Cent, MS65 Attractive Red and Brown Surfaces
1909-S VDB MS65 Red and Brown PCGS. CAC. The 1909-S VDB Lincoln cent is widely recognized as the low-mintage key to the series, from a small first-year mintage of 484,000 pieces. This delightful Gem exhibits sharply detailed design elements throughout and the all-important designer’s initials are bold. The well-preserved original red surfaces have mellowed to light brown in selected areas but the overall quality and eye appeal are confirmed by CAC.
NGC ID# 22B2, PCGS# 2427
3038
1909-S VDB Cent, MS66 Red and Brown Terrific Color
1909-S VDB MS66 Red and Brown PCGS. CAC. Copper- orange and pumpkin-gold dominate this Premium Gem. Rose and violet tones serve as pleasing accents, though they probably stand in the way of a full Red designation. No matter, for the coin retains fantastic eye appeal and technical quality is outstanding. We note only a trace of softness on Lincoln’s portrait and around the rims, including the VDB initials, which are visible but faint. PCGS lists a single numerically finer example in the Red and Brown color category (8/21).
NGC ID# 22B2, PCGS# 2427
1909-S VDB Cent, MS66 Red and Brown First-Year Series Stopper
3039
1909-S VDB MS66 Red and Brown PCGS. CAC. This is a lustrous, glowing Premium Gem example of the popular first-year stopper in the Lincoln cent series. Pristine surfaces display a rich shade of coppery gold color, just a bit too deep for the sought-after full Red designation. Still, an exceptional coin for the serious collector.
Ex: Central States Signature (Heritage, 5/2004), lot 346.
NGC ID# 22B2, PCGS# 2427
1909-S VDB Cent MS66 Red and Brown Virtually Full Red
3040 1909-S VDB MS66 Red and Brown PCGS. CAC. After carefully
studying this Premium Gem, we believe that it should have received the coveted Gold CAC sticker, rather than the present green oval. The surfaces are flawless, the strike is exceptional, and the color is amazing. Both sides of this frosty and highly lustrous Mint State piece are essentially full Red. Only the slightest mellowing of the orange mint luster is noted on the reverse. Population: 94 in 66 (2 in 66+) Red and Brown, 1 finer. CAC: 29 in 66, 0 finer (8/21). NGC ID# 22B2, PCGS# 2427
1909-S VDB Lincoln Cent, MS66 Red Low-Mintage Series Key
3041 1909-S VDB MS66 Red PCGS. Take the lowest grade one
could imagine, and there are thousands of collectors who would love to own a 1909-S VDB cent in that condition. Of course, the same collectors would not be averse to an incredibly high-quality coin such as this Red Premium Gem, either. Semibright luster with a satiny undercurrent is primarily orange and peach, a trifle duskier on the reverse but entirely appealing and never “Brown” in any sense. Carefully preserved with excellent luster and eye appeal in spades. PCGS has certified only 15 numerically finer Red representatives (8/21).
Ex: Pittsburgh Signature (Heritage, 10/2011), lot 3200, realized $10,350.
NGC ID# 22B2, PCGS# 2428
Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
1916 Cent, MS67 Red Old Green Label Holder
3042 1916 MS67 Red PCGS. CAC. With a mintage in excess of 131 million pieces it is surprising that not more have survived in as fine condition as this Plus-graded Superb Gem. This is a beautifully preserved and luminous example, virtually flawless in its preservation with gold, orange, and rose hues throughout. Strike sharpness is outstanding. Among the finest pieces known. Population: 84 in 67 (21 in 67+) Red, 0 finer. CAC: 24 in 67, 0 finer (8/21). NGC ID# 22BN, PCGS# 2488
1922 Lincoln Cent, AU55 No D, Strong Reverse
1922 No D, Strong Reverse, FS-401, AU55 PCGS. Die Pair 2. The 1922 No D cent is a sought-after Guide Book and Cherrypickers’ variety. The mintmark was effaced during the removal of some die damage on Die Pair 2, the universally recognized No D variety, with the Strong Reverse. This pleasing Choice AU example shows only light wear on the design elements and the olive-brown surfaces are lightly abraded.
PCGS# 37676 Base PCGS# 3285
1926-S Cent, MS64 Red Challenging With Red Color
3043
3044 1926-S MS64 Red PCGS. The 1926-S is among the better-known condition keys in the Lincoln cent series, seldom offered in Red grades at any level. Gem Red coins are, in fact, prohibitively rare, with only three reported at PCGS and NGC combined (5/21). This Choice example represents the finest quality typically available for the Red color category. Sharp devices complement satiny luster, with no distracting carbon seen. The warm amber-orange surfaces exhibit the subdued “red” appearance that is characteristic of the 1926-S. Population: 79 in 64 (5 in 64+) Red, 2 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 22CL, PCGS# 2575
1929-D Cent, MS66+ Red Top-of-the-Line CAC Registry Coin
1929-D MS66+ Red PCGS. CAC. A scarce Premium Gem Red example of this Denver issue, devoid of carbon spotting and vibrantly lustrous. The strike is bold, and there is no obtrusive die erosion. With the Plus designation and CAC endorsement, this is within the Condition Census of certified 1929-D Lincoln cents, and none are known finer in the Red category. Population: 40 in 66 (6 in 66+) Red, 0 finer. CAC: 14 in 66, 0 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 22CV, PCGS# 2599
1930-S Cent, MS67 Red Among the Finest Certified
3045
3046 1930-S MS67 Red NGC. A lovely Superb Gem Red example of this conditionally challenging San Francisco issue, showing rich copper-red color that is devoid of bothersome spots. A loupe fails to reveal even a single notable abrasion. The 1930-S is scarce in MS67 Red, and no finer pieces are reported. An exceptional Registry candidate. Census: 33 in 67 Red, 0 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 22CZ, PCGS# 2611
1934-D Cent, Luminous MS67 Red Among the Finest Pieces Certified One of the Finest at CAC
3047 1934-D MS67 Red PCGS. CAC. A Superb Gem, this Red 1934- D Lincoln cent is among the finest pieces certified. Examples in this condition are important Registry Set acquisitions, and they are scarce. This piece is CAC endorsed — one of just 15 top-grade coins so recognized. Luminous copper-orange surfaces complement satiny mint luster, while neither side has obvious carbon spotting. The coin is well-struck with outstanding visual appeal. Population: 70 in 67 (12 in 67+) Red, 0 finer. CAC: 15 in 67, 0 finer (8/21). NGC ID# 22DA, PCGS# 2638
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7, 2021 | 1:00 PM CT 15
1949 Cent, MS67+ Red CAC-Approved Registry Coin
oe
3048 1949 MS67+ Red PCGS. CAC. Although plentiful in lower grades, the 1949 Lincoln cent is conditionally scarce in MS67 Red, and such coins are rare with a Plus designation. This is one of the top five pieces at PCGS, with none graded finer (8/21). The strike is sharp, and frosty copper-orange luster is devoid of carbon spotting. Population: 48 in 67 (5 in 67+) Red, 0 finer. CAC: 16 in 67, O finer (8/21). NGC ID# 22EV, PCGS# 2770
1955 FS-101 Cent, MS63 Brown Doubled Die Obverse
os
1955 Doubled Die Obverse, FS-101, MS63 Brown PCGS. CAC. The 1955 Doubled Die Obverse cent, designated as FS-101 in the Cherrypickers’ Guide, has a strong claim to being the most famous variety in 20th century American coinage. This Select example maintains original mint red around the devices, while the smooth, glossy brown surfaces exhibit scattered violet and steel-blue accents. Well-detailed with unmistakable doubling on all obverse legends. NGC ID# 22FG, PCGS# 37910 Base PCGS# 2825
1976 Lincoln Cent, MS68 Red Among the Finest Certified
were
3049
3050 1976 MS68 Red NGC. This magnificent MS68 Lincoln cent, from the country’s Bicentennial year, exhibits sharply detailed design elements throughout and the original red surfaces are virtually flawless. Vibrant mint luster adds to the terrific eye appeal. NGC has certified four coins in MS68 Red, with none finer, while PCGS has graded five examples in the same grade, also with none finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 22H7, PCGS# 2982
PROOF LINCOLN CENTS
1916 Lincoln Cent, PR64 Red and Brown Final Matte Proof Issue
1916 PR64 Red and Brown PCGS. Only 600 matte proof Lincoln cents were struck in 1916, with the coins delivered in three 200-coin batches. This was the final year of commercial proof offerings during the classical era. This impressive Choice example is sharply struck throughout and the well-preserved surfaces are mostly red, with highlights of magenta, blue, and light brown patina. Housed in a green label holder. Population: 58 in 64 Red and Brown, 93 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 22KZ, PCGS# 3325
1936 Lincoln Cent, PR66 Red Type One-Satin Finish
3051
1936 Type One—Satin Finish PR66 Red PCGS. CAC. The Philadelphia Mint resumed commercial proof set offerings in 1936, after a two-decade hiatus. The first cents struck featured a Satin Finish, with a mintage of 5,569 pieces. This spectacular Premium Gem displays virtually flawless original red surfaces, with vibrant mint luster and sharply detailed design elements throughout. Housed in a green label holder. Population: 45 in 66 (8 in 66+) Red, 1 finer. CAC: 14 in 66, 0 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 22L2, PCGS# 3332
1936 Lincoln Cent, PR66 Red Popular Brilliant Finish Example
3052
3053 1936 Type Two — Brilliant Finish PR66 Red PCGS. The Mint resumed its commercial proof offerings in 1936, after a two-decade hiatus. At first, the coins were struck with a matte proof finish, but that proved unpopular with collectors, so the Mint switched to a brilliant finish part way through the year. This delightful Premium Gem exhibits sharply detailed design elements and virtually pristine original red surfaces throughout. Population: 79 in 66 (5 in 66+) Red, 2 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 22L3, PCGS# 3335
16 Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
1937 Lincoln Cent, PR67 Red CAC-Endorsed Registry Grade Example
3054
1937 PR67 Red NGC. CAC. From a small mintage of 9,320 pieces, the 1937 proof Lincoln cent is an elusive issue in PR67, and finer coins are virtually unobtainable. This spectacular Superb Gem proof exhibits sharply detailed design elements throughout, with impeccably preserved original red surfaces and deeply reflective fields. Census: 22 in 67 (2 in 67+ Red, 1 in 67%), 1 finer. CAC: 18 in 67
NGC ID# 22L4, PCGS# 3338
1990 Lincoln Cent, PR67 Red Deep Cameo No S Proof, FS-101
3055
1990 No S, FS-101, PR67 Red Deep Cameo PCGS. Probably fewer than 200 examples of this popular Guide Book and Cherrypickers’ variety escaped the San Francisco Mint, to be found in both regular and Prestige proof sets by lucky collectors. This spectacular Superb Gem exhibits sharply detailed, frosty design elements that contrast profoundly with the deeply mirrored fields. The copper-red surfaces are well-preserved and appealing.
PCGS# 408239 Base PCGS# 93506
THREE CENT SILVER
1857 Three Cent Silver, MS65 Elusive Type Two Issue
3056
1857 MS65 PCGS. Ex: Larry Shapiro. Dappled grayish-silver toning hosts blue and gold highlights across the attractive surfaces of this Gem Uncirculated silver three cent piece. A burst of ruby- red and yellow-gold highlights the central reverse for extra eye appeal. With the exception of minor weakness at the lower obverse star border, the strike is sharp for a Type Two silver three. Gem Uncirculated examples are scarce regardless of date for this five- year design. Population: 38 in 65 (1 in 65+), 24 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 2226, PCGS# 3673
PROOF THREE CENT SILVER
1863 Three Cent Silver, PR66 Beautifully Toned, Exquisitely Preserved
3057
1863 PR66 PCGS. CAC. This is an original and richly toned proof three cent silver piece from a mintage of 460 coins. Blue and green color at the borders turns to shades of violet, rose, and golden-orange toward the center of this Premium Gem. Exquisitely preserved. Population: 25 in 66 (3 in 66+), 0 finer. CAC: 10 in 66, 2 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 22ZP, PCGS# 3712
1873 Three Cent Silver, PR66 Proof-Only Final Issue
3058
1873 PR66 NGC. Closed 3. Coinage of three cent silver pieces was discontinued after 1873, when a meager mintage of 600 proofs for collectors was accomplished. This spectacular Premium Gem displays sharply detailed design elements, with full star centers and fine definition on the arrow fletching. The surfaces are impeccably preserved. Census: 29 in 66 (1 in 66+, 1 in 66%), 8 finer (8/21). NGC ID# 27CJ, PCGS# 3724
THREE CENT NICKELS
3059
1880 Three Cent Nickel, MS67+ Among the Finest Certified
1880 MS67+ PCGS. CAC. The 1880 three cent nickel claims a small business-strike mintage of 21,000 pieces. Examples in MS67 condition are definitely elusive today, and no coins have been certified in higher numeric grades at either of the leading grading services (8/21). This Plus-graded Superb Gem exhibits sharply detailed design elements and impeccably preserved lustrous surfaces, with attractive highlights of pale gold and lavender toning. Population: 52 in 67 (6 in 67+), O finer. CAC: 19 in 67, 0 finer (8/21).
NGC 1D# 275C, PCGS# 3748
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7, 2021 | 1:00 PM CT 17
1882 Three Cent Nickel, MS66 Conditionally Scarce
3060
1882 MS66 PCGS. From a limited mintage of 22,200 pieces, the 1882 three cent nickel is conditionally scarce in MS66, and finer pieces are major rarities. This example is sharply struck and brilliant, with luminous satin surfaces and no bothersome abrasions. Faint die polish lines in the obverse fields produce mild simulated reflectivity. Population: 24 in 66 (1 in 66+), 4 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 275D, PCGS# 3750
1882 Three Cent Nickel, MS66 Rare Any Finer
3061
1882 MS66 PCGS. CAC. From a mintage of only 22,200 pieces, the 1882 three cent nickel is a better date in all grades. Premium Gem examples such as the present coin are rare, and finer coins are virtually unobtainable. This coin is one of only seven pieces in this grade with CAC approval, with one finer. The strike is sharp, and the softly frosted luster yields delicate iridescence. Population: 24 in 66 (1 in 66+), 4 finer. CAC: 7 in 66, 1 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 275D, PCGS# 3750
PROOF THREE CENT NICKEL
1877 Three Cent Nickel, PR65 Series Key, Gold CAC Sticker
3062 1877 PR65 PCGS. Gold CAC. The 1877 is one of the premier
dates in the three cent nickel series. A total of 900 coins were struck in proof format exclusively, accounting for the issue’s widespread popularity and the challenge it poses. This Gem displays undesignated cameo contrast and features the faintest trace of golden color over otherwise brilliant nickel-gray surfaces. The coin boasts a seldom-seen Gold CAC approval sticker, suggesting a possible endorsement even at the next highest grade level.
NGC ID# 275X, PCGS# 3773
SHIELD NICKELS
18
3063
1866 Shield Nickel, MS66 High-End Rays Type Coin
1866 Rays MS66 PCGS. Satiny luster is brilliant and unabraded on this Premium Gem Rays type coin, complementing sharply struck design elements. Myriad small die cracks are visible on each side in the margins, as is typically the case for early Shield nickel issues. Eye appeal is pleasing. This is among the finest 1866 Shield nickels certified. Population: 62 in 66 (8 in 66+), 0 finer (8/21). NGC ID# 22NX, PCGS# 3790
1868 Shield Nickel, MS66+ Only Two Finer Coins at PCGS
3064
1868 MS66+ PCGS. CAC. The 1868 Shield nickel claims a mintage of more than 28 million pieces, but few survivors can match the quality and eye appeal of the present coin. This Plus- graded Premium Gem exhibits well-detailed design elements and impeccably preserved lustrous surfaces that show a few subtle hints of pale gold and lavender toning. Population: 45 in 66 (10 in 66+), 2 finer. CAC: 15 in 66, 1 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 22P2, PCGS# 3795
PROOF SHIELD NICKELS
1866 Shield Nickel, PR66 Cameo Brilliant Rays Type Coin
3065
1866 Rays PR66 Cameo NGC. Brilliant and deeply mirrored, this contrasted Premium Gem proof displays sharp motifs and excellent preservation. The 1866 is the first of only two Rays issues in the Shield nickel series, an ideal choice for type collectors in proof format. Census: 27 in 66 Cameo (2 in 66%), 13 finer (8/21).
Ex: Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 9/2003), lot 5914.
NGC ID# 276G, PCGS# 83817
Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
1868 Shield Nickel, PR66+ Cameo Beautifully Contrasted
1868 PR66+ Cameo NGC. The 1868 proof is seldom seen in high Cameo grades, and Ultra or Deep Cameo pieces are prohibitively rare for most collectors. This Plus-graded Premium Gem displays generous field-device contrast complemented by fully brilliant surfaces. The strike is sharp, and neither side exhibits bothersome abrasions. Census: 20 in 66 Cameo (2 in 66+, 2 in 66+%*), 5 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 276], PCGS# 83822
1876 Shield Nickel, PR66 Ultra Cameo Rare So Starkly Contrasted
3066
1876 PR66 Ultra Cameo NGC. Razor-sharp and deeply reflective, showing brilliant, starkly contrasted surfaces with nearly flawless preservation. Proof 1876 Shield nickels are incredibly rare in Ultra or Deep Cameo grades, with only nine such pieces reported at NGC at all levels. This piece is an outstanding Registry candidate. Census: 8 in 66 Ultra Cameo (1 in 66+), 1 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 276T, PCGS# 93830
1877 Shield Nickel, PR66 Delicate Pastel Toning
3067
3068 1877 PR66 NGC. From a proof-only mintage of just 900 pieces, this Premium Gem 1877 Shield nickel is conditionally scarce. Lovely pastel blue and lavender toning graces the modestly reflective fields, while the devices exhibit bold sharpness. A few faint, milky spots are barely discernible on the reverse. Eye appeal is outstanding. Finer examples are rarely seen. Census: 35 in 66 (1 in 66+, 3 in 66%), 5 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 276U, PCGS# 3831
1877 Shield Nickel, PR64+ Cameo Well Contrasted
3069 1877 PR64+ Cameo PCGS. Deep Cameo examples of this proof- only issue are prohibitively rare, making Cameo pieces attractive options for most collectors. This Plus-graded piece displays brilliant surfaces and appreciable contrast on each side. The devices are sharp and softly frosted. No contact marks interrupt the eye appeal.
NGC ID# 276U, PCGS# 83831
PROOF LIBERTY NICKELS
1909 Nickel, PR68 Lavender and Gold Patina
1909 PR68 NGC. This is a gorgeous lavender and gold-toned proof Liberty nickel in top-graded PR68 condition. Partial contrast exists between the portrait of Liberty and the surrounding fields, though not enough to merit a seldom-awarded Cameo designation. Still, eye appeal and technical quality are both excellent. From a mintage of 4,763 proofs. Census: 13 in 68 (2 in 68 *), O finer in this category (9/21).
NGC ID# 278K, PCGS# 3907
3070
1909 Nickel, PR67+ Cameo CAC-Endorsed Proof Type Coin
1909 PR67+ Cameo PCGS. CAC. The proof 1909 Liberty nickel is a great rarity in Deep Cameo grades, and high-end Cameos are conditionally scarce. This Plus-graded, CAC-endorsed Superb Gem Cameo displays beautifully contrasted, frosty devices set against deeply reflective fields. Brilliant and pristine. Population: 57 in 67 (22 in 67+) Cameo, 6 finer. CAC: 41 in 67, 4 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 278K, PCGS# 83907
3071
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7, 2021 | 1:00 PM CT 19
BUFFALO NICKELS
1913-S Type One Nickel, MS67 Rarely Seen Finer
3072
1913-S Type One MS67 PCGS. Definition is full on the braid and bison’s shoulder, but a touch soft on LIBERTY and the bison’s head. This S-mint Type One Superb Gem is awash in frosty mint luster and remains mostly brilliant with gold and blue accents, especially on the reverse. There are only four numerically finer submissions at PCGS (8/21).
NGC ID# 22PY, PCGS# 3917
1914 Buffalo Nickel, MS67 Registry Set Contender
3073
1914 MS67 PCGS. The 1914 Buffalo nickel claims a mintage of more than 20.6 million pieces, but the issue is definitely elusive at the MS67 grade level and neither of the leading grading services have certified any coins in higher numeric grades (8/21). This delightful Superb Gem exhibits well-detailed design elements, with just a trace of softness on the bison’s shoulder. The impeccably preserved surfaces radiate vibrant mint luster, with outstanding eye appeal. Population: 43 in 67 (3 in 67+), 0 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 22R4, PCGS# 3924
1925 Nickel, MS67+ Beautifully Toned, None Finer
3074 1925 MS67+ NGC. Peach-gold, powder-blue, and lavender
toning covers the entirety of this Superb Gem nickel. The natural overlay produces exquisite eye appeal, matching the unsurpassed technical quality. Strike definition is as sharp as can be and there are no marks to report. Among the finest at both services combined. Census: 12 in 67 (4 in 67+), 0 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 2282, PCGS# 3954
20
3075
1925 Nickel, MS67 CAC-Approved Registry Coin
1925 MS67 PCGS. CAC. The 1925 nickel is known for its weak-to-average strike. Although far from fully struck and lacking sharpness on 19 in the date, this Superb Gem displays good detail on the bison’s head, horn, and shoulder, and the legends. Even the Indian’s braid is relatively well-defined. Both sides are frosty and brilliant without much more than a few areas of planchet roughness. Population: 41 in 67 (6 in 67+), 0 finer. CAC: 6 in 67, 0 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 2282, PCGS# 3954
1927-D Buffalo Nickel, MS65+ Key Issue in High Grade
3076
1927-D MS65+ PCGS. CAC. The Denver Mint struck more than 5.7 million Buffalo nickels in 1927, but the issue was not well- produced and quality control was spotty. The dies were overused or widely spaced, causing many examples to show weak striking details and lackluster surfaces. As might be expected, the 1927-D is scarce at the MS65 grade level and finer coins are decidedly rare. This Plus-graded Gem exhibits well-detailed design elements, with just a touch of the usual softness on the bison’s shoulder. The well-preserved lustrous surfaces are blanketed in attractive shades of ice-blue, sea-green, and bluish-gray toning. Eye appeal is outstanding. PCGS has graded 16 numerically finer examples. CAC: 22 in 65, 4 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 2289, PCGS# 3961
3077
1937-D Three-Legged Nickel, MS62 Pleasing CAC-Approved Example
1937-D Three-Legged, FS-901, MS62 PCGS. CAC. The die pair that struck this famous variety was heavily worn and eroded by the time that the reverse was polished down, effacing the bison’s leg. The design elements and portions of the fields on both sides exhibit heavy metal flow and die fatigue. This Mint State example is CAC endorsed. Satiny luster yields delicate pastel color, with no major abrasions despite the modest numeric grade.
NGC ID# 22SX, PCGS# 38475 Base PCGS# 3982
Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
3078
1937-D Three-Legged Nickel, MS64 Sought-After Guide Book Variety
1937-D Three-Legged, FS-901, MS64 NGC. Genuine examples of this key Guide Book variety can be distinguished by the presence of fine, raised rust lumps in the reverse field from the center of the bison’s belly to the ground between the hooves. This example is well struck with deep olive-gray toning that lightens to golden iridescence in the centers. A pleasing near-Gem representative. Ex: Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 6/2015), lot 3829.
NGC ID# 22SX, PCGS# 38475 Base PCGS# 3982
PROOF BUFFALO NICKELS
1915 Buffalo Nickel, PR66 Attractive Multicolor Toning
3079
1915 PR66 PCGS. CAC. The Philadelphia Mint struck a small production of 1,050 matte proof Buffalo nickels for collectors in 1915. Enough examples were saved by contemporary numismatists to make the issue collectible at the PR66 grade level, but finer coins are elusive. This spectacular Premium Gem exhibits razor- sharp definition on all design elements and the impeccably preserved lustrous surfaces are enhanced by highlights of ice-blue, sea-green, and magenta toning.
PCGS has certified 93 numerically finer examples. CAC: 48 in 66, 40 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 278U, PCGS# 3992
1916 Nickel, PR65+ Key Matte Proof Issue
3080
1916 PR65+ PCGS. Streaks of golden color line the dusky nickel- gray surfaces of this matte proof, one of only 600 pieces struck. That low mintage makes the 1916 the singular key among Buffalo nickels in this format. Definition is predictably pinpoint-sharp, and we have a hard time picking out any overt points of contact on either side.
NGC ID# 278V, PCGS# 3993
1916 Nickel, Sharp PR67 A Rarity This Fine
3081
1916 PR67 NGC. The 1916 is the lowest-mintage and most elusive of the matte proof Buffalo nickel issues, just 600 pieces strong, represented here by a remarkable Superb Gem. The minimally toned surfaces showcase the distinctive matte luster and razor-sharp detail that are the hallmarks of this type. Eye appeal is outstanding. Census: 27 in 67 (2 in 67+, 1 in 67%), 2 finer (8/21). NGC ID# 278V, PCGS# 3993
3082
1936 Buffalo Nickel, PR67+ Sparkling Brilliant Finish
1936 Type Two — Brilliant Finish PR67+ PCGS. CAC. Aside from mellowing into a melange of beautiful colors, this mirrorlike Superb Gem Type Two proof is essentially as struck. There are no post-Mint impairments, while the strike is as sharp as can be and the fields are prepared to the utmost of the Mint’s capabilities. Subtle, multicolor toning enhances each side in shades of lavender, pale-blue, lilac-gray, and yellow-gold. The watery, reflective fields counterbalance exquisite raised elements. PCGS reports just 16 numerically finer examples. Population: 77 in 67+, 16 finer. CAC: 105 in 67, 8 finer (7/21).
NGC ID# 278Y, PCGS# 3995
JEFFERSON NICKELS
1943-D Nickel, MS68 Five Full Steps Beautifully Toned Registry Candidate
3083 1943-D MS68 Five Full Steps NGC. A needle-sharp, high-end
Superb Gem with pristine surfaces that appear flawless even under a loupe. Beautiful rainbow toning on each side surrounds the margins, leaving the interiors yellow-gold. Eye appeal is exceptional. A rarity in this grade and among the finest Full Steps coins certified. Census: 11 in 68 (1 in 68+ Five Full Steps, 1 in 68%), 0 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 22TS, PCGS# 84020
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7, 2021 | 1:00 PM CT 2)
1947-S Nickel, MS67 Full Steps Tied for Finest at PCGS
3084 1947-S MS67 Full Steps PCGS. This conditionally rare Jefferson nickel offering ranks among the finest 1947-S representatives at both services. Frosty luster shimmers across mostly brilliant surfaces. Golden accents appear along the right borders on each side. Population: 10 in 67 Full Steps, 0 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 22U7, PCGS# 84033
1949-D/S FS-501 Nickel, MS67+ Top-Graded Guide Book Variety
1949-D/S FS-501 MS67+ PCGS. The underlying S mintmark is clear beneath the primary D on this Guide Book and Cherrypickers Guide variety, described by the authors of the latter as “quite rare in Mint State and highly sought after.” This is the PCGS CoinFacts plate coin and one of the finest certified 1949-D/S nickels at both services combined. Pastel iridescence covers satiny, unmarked surfaces in shades of green, blue, rose, violet, magenta, and orange. Population: 7 in 67 (2 in 67+), O finer (8/21).
PCGS# 38511 Base PCGS# 4039
3085
]
PROOF JEFFERSON NICKEL
1939 Jefferson Nickel, PR68 Reverse of 1938
1939 Reverse of 1938 PR68 PCGS. CAC. A proof variant that shows the “wavy” steps on Monticello as seen in 1938. This is a truly Superb representative that has a colorful, rainbow-like toning scheme at the peripheries on each side. Beautifully original, there are no mentionable marks or spots. Population: 20 in 68, 0 finer. CAC: 3 in 68, 0 finer (7/21).
Ex: New York Signature (Heritage, 7/2004), lot 5689; Dallas Signature (Heritage, 11/2005), lot 2052; Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 6/2013), lot 4406.
NGC ID# 22YB, PCGS# 4176
3086
EARLY HALF DIMES
1795 Flowing Hair Half Dime, VF30 V-5, LM-8, Obverse Die Crack
3087 1795 V-5, LM-8, R.3, VF30 PCGS. LM-8 is one of the two most frequently seen 1795 half dime varieties, distinctive for a heavy, bisecting die crack that runs from the Y in LIBERTY to the 7 in the date. This midgrade example displays uniform wear with most major details remaining. Deep olive-gold and lilac-gray patina characterizes each side.
NGC ID# 22ZV, PCGS# 38592 Base PCGS# 4251
1797 16 Stars Half Dime, Fine 12 V-4, LM-2
1797 16 Stars, V-4, LM-2, R.4, Fine 12 PCGS. One of four 1797 half dime varieties and the final year of coinage for the Small Eagle reverse on this denomination. LM-2 is often weakly struck, as seen here, with softness on the central portion of Liberty’s portrait and on the eagle. This piece displays mottled olive-gray and russet-gold patina with minimal abrasions.
NGC ID# 22ZZ, PCGS# 38598 Base PCGS# 4259
1800 V-1, LM-1 Half Dime, VF25 Multicolor Patina
3088
1800 V-1, LM-1, R.3, VF25 PCGS. LM-1 is the most plentiful variety of the 1800 half dime, commonly encountered in type collections as a representative of the first-year Heraldic Eagle reverse. This piece displays blue-green, lilac, and golden-olive toning over evenly worn surfaces. Localized strike weakness is seen on the eagle’s right (facing) wing and Liberty’s bust, as usual.
NGC ID# 2326, PCGS# 38601 Base PCGS# 4264
3089
22 Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
BUST HALF DIMES
SEATED HALF DIMES
1829 V-3, LM-2 Half Dime MS65 Prooflike
Ex: Green, Newman
3090
1829 V-3, LM-2, R.1, MS65 Prooflike NGC. Ex: “Col.” E.H.R. Green, Eric P. Newman. The LM-2 die pair was utilized for both proof and business strike half dimes in 1829, and this Gem, designated Mint State by NGC, was considered a proof by its famous prior owners. This early die state piece displays clash marks but no die cracks. The flashy fields are lightly toned silver-gray and the margins are powder-blue. The strike is razor-sharp.
Ex: Selections From the Eric P. Newman Collection, Part II (Heritage, 11/2013), lot 33035; Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 9/2014), lot 3916.
NGC ID# 232B, PCGS# 38613 Base PCGS# 4276
1833 Half Dime, Dazzling MS66+ V-3, LM-4.1
3091
1833 V-3, LM-4.1, R.2, MS66+ PCGS. CAC. The 3s in the date are widely spaced, and the O in OF is both repunched and positioned above UN below. This outstanding Premium Gem is remarkably lustrous and displays full strike definition. Dazzling surfaces are largely silver with splashes of steel patina. Struck from clashed, uncracked dies. Population (all varieties): 28 in 66 (3 in 66+), 15 finer. CAC: 12 in 66, 9 finer (9/21).
NGC ID# 232F, PCGS# 38693 Base PCGS# 4280
3092
1849/8 FS-301 Half Dime, MS66+ High-End Overdate Example
1849/8 V-1, FS-301, MS66+ PCGS. CAC. The Guide Book and PCGS refer to this variety as 1849/6, while the Cherrypickers’ Guide calls it an 1849/8 overdate. Whichever it is, there are clear underdigits beneath 49 in the date. The present Premium Gem maintains its original brilliance, showing only scattered accents of natural golden color. Mint luster is frosty and vibrant, undiminished by age, and strike detail is bold on the head, stars, and wreath. Overtly high-end for the grade.
NGC ID# 233D, PCGS# 38738 Base PCGS# 4343
1851-O Half Dime, MS65 A PCGS CoinFacts Plate Coin
3093
1851-O MS65 PCGS. This is one of the coins pictured on the PCGS CoinFacts website. The obverse features a beautiful medley of cobalt-blue, orange, violet, and magenta tones, while the reverse exhibits similar colors but in considerably lighter hues. Both sides are generally well-struck for a New Orleans product of the period. Just a touch of incompleteness occurs on Liberty’s head, the bow knot, and a few of the wreath leaf tips. Remarkably clean and undeniably appealing. Population: 6 in 65 (1 in 65+), 3 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 233], PCGS# 4348
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7, 2021 | 1:00PMCT —_23
1867-S Half Dime, Well-Preserved MS65 Low-Mintage Issue, Seldom Seen So Fine
3094
1867-S MS65 PCGS. V-1a, showing repunching on the top of the lower base of the 1. Some lumpy die clash marks also appear nearby, below Liberty’s rock, from the reverse upper wreath. The surfaces are well-preserved and show attractive dusky golden-gray patina. Only 120,000 examples of this issue were produced, and few survive as fine as this remarkable Gem example. Population: 6 in 65, 2 finer (7/21).
Ex: Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 2/2016), lot 3765.
NGC ID# 234M, PCGS# 4391
PROOF SEATED HALF DIME
3095
1867 Half Dime, PR65 Ultra Cameo Only Two Coins Certified Finer
1867 PR65 Ultra Cameo NGC. This is a virtually all-brilliant, high-contrast Gem half dime from a proof mintage of 625 coins. Just a few delicate splashes of rose-violet and golden accents appear around the borders. This is the sole PR65 Ultra Cameo example certified at NGC. Only two coins, one each in PR66 and PR67, both in Ultra Cameo, are finer at that service. None are finer at PCGS (8/21).
NGC ID# 2364, PCGS# 94450
24
EARLY DIMES
1796 JR-1 Dime, VF25 Sharp Definition on Both Sides
3096
1796 JR-1, R.3, VF25 PCGS. JR-1 represents almost half of the known 1796 dime survivors, and most off those are quickly identified by a mountain-shaped cud at star 1. In all, 15 obverse stars are positioned 8 left, 7 right, with the right-side stars crowded together. 1 is distant from 769 in the date. This is a pleasing silver- gray example with a sharp definition throughout both sides despite moderate wear and the late die state. Traces of golden toning glow softly beneath evenly distributed silver-gray patina. More than half of the eagle’s wing feathers are defined, with strong rims and dentils in most areas.
NGC ID# 236B, PCGS# 38742 Base PCGS# 4461
1805 JR-2 Dime, XF45 Faint Signs of Luster Remain
3097
1805 4 Berries, JR-2, R.2, XF45 PCGS. JR-2 is most easily distinguished from JR-1 by the number of berries on the reverse olive branch (four instead of five). This Choice XF example is ideal for type purposes. The strike is bold in the centers and shows little wear, with tiny remnants of luster clinging to the most protected fields immediately around the obverse stars. Olive-gray, amber-gold, and russet hues adorn each side.
NGC ID# 2368S, PCGS# 38769 Base PCGS# 4477
Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
BUST DIMES
PROOF SEATED DIMES
1821 Large Date Dime, MS64 JR-1, Lightly Toned and Lustrous
1859 Dime, Multicolor PR66+ Beautiful CAC Proof
3098
1821 Large Date, JR-1, R.2, MS64 NGC. Ex: Reed. Light chestnut and powder-blue toning graces this smoothly frosted near-Gem. A thin vertical mark concealed near the top of the cap and a few minute slide marks on the chin are all that limit the grade. The strike is sharp except at stars 1 to 3, where an early stage die crack at the outer points begins to form. Byron Reed was a farsighted 19th century real estate investor who famously bequeathed his collection to the city of Omaha, Nebraska. Census: 27 in 64, 12 finer (9/06).
Ex: Byron Reed Collection (Christies, 10/96), lot 279; FUN Signature (Heritage, 1/2007), lot 2542.
NGC ID# 236Y, PCGS# 38791 Base PCGS# 4496
3099
1829 Capped Bust Dime, MS64 Medium 10C, JR-12
1829 Medium 10C, JR-12, R.3, MS64 PCGS. The Philadelphia Mint struck a large production of 770,000 Capped Bust dimes in 1829, with 12 die varieties known for the date. This coin represents the JR-12 variety, with a Straight Neck 2 in the date and two pale jules in the shield. This attractive Choice example exhibits sharply detailed design elements throughout, with a faint die crack through stars 12 and 13. The well-preserved brilliant surfaces are lustrous and appealing. Population: 11 in 64, 9 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 2378, PCGS# 38838 Base PCGS# 84511
3100
1859 F-101, R.4, PR66+ PCGS. CAC. Scarce, from the second year of proof set production for purposeful sale to collectors. The Premium Gem surfaces yield deep reflectivity in the fields, highlighted by vivid sun-gold, amber, violet, blue, and sea-green toning. The strike is sharp, and the frosty devices are devoid of contact marks. A Cameo designation might have been awarded were it not for the beautiful toning throughout. Population: 17 in 66 (3 in 66+), 1 finer. CAC: 4 in 66, 2 finer (8/21).
PCGS# 538999 Base PCGS# 4748
3101
1873 Open 3, Arrows Dime, PR66 Two-Year Proof Type
1873 Arrows, F-102, R.4, PR66 NGC. Tiny die lumps on Liberty’s leg, east of the shield corner, attribute the Fortin-102 die pair. The marriage coined both proofs and circulation strikes. This well struck specimen reveals exquisite rose-red, sea-green, and straw-gold toning when it is rotated beneath a light. The reverse patina is particularly attractive. Census: 10 in 66, 4 finer (8/21). Ex: Summer FUN Signature (Heritage, 7/2016), lot 3808.
PCGS# 539033 Base PCGS# 4769
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7, 2021 | 1:00PMCT — 25
1879 Seated Dime, PR68 A Top-Grade Example None Finer at Either Service
3102
1879 F-102, R.3, PR68 NGC. A total of 1,100 proofs were struck in 1879, a significant adjunct to the meager 14,000-piece circulation strike mintage of that year. Deep blue and purple tones coalesce over each side and provide this Superb Gem proof with undeniable eye appeal. Aside from trivial softness on the top-left corn stalk, the strike is pinpoint-sharp. This is a seldom-offered opportunity to obtain a top-grade 1879 proof example. It is tied for finest-known with just three other non-Cameo proofs at NGC. Census: 4 in 68, 0 finer (8/21).
PCGS# 539043 Base PCGS# 4776
PROOF BARBER DIMES
3103
1896 Barber Dime, PR66+ Ultra Cameo Extremely Rare Any Finer
1896 PR66+ Ultra Cameo NGC. Only 762 proof Barber dimes were struck in 1896. This Plus-graded Premium Gem exhibits razor- sharp definition on all design elements and the deeply mirrored fields contrast profoundly with the richly frosted devices to produce a stunning cameo effect when the coin is tilted in the light. The virtually flawless surfaces add to the terrific eye appeal. Census: 2 in 66 Ultra Cameo (1 in 66+), 2 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 23G9, PCGS# 94880
26
1912 Barber Dime, PR67 Registry Grade Cameo Example
1912 PR67 Cameo NGC. The Philadelphia Mint struck a small mintage of 700 proof Barber dimes in 1912. As might be expected, the issue is quite elusive in high grade today, especially with Cameo surfaces. This spectacular Superb Gem proof displays razor-sharp design elements and deeply mirrored fields that contrast boldly with the frosty devices. The surfaces are impeccably preserved and eye appeal is terrific. Census: 4 in 67 Cameo (2 in 67%, 1 in 67+), 2 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 23GT, PCGS# 84896
ROOSEVELT DIME
1955-D Dime, MS68 Full Bands Beautifully Toned Among the Finest Certified
3105 1955-D MS68 Full Bands NGC. Among the finest Full Bands
examples certified and a rarity as such, this Registry-grade 1955-D Roosevelt dime displays beautifully luminous, multicolor surfaces. Both sides are pristine. Delicate lavender and powder-blue interior hues cede to more vivid rainbow color in the margins. Eye appeal is stunning. Census: 5 in 68 (1 in 68%) Full Bands, 0 finer (8/21). NGC ID# 3TLH, PCGS# 85110
Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
EARLY QUARTER
3106
1807 B-1 Quarter Dollar, XF40 Attractive Draped Bust Example CAC Endorsed
1807 B-1, R.2, XF40 PCGS. CAC. Tompkins Die State 5/2. Block 8 in the date. A late die state, with the obverse die lapped, showing smaller stars and some detail at the lower hair curls removed. Weak dentils at the upper obverse are typical for the variety, and the edge reading is missing along the bottom edge from a worn collar die. Beautiful old-silver color deepens slightly in protected areas, while the smooth and attractive surfaces show remarkably few marks for the grade. This is an essentially problem-free and well-defined example, ideal for a carefully assembled circulated set. CAC endorsement confirms high quality for the assigned grade level.
NGC ID# 23RE PCGS# 38939 Base PCGS# 5316
SEATED QUARTERS
3107
1839 Seated Quarter, MS63 No Drapery, Closed Claws Reverse
1839 No Drapery MS63 PCGS. Briggs 2-B. Closed Claws Reverse. These second-year Seated Liberty quarters were saved to a slightly lesser degree than their first-year counterparts, but collectors should still be able to locate a Mint State example with some patience. Olive-gold and gunmetal-gray patina is more pronounced on the reverse than it is on the obverse. Partial luster shines through on each side. The impression is bold overall with a few points of softness on Liberty’s head and foot. The eagle is razor- sharp by comparison. Population: 18 in 63, 15 finer (9/21).
NGC ID# 23SF, PCGS# 5392
1857 Seated Quarter, MS66 Attractive Original Toning
3108
1857 MS66 PCGS. Autumn-brown and harvest-gold obverse toning transitions to a window of emerald-green and silver, while the reverse displays frosty brilliance at the center with golden- brown borders. More than 9.6 million quarters were struck by the Philadelphia Mint in 1857, although Premium Gem survivors are scarce and finer coins are seldom offered. This example is sharply struck including sharp definition at Liberty’s head and throughout the surrounding stars. Only a few tiny ticks are seen under a loupe. Population: 45 in 66 (7 in 66+), 12 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 23TE, PCGS# 5442
1868 Quarter, MS64 Strong Strike
3109
1868 MS64 PCGS. Briggs 1-A. This single die pair was used to manufacture all 29,400 circulation-strike quarters at the Philadelphia Mint in 1868. The date slopes markedly downward. Dusky golden-orange patina blankets partially brilliant surfaces. The devices exhibit mostly full detail. Just a hint of softness occurs at the upper obverse, particularly stars 4 through 7. Population: 9 in 64, 7 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 23UF, PCGS# 5472
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7,2021 | 1:00PMCT — 27
PROOF SEATED QUARTERS
BARBER QUARTERS
1880 Seated Quarter, PR67 Ex: Eliasberg
3110 1880 PR67 PCGS. CAC. Ex: Eliasberg. Type One Reverse.
Lustrous silver centers meld into iridescent blue and flashy amber- gold at the rims. Considerable field-device contrast suggests Cameo consideration, although with or without the designation this Superb Gem proof radiates original eye appeal. The 1880 issue was produced during an era when Morgan silver dollars were struck by the millions, largely to the neglect of silver quarters and halves. Speculators and dealers seized on the low circulation strike mintages, while proofs were struck in larger-than-normal quantity (riding the coattails of an extra-large mintage of 1880 Trade dollars). This is a boldly struck survivor of the 1,335 proof quarters struck, complementing just 13,600 business strikes. Population: 15 in 67 (2 in 67+), 4 finer. CAC: 6 in 67, 2 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 23XC, PCGS# 5581
1885 Quarter Dollar, PR67 Remarkable Preservation
3111
1885 PR67 PCGS. CAC. Glittering silver mirrors surround the lightly frosted portrait of Liberty, while a narrow band of blue- gray toning shares space with golden accents at the borders. The reverse is more extensively toned in lilac-gray and golden shades, revealing glassy-mirrored fields when viewed at an angle. There are no bothersome hairlines seen on either side of this Superb Gem proof. The strike is sharp except at stars 8 through 11, which lack their full central detail. Eye appeal is exceptional as indicated by CAC endorsement. Population: 7 in 67 (2 in 67+), 0 finer. CAC: 4 in 67, O finer (8/21).
NGC 1D# 23XH, PCGS# 5586
28
1893 Barber Quarter, MS66 Rare Any Finer
3112 1893 MS66 PCGS. Nearly 10 million Barber quarters were struck
in 1893, with more than half of them at the Philadelphia Mint and the balance produced by the San Francisco and New Orleans branches. This Philadelphia example is among the finest known of the issue. Extremely lustrous, brilliant-white surfaces are lightly frosted and pristine. Not a bit of toning exists on the mark-free, silver surfaces. The strike is full with no weakness on the eagle, shield, or stars and high rims. Population: 26 in 66 (12 in 66+), 3 finer (7/21).
Ex: Atlanta Signature (Heritage, 2-3/2014), lot 3408.
NGC ID# 23XW, PCGS# 5604
1893-S Barber Quarter, MS66+ Exceptional Color
3113 1893-S MS66+ NGC. Mintmark far right, one of three different
positions noted by David Lawrence. The 1893-S quarter is scarce in Mint State and most such pieces grade MS64 or lower. This Premium Gem example is far finer than most collectors will ever lay eyes on. The strike is bold throughout and the surfaces are free of distracting abrasions. Vibrant mint luster illuminates deep ocean-blue peripheral toning and warm gold and violet central hues. Census: 3 in 66 (2 in 66+), 1 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 23XY, PCGS# 5606
1901-S Quarter Dollar, VG Details Strong Detail for the Grad
0
3114 1901-S — Cleaned — NGC Details. VG. Strong VG details
leave most of LIBERTY readable, save for the E and half of the B and R. Golden-gray surfaces are smooth and pleasing to the unaided eye, although a loupe reveals hairlines that betray an old cleaning. The 1901-S is one of the most challenging acquisitions in the Barber quarter series, and collectible examples such as the present are in constant demand.
Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
PROOF BARBER QUARTERS
1902 Quarter, PR68 Tied for Finest at Both Services
3115
1902 PR68 NGC. CAC. Rainbow toning covers the obverse in shades of yellow, orange, blue, violet, and green. The reverse is slightly less exotic with swathes of crimson and pastel blue. Few contact marks appear beneath the patina. This was the first year that Mint officials began producing proofs with a brilliant finish. The issue is practically impossible to locate with any degree of cameo contrast, affirming this Superb Gem’s status as one of the finest obtainable examples of the date. Census: 5 in 68, 0 finer (8/21). NGC ID# 242H, PCGS# 5688
1903 Quarter, PR67+ Cameo Sensational Colors, Bold Contrast
3116
1903 PR67+ Cameo PCGS. CAC. The proof mintage was 755 pieces, and while there are some spectacular 1903 Barber quarter proofs known to survive, one can hardly imagine a more impressive Superb Gem proof than this richly contrasted, beautifully toned example with the PCGS Plus designation and CAC endorsement. Frosted golden centers meet jewel-like reflectivity of undisturbed cerulean-blue fields, accented by ruby-gold hues. The strike is razor- sharp. Population: 3 in 67+ Cameo, 7 finer. CAC: 9 in 67, 8 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 242], PCGS# 85689
1908 Barber Quarter, PR67 Colorfully Toned
SUNG
1908 PR67 PCGS. CAC. This Superb Gem proof showcases rich, colorful patina in shades of green, blue, purple, and orange. There is a strong degree of reflectivity in the fields, though minimal field- device contrast is typical of the era. This is a carefully preserved and highly appealing Barber quarter from a mintage of only 545 proofs. Population: 21 in 67 (6 in 67+), 8 finer. CAC: 10 in 67, 6 finer (7/21).
Ex: Central States Signature (Heritage, 4/2015), lot 4222.
NGC ID# 242P, PCGS# 5694
1911 Quarter, PR67 Cameo Beautifully Contrasted
3118 1911 PR67 Cameo PCGS. A beautifully struck Superb Gem proof, showing stark cameo contrast on each side with a delicate champagne glow overall. The fields are liquidlike and show no obtrusive hairlines, and the devices have subtle satin luster. The 1911 proof is seldom offered this fine as a Cameo, and higher-grade er are rare. Population: 14 in 67 (1 in 67+) Cameo, 4 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 242T, PCGS# 85697
STANDING LIBERTY QUARTERS
1916 Standing Liberty Quarter Attractive Color, Fine Details
3119 1916 — Obverse Scratched — NGC Details. Fine. Collectible examples of the 1916 Standing Liberty quarter are always in demand, particularly with original surfaces. This pewter-gray example displays smooth surfaces and pleasing color. The lower half of the date is clear. A thin, radial pinscratch is visible at certain angles running through the Y in LIBERTY, but it is minor. The obverse rim has a pair of small nicks over the B, and a few other small marks are noted on Liberty’s neck and on the left gateway wall.
1923-S Quarter, MS62 Above-Average Strike
3120 1923-S MS62 PCGS. The 1923-S is a better date in the Standing Liberty quarter series. This Mint State example displays brilliant luster and satiny surfaces, with minimal abrasions. Liberty’s head shows sharp temple definition, but the area of Liberty’s ear is weak. The shield rivets are nearly complete. Collector-grade Mint State examples of this San Francisco issue are in constant demand.
NGC ID# 243k, PCGS# 5744
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7, 2021 | 100PMCT 29
1927-S Standing Liberty Quarter, AU58 Low-Mintage Key
3121
1927-S AU58 PCGS. From a small production of 396,000 pieces, the 1927-S Standing Liberty quarter is a low-mintage key to the series. This impressive near-Mint specimen exhibits just a trace of friction on the well-detailed design elements, with a touch of the usual softness on the shield rivets and eagle’s breast. The lightly abraded surfaces retain much original mint luster and the overall presentation is most attractive.
NGC ID# 243W, PCGS# 5764
3122
1927-S Quarter Dollar, MS63 Collectible Mint State Example
1927-S MS63 PCGS. A brilliant, satiny Mint State example of this semikey San Francisco issue. Light abrasions define the grade but none are individually bothersome. The usual strike softness occurs on the shield rivets and the leading edge of the eagle’s left (facing) wing. Liberty’s temple is sharp, but the area of the ear is incomplete. From a limited mintage of 396,000 pieces.
NGC ID# 243W, PCGS# 5764
1950 Quarter, MS68 The Sole Finest Certified
3124 1950 MS68 NGC. It is difficult to envision a more visually
appealing example of the 1950 Washington quarter. In fact, this Superb Gem is unrivalled, standing alone atop the certified populations at both services combined. Rainbow toning colors the obverse, leaving the reverse essentially brilliant. Both sides are pristine. Census: | in 68, 0 finer (9/21).
NGC ID# 245S, PCGS# 5841
1951-D Washington Quarter, MS67+ Just Two Coins Finer at PCGS
3125 1951-D MS67+ PCGS. CAC. Vivid shades of golden-orange and
lavender-gray toning enhance the impeccably preserved obverse of this Plus-graded Superb Gem, while the reverse remains essentially brilliant. The design elements are sharply detailed throughout and both sides radiate vibrant mint luster, with outstanding eye appeal. Population: 22 in 67+, 2 finer. CAC: 44 in 67, 0 finer (8/21). NGC ID# 245X, PCGS# 5847
WASHINGTON QUARTERS
3123 1936-D MS67 NGC. CAC. A Registry-grade example of this
1936-D Washington Quarter, MS67 CAC-Approved Superb Gem
conditionally challenging Denver issue, from a mintage of 5.3 million pieces. This spectacular Superb Gem exhibits well- detailed design elements and virtually pristine brilliant surfaces, with vibrant mint luster on both sides. Eye appeal is outstanding. Census: 16 in 67 (2 in 67+), 0 finer. CAC: 15 in 67, 0 finer (8/21). NGC ID# 244H, PCGS# 5801
30
1963-D Quarter, Toned MS67+ Just One Coin Graded Finer
3126 1963-D MS67+ PCGS. Vibrant rainbow toning is a hallmark
of this Plus-graded Superb Gem Washington quarter. So is its outstanding preservation, which is surpassed by only a single other coin between both services combined despite a mintage in excess of 135.2 million coins. Satiny luster shines through the patina on each side. Population: 35 in 67 (6 in 67+), 1 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 246T, PCGS# 5875
Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
EARLY HALF DOLLARS
BUST HALF DOLLARS
1795 Flowing Hair Half Dollar, Fine 15 Pleasing O-102 Die Pair
1808 O-106 Half Dollar, AU58 Nicely Toned, Intermediate Die State
3127
1795 2 Leaves, O-102, T-26, R.3, Fine 15 PCGS. Tompkins Die State 1/1. An early die state, with no vertical crack through E of LIBERTY. The surfaces are Choice for the grade, featuring deep, sea-green and tan obverse toning, and rich, brownish-gray shades on the reverse. A few light adjustment marks can be seen along the obverse border, and faint hairlines are visible on each side. The obverse is especially sharp — approaching VF definition — while the reverse falls in the VG range, a trait of the O-102 die pair.
Ex: Bayside New York Collection/ANA Signature (Heritage, 7-8/2008), lot 364.
NGC ID# 24E7, PCGS# 39215 Base PCGS# 6052
1807 Draped Bust Half, MS61 0-106, Condition Census Coin
3128
1807 Draped Bust, O-106, T-6, R.3, MS61 NGC. Tompkins Die State 2/3. The obverse is in its second of three uses, sharing duty with O-105 and the scarce O-107. The reverse appears only for this single die marriage, hampered by die clashing and subsequent die cracks. This Mint State example shows multiple die clashing and heavy reverse die cracks. The obverse is cracked as well, although soldiered on for one more brief use before failure. This attractive, smooth coin displays essentially full luster, with vivid peripheral gold, lilac, and blue album toning on both sides. The reverse has a bit of old build-up at the final S of STATES. The strike is surprisingly sharp given the late die state and multiple die breaks. Steve Herrman’s Spring 2021 reference lists this exact coin in the fifth slot of the Condition Census, behind four other Mint State examples. The Tompkins’ reference has it listed fourth in the Census.
Ex: The Westmoreland County Collection of Early Bust Halves, 1794- 1807 | FUN Signature (Heritage, 1/2008), lot 1405.
NGC ID# 24EM, PCGS# 39345 Base PCGS# 6079
3129
1808 O-106, R.3, AU58 NGC. Ex: Link. The E in AMERICA is sharply recut, and a centering dot sits like a pea on the eagle's shoulder. Attractive album toning graduates from deep-brown to rainbow hues as it transitions to the inner star points. Smooth, silver-gray surfaces then prevail through the centers. As often seen, central strike weakness exists at Liberty’s neck curls and the eagle’s head. Faint evidence of brief circulation flattens a few eagle feathers, joining a few wispy field abrasions. This is an intermediate die state, with a long, semicircular crack from the rim through Liberty’s portrait and cap, but but no adjoining crack from star 9. The reverse lacks a late-developing crack from 5 to the stem. The Steve Herrman census shows several AU58 coins tied as O-106 leading examples, with all finer examples occupying the late die state O-106a listing.
NGC ID# 24EP, PCGS# 39368 Base PCGS# 6090
1813 Half Dollar, MS64 O-107a, Wild Die Cracks
3130
1813 O-107a, R.1, MS64 NGC. CAC. Myriad spidery die cracks across both sides confirm the variety and late die state for this near- Gem Capped Bust half dollar. Although Overton-107a is relatively plentiful, MS64 qualifies for the low end of the Condition Census. Both sides are richly toned in silver and gunmetal-blue patina. Definition is impressively bold, and preservation is excellent. The fields are practically mark-free.
NGC ID# 24EZ, PCGS# 39468 Base PCGS# 6103
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7, 2021 | 1:00PMCT 31
1822 O-108a Half Dollar, MS64+ Attractive Toning, Great Strike
3131 1822 O-108a, R.3, MS64+ PCGS. A pair of lengthy die cracks — one on the obverse, one on the reverse — define the late die state of O-108a. Star 7 touches the cap front, while R and I of AMERICA nearly touch at their bases. This is a pinpoint-sharp example, boldly struck, with smooth and semireflective fields throughout both sides. A blaze of orange-gold toning envelopes Liberty’s head and the surrounding fields, while lilac-gray shades are seen elsewhere. Subtle iridescence adds to the colorful eye appeal. This borderline Gem appears to be the second-finest O-108a, outranking the Eliasberg example by the PCGS Plus designation.
NGC ID# 24FG, PCGS# 39595 Base PCGS# 6129
1827 Capped Bust Half, MS63 O-109, Square 2, ‘Neck Dots’
3133 1827 Square Base 2, O-109, Low R.4, MS63 PCGS. CAC. A scarce 1827 die marriage, most easily identified by a series of “neck dots” near Liberty’s ear. Frosted silver luster flashes on both sides of this Select Uncirculated example, with natural silver-gray toning at the borders. As usually seen for the variety, the strike is up and down at the peripheries, with some stars sharp and others flat. Likewise, the lower-right reverse border is weak at the the arrowheads and C of the denomination. Nearly all else is sharply struck, with smooth surfaces free of distracting marks or abrasions. CAC endorsement confirms the high-quality surfaces.
NGC ID# 24FN, PCGS# 39702 Base PCGS# 6144
1824/4 Half Dollar, MS64 O-110, Repunched 4
3132 1824/4 0-110, R.1, MS64 PCGS. CAC. A lovely near-Gem, with
nearly undisturbed surfaces and unencumbered cartwheel luster.
Medium dove-gray color fills the centers, while the margins offer hints of gold and olive patina. The major devices are well struck aside from the eagle’s right (facing) claw, and the obverse stars are not fully defined. Still, the surfaces are beautifully preserved, since only an inconspicuous tiny mark on the cheekbone is barely visible even under magnification. CAC endorsement reinforces the high quality of this near-Gem Uncirculated Bust half.
SEATED HALF DOLLARS
1865 Half Dollar, MS65+ Seldom Offered This Fine
3134 1865 Repunched Date, WB-104, MS65+ PCGS. The lower loop of the 8 shows faint repunching on this variety. As a date, the 1865 Seated half dollar is scarce in MS65 and rare finer. This Plus-graded Gem displays brilliant, frosty mint luster with no major abrasions. The right hand obverse stars exhibit some strike softness, but the central devices are well defined. Population: 15 in 65 (2 in 65+), 9 finer (8/21).
PCGS# 572166 Base PCGS# 6313
1870-CC Half Dollar, Fine 15 Pleasing First-Year Semikey
3135 1870-CC WB-101, Die Pair 2, R.5, Fine 15 PCGS. Pleasing lilac-gray patina adorns each side of this midgrade first-year Carson City half dollar. The surfaces are smooth and evenly worn, with good detail remaining for the grade. The 1870-CC is a semikey date in the Seated half dollar series with a mintage of only 54,617 coins Ex: FUN Signature (Heritage, 1/2005), lot 7331; Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 9/2019), lot 3499. PCGS# 800650 Base PCGS# 6328
32 Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
1877-CC Half Dollar, MS64 Lustrous CC-Mint Type Coin
1889 Half Dollar, MS66 Tied for Second Finest
3136 1877-CC Type Two Reverse, Medium CC, WB-103, Die Pair 6,
R.6, MS64 PCGS. An untoned, softly frosted near-Gem Carson City half dollar, showing sharp detail highlighted by a vibrant cartwheel effect. Trivial luster grazes prevent Gem classification but none are obtrusive. The 1877-CC is scarce in finer grades. Population: 59 in 64 (5 in 64+), 32 finer (7/21).
PCGS# 572250 Base PCGS# 6356
1877-CC Half Dollar, MS64 Repunched Mintmark
3137 1877-CC Type Two Reverse, Medium CC, WB-103, Die Pair
13, R.2, MS64 PCGS. An early die state of this variety, which features the Closed Bud Type Two reverse and a repunched Medium CC mintmark. This is a near-Gem Uncirculated example, with partially prooflike fields and richly frosted central devices. The strike is razor-sharp on both sides. Attractive gold and tan-brown toning visits the margins, while subtle iridescent colors flash across the reflective fields. There are no individually significant marks seen on either side.
PCGS# 800749 Base PCGS# 6356
1879 Seated Liberty Half Dollar, MS65 Vivid Multicolor Toning
3138 1879 Closed Bud, WB-102, MS65 PCGS. The 1879 Seated
Liberty half dollar claims a small mintage of 4,800 pieces, but the issue is not as difficult to locate as the small production total would suggest. This spectacular Gem displays sharply detailed design elements and well-preserved surfaces, with deeply reflective
fields, under vivid shades of emerald-green and cobalt-blue toning.
Population: 45 in 65 (2 in 65+), 76 finer (8/21). PCGS# 572260 Base PCGS# 6361
3139 1889 WB-101 MS66 PCGS. This late Seated Liberty half dollar
survives from a business strike mintage of 12,000 coins. Both sides of this Premium Gem exhibit frosty silver luster and bold design motifs with faint champagne toning, although most observers would say that this piece is untoned. Population: 19 in 66 (1 in 66+), 1 finer (7/21).
Ex: Atlanta Signature (Heritage, 2-3/2014), lot 3912.
PCGS# 572274 Base PCGS# 6371
PROOF SEATED HALF DOLLARS
1873 Seated Liberty Half Dollar, PR65 No Arrows, Closed 3
3140 1873 No Arrows, Closed 3, PR65 PCGS. Only 600 proofs were
struck in 1873 of the No Arrows type. Overshadowed by the two- year Arrows type, the No Arrows proofs are quite elusive in their own right. This piece has sparkling, deeply mirrored fields and each side is beautifully toned. The obverse has bright cherry-red patina with electric-blue around the periphery. The reverse is more traditional with a brilliant center that is surrounded by deep reddish-gold and gunmetal-blue at the margin. Population: 17 in 65, 23 finer (8/21).
Ex: Central States Signature (Heritage, 4/2006), lot 2031.
NGC 1D# 27U8, PCGS# 6431
1874 Seated Liberty Half Dollar, PR64 Short-Lived Arrows Type
3141 1874 Arrows PR64 NGC. Only 700 proof Seated Liberty half
dollars were struck in 1874, all with the popular Arrows design that was employed in 1873 and 1874. This attractive Choice example exhibits well-detailed design elements and well-preserved surfaces that include deeply mirrored fields, beneath mottled shades of amber and steel-blue toning. Census: 50 in 64, 24 finer (8/21). NGC ID# 27UV, PCGS# 6435
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7, 2021 | 1:00 PM CT 33
3142
1877 Half Dollar, Brilliant PR66 Cameo Tied for Finest Certified
1877 PR66 Cameo PCGS. The 1877 is one of the most frequently encountered Seated half dollars as a circulation strike, but the same cannot be said of proofs. Only 510 pieces were struck. This is a dazzling, all-white example with deeply mirrored fields that establish the “black” background for well-frosted devices, a combination that yields substantial cameo contrast. A full strike exists throughout both sides, and there are no mentionable post- Mint contact marks on either side. High-grade proofs are rare. PCGS has only certified seven others as PR66 Cameo, and NGC has graded just three at this high level. PCGS Population: 8 in 66 (2 in 66+) Cameo, 0 finer (8/21).
Ex: FUN Signature (Heritage, 1/2014), lot 4574; PNG Dallas Signature (Heritage, 2/2014), lot 3124; Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 2/2018), lot 3918.
NGC ID# 27UC, PCGS# 86438
3143
1882 Seated Half Dollar PR64 Deep Cameo
1882 PR64 Deep Cameo PCGS. CAC. This amazing near-Gem is brilliant, save for faint gold toning around the borders. Both sides have deeply mirrored fields, and boldly detailed devices that offer considerable mint frost, including the central design motifs and all of the peripheral elements. Population: 6 in 64 (1 in 64+) Deep Cameo, 13 finer. CAC: 4 in 64, 3 finer (7/21).
Ex: Pittsburgh Signature (Heritage, 10/2011), lot 3788.
NGC 1D# 27UH, PCGS# 96443
1890 Half Dollar, PR67 Attractive Original Toning
3144
1890 PR67 PCGS. Original toning in shades of peach-gold, lavender, rose, mint-green, and ocean-blue adorns each side of this Superb Gem proof. Liberty’s temple is slightly soft, but the strike is otherwise sharp throughout. No contact marks or major hairlines are seen. Population: 9 in 67, 0 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 27US, PCGS# 6451
34
BARBER HALF DOLLARS
3145
1892-O Half Dollar, MS64+ Low-Mintage New Orleans Issue
1892-0 MS64+ PCGS. Brilliant, pearlescent silver surfaces display a tinge of golden rim toning, while this first-year New Orleans issue sports the lowest mintage of any O-mint Barber half dollar in the entire series. The 390,000-piece mintage is also the lowest mintage among all mintmarked Barber halves. This near- Gem example is sharply struck with only minor weakness at the right wing junction and talons below. Eye appeal is tremendous. Population: 3 in 64+, 23 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 24LG, PCGS# 6462
3146
1910 Barber Half Dollar, MS65 Scarcer, Low-Mintage Issue
1910 MS65 PCGS. This brilliant, untoned Gem is a scarce and pleasing example of this elusive, low-mintage date. Only 418,000 pieces were produced and the survival rate is low, especially in this state of preservation. Sharply detailed and lustrous, this example displays surfaces that are brilliant-white, frosted, and exceedingly smooth. Only tiny abrasions exist on the coin — none that are significant in any way. The luster is outstanding. Population: 25 in 65 (3 in 65+), 10 finer (7/21).
Ex: Atlanta Signature (Heritage, 2-3/2014), lot 3561.
NGC ID# 24NB, PCGS# 6519
Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
1912-D Half Dollar, MS66+ Among the Finest Certified
3147 1912-D MS66+ PCGS. With a mintage of more than 2.3 million
pieces, the 1912-D is known as a common issue in lesser grades. However, examples are rarely found at this lofty level. This lustrous and frosty, high-end Barber type coin at the Plus-graded Premium Gem level displays vibrant luster and dappled orange-gold, forest- green, and stone-gray toning. The cheekbone shows a few light tusset freckles, and the surfaces are pristine, aside for a single wispy graze on Liberty’s neck. A sharp strike covers both sides, with only a trace of blending at the eagle’s talon. This coin is tied for second in the date and mint Condition Census. Population: 5 in 66+, 1 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 24NH, PCGS# 6525
1914 Barber Half, MS63 Lowest Mintage in the Series
3148 1914 MS63 PCGS. Mint luster shines boldly beneath subtle
golden-gray toning that blankets both sides of this sharply struck, low-mintage half dollar. Just 124,230 pieces were struck, making the 1914 a key to the late-date P-Mint Barbers — always a challenge for series specialists. An equally low 380 proofs add relatively few coins to the total availability of the 1914 in Mint State grades. This Select Uncirculated circulation strike is sure to draw strong attention when it is called. Population: 39 in 63, 70 finer (8/21). NGC ID# 24NN, PCGS# 6530
PROOF BARBER HALF DOLLARS
1893 Barber Half Dollar, PR66 Strong Cameo Contrast
3149
1893 PR66 Cameo PCGS. CAC. Only 792 proof Barber half dollars were struck in 1893 and few survivors display the intense field-device contrast of this delightful Premium Gem. The design elements exhibit sharp definition throughout and the deeply mirrored fields show minimal signs of contact. Delicate champagne- gold toning adds to the outstanding visual appeal. Population: 28 in 66 (3 in 66+) Cameo, 9 finer. CAC: 16 in 66, 8 finer (8/21).
From The Ed’s Treasures Collection.
NGC ID# 24NV, PCGS# 86540
1902 Half Dollar, PR68 Tied for Finest
3150
1902 PR68 NGC. The United States Mint struck 777 proof half dollars for collectors in 1902 — the first year the facility employed an all-brilliant finish for its proof coinage. That was in sharp contrast to proofs it struck during the 19th century, which generally featured stark cameo appearances. Whereas NGC reports 225 non- Cameo submissions, including this PR68, which is tied for finest in the category, only six coins in total have been designated as Cameo (8/21). Neon iridescence graces the obverse, while the reverse is minimally toned with golden patina at the center. Expectedly sharp and predictably clean for the grade.
NGC ID# 24P6, PCGS# 6549
1907 Barber Half Dollar, PR66+ Only 575 Pieces Struck
3151 1907 PR66+ PCGS. Vivid shades of sea-green, cerulean-blue,
silver-gray, and amber toning visit the impeccably preserved surfaces of this delightful Plus-graded Premium Gem. The design elements are sharply detailed, aside from a touch of softness on the right (facing) shield point. Deeply reflective fields shine through the patina. Population: 24 in 66 (4 in 66+), 12 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 24PB, PCGS# 6554
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7, 2021 | 1:00 PM CT 35
1911 Barber Half, PR66 Cameo Elusive in This Grade
3152 1911 PR66 Cameo PCGS. A deeply reflective proof with obvious cameo qualities. The surfaces displays a thin layer of even light amber toning, and just a couple of minor slide marks are seen on the cheek at certain angles. The 1911 proof is scarce this fine with in the Cameo category, and it is rare finer. Population: 21 in 66 (1 in 66+) Cameo, 7 finer (8/21).
Ex: FUN Signature (Heritage, 1/2004), lot 6731. NGC ID# 24PF, PCGS# 86558
WALKING LIBERTY HALF DOLLARS
1920 Walking Liberty Half Dollar, MS65 Rare Any Finer
3153 1920 MS65 PCGS. CAC. The 1920 Walking Liberty half dollar claims a mintage of 6.3 million pieces, making the issue reasonably available in high grade. This delightful Gem exhibits sharply detailed design elements and the lustrous surfaces are free of mentionable distractions. Highlights of lavender-gray, sea-green, and magenta toning add to the outstanding eye appeal. PCGS has graded 26 numerically finer examples. CAC: 14 in 65, 8 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 24R3, PCGS# 6580
1929-S Half Dollar, MS66 Speckled Iridescent Toning
1929-S MS66 PCGS. Speckled iridescent toning colors this Premium Gem half dollar in neon-green, powder-blue, violet, lavender, orange, and golden elements, particularly around the borders. A touch of softness occurs on Liberty’s head, while the branch hand shows strong thumb separation. Both sides are frosty and well-preserved. Population: 70 in 66 (8 in 66+), 2 finer (9/21). NGC ID# 24RD, PCGS# 6590
3154
PROOF WALKING LIBERTY HALF DOLLARS
1936 Walking Liberty Half Dollar, PR65 First Proof Issue in the Series
3155 1936 PR65 PCGS. This lovely Gem features noticeable contrast between the fields and devices, although not enough to warrant a Cameo designation from PCGS. In fact, PCGS has never designated a 1936 proof Walker as Cameo. The fields are deeply mirrored with hints of gold toning, and eye appeal is terrific. We encourage the specialist to give this coin due consideration. Ex: Dallas Signature (Heritage, 11/2006), lot 1005; Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 6/2015), lot 4670. NGC ID# 27V4, PCGS# 6636
1936 Walking Liberty Half Dollar, PR65 Lovely Mirrors, Partially Frosted Devices
1936 PR65 PCGS. This is a gorgeous Gem proof with lovely mirrors and partially frosted devices that generate moderate cameo contrast. The coin is essentially brilliant, save for wisps of pale golden patina that confirm its originality. The 1936 famously serves as the first proof entry in the Walking Liberty half dollar series. Only 3,901 pieces were struck.
NGC ID# 27V4, PCGS# 6636
1936 Half Dollar, PR66 First Walking Liberty Proof
3156
3157 1936 PR66 NGC. CAC. The Philadelphia Mint struck proof Walking Liberty half dollars for the first time in 1936, when a small mintage of 3,901 specimens was produced. This attractive Premium Gem exhibits sharply detailed design elements and well-preserved surfaces, with deeply reflective fields and subtle highlights of lavender and sea-green toning. The quality and eye appeal are confirmed by the CAC sticker.
NGC ID# 27V4, PCGS# 6636
36 Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
3158
1940 Half Dollar, PR68 None Numerically Finer
1940 PR68 PCGS. This is a spectacular, near-flawless Walking Liberty half dollar from a mintage of 11,279 proofs. Perhaps unsurprisingly, none are numerically finer than this one. Delicate powder-blue, lavender, and tan-gold colors gently grace the outer areas, leaving the centers mostly brilliant. Population: 49 in 68 (4 in 68+), O finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 27V8, PCGS# 6640
1940 Walking Liberty Half Dollar, PR68 CAC-Approved Registry Grade Example
ear re —"
3159 1940 PR68 NGC. CAC. The Philadelphia Mint struck a modest
mintage of 11,279 proof Walking Liberty half dollars in 1940. This magnificent PR68 example is among the finest certified, with sharply detailed design elements and deeply reflective fields throughout. The virtually pristine surfaces are highlighted by shades of lime-green and russet toning. Census: 63 in 68 (1 in 68+, 4 in 68%), 0 finer. CAC: 21 in 68, 0 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 27V8, PCGS# 6640
FRANKLIN HALF DOLLARS
1956 Franklin Half Dollar, MS67+ Registry Grade Full Bell Lines Example
3160 1956 MS67+ Full Bell Lines NGC. CAC. From a mintage
of just over 4 million pieces, the 1956 Franklin half dollar is an elusive issue in MS67, with the Full Bell Lines designation, and finer coins are virtually unobtainable. This Plus-graded Superb Gem displays well-detailed design elements, with just a touch of the usual softness on Franklin’s hair, but Full Bell Lines definition on the reverse. The impeccably preserved lustrous surfaces are blanketed in shades of lavender and sea-green toning. Census: 32 in 67 (8 in 67+ Full Bell Lines, 1 in 67%), 0 finer. CAC: 60 in 67 NGC ID# 24TD, PCGS# 86671
1962 Franklin Half Dollar, MS66 Full Bell Lines None Finer at PCGS
3161 1962 MS66 Full Bell Lines PCGS. This spectacular Premium
Gem Franklin dollar exhibits sharply detailed design elements with Full Bell Lines definition. The immaculate, mostly brilliant surfaces radiate vibrant mint luster on both sides, with a few hints of golden-tan toning. Eye appeal is extraordinary. Population: 24 in 66 Full Bell Lines, 0 finer (7/21).
Ex: Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 6/2016), lot 4598.
NGC 1D# 24TR, PCGS# 86682
1963-D Franklin Half Dollar, MS66+ Full Bell Lines
3162 1963-D MS66+ Full Bell Lines PCGS. CAC. The Denver Mint
struck a series-high mintage of more than 67 million Franklin half dollars in 1963, the final year of the design. Despite the large production total, the 1963-D becomes scarce in MS66, and finer coins are virtually unobtainable. This Plus-graded Premium Gem exhibits sharply detailed design elements, with the Full Bell Lines designation. The impeccably preserved surfaces are lustrous and appealing. PCGS has certified only one numerically finer Full Bell Lines specimen. CAC: 17 in 66, 0 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 24TU, PCGS# 86685
PROOF FRANKLIN HALF DOLLARS
1950 Half Dollar, PR67 First Proof Franklin
3163 1950 PR67 PCGS. CAC. The Mint resumed proof set offerings
in 1950, for the first time since 1942. From a mintage of 51,386 pieces, the 1950 Franklin half dollar is the scarcest proof in the series in Superb Gem condition. The present coin is fully struck and brilliant, with deep mirrors and untouched, beautiful surfaces. PCGS has certified 39 finer examples, 38 in PR67+, and only one numerically finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 27VA, PCGS# 6691
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7, 2021 | 1:00 PM CT 37
3164
1952 Franklin Half Dollar, PR68 Cameo Exceptional Quality and Eye Appeal
1952 PR68 Cameo NGC. The Philadelphia Mint struck 81,980 proof Franklin half dollars in 1952, but few survivors can match the quality and eye appeal of the present coin. This delightful PR68 specimen displays sharply detailed design elements throughout and the impeccably preserved brilliant surfaces include deeply mirrored fields that contrast boldly with the frosty devices. Census: 16 in 68 Cameo (1 in 68+, 2 in 68%), 0 finer (8/21).
NGC 1D# 6L9P, PCGS# 86693
3165
1958 Half Dollar, PR68 Ultra Cameo Seldom Offered With Such Strong Contrast
1958 PR68 Ultra Cameo NGC. The proof 1958 Franklin half dollar is common in most Cameo and non-Cameo grades, but Ultra Cameo examples are scarce at all numeric levels. This high-end
Superb Gem is near the Condition Census of Ultra Cameo pieces.
Sharp devices complement mercury-like fields, providing stark white-and-black contrast on each side. The preservation is superb. Census: 20 in 68 Ultra Cameo (2 in 68+, 2 in 68%, 1 in 68+%*), 5 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# CPER, PCGS# 96699
38
EARLY DOLLARS
1795 Flowing Hair Dollar, VF25 B-1, BB-21, Two Leaves Reverse
3166
1795 Flowing Hair, Two Leaves, B-1, BB-21, R.2, VF25 PCGS. Bowers Die State I. A scarce later die state exists, with die clashing visible at the bridge of Liberty’s nose, but this is the usual early die state. Examination under a loupe reveals virtually no marks of significance, as well as an absence of any adjustment marks or other Mint-related anomalies. The coin is well-centered with full dentils and no rim problems of any kind. Glints, of silver, rose, and blue surround the raised elements for strong eye appeal, while bluish- gray toning lightens slightly across the evenly worn high points. As might be expected, a few wispy hairlines exist, but they are not seen by the unaided eye, and of little consequence. This coin is strong for the grade and will please any early dollar specialist.
NGC ID# 24WZ, PCGS# 39986 Base PCGS# 6853
3167
1795 Draped Bust Dollar, VF20 Off-Center Bust, B-14, BB-51
1795 Draped Bust, Off-Center, B-14, BB-51, R.2, VF20 PCGS. Bowers Die State I, an early die state. BB-51 is also known in at least two later die states based on reverse die clashing. Liberty’s top-most curl sits directly below B in LIBERTY, confirming the Off-Center portrait variety. Deep-gray fields surround lighter, tan- gray devices for attractive visual appeal. Occasional charcoal- gray accents are seen on each side, and a few wayward hairlines are visible with magnification beneath the toning. Marks are remarkably absent for the grade, limited to a tiny ticks and a small scrape between E and D of UNITED. The motifs and legends are sharply defined for the assigned grade.
NGC ID# 24X2, PCGS# 39996 Base PCGS# 96858
Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
3168
1798 Heraldic Eagle Dollar, XF45 B-27, BB-113, Sharp for the Grade
1798 Large Eagle, Pointed 9, Close Date, B-27, BB-113, R.2, XF45 PCGS. Bowers Die State II. Most examples of BB-113 exist in this die state, which shows a faint die crack from the dentils to 9 in the date and a somewhat bolder crack through OF on the reverse. The stem of 9 is narrowly recut at its lower-right. This Choice XF example is toned in dappled shades of grayish-blue and the coin is extremely well-struck, with a bold strike that carries over from obverse to reverse. The star centers on both sides are sharp. Only slight wear is seen at the central high points, while marks and abrasions are remarkably few for the assigned grade. Housed in an old green label holder.
NGC ID# 24X6, PCGS# 40030 Base PCGS# 40018
1798 Pointed 9 Dollar, AU50 B-24, BB-124, Heraldic Eagle Reverse
3169
1798 Large Eagle, Pointed 9, B-24, BB-124, R.2, AU50 PCGS.
Bowers Die State II, lightly lapped on the reverse, without obverse die cracks. This appealing Large Eagle type coin displays strong detail throughout the margins, with a touch of strike softness at the centers. Pleasing golden-gray patina deepens slightly at the margins and gathers around the raised elements. The attractive toning is evenly distributed throughout both sides for a well-balanced effect. This well-preserved early dollar lacks adjustment marks
and is free of all but the tiniest of marks from brief circulation.
Original eye appeal and problem-free surfaces easily justify the About Uncirculated grade. NGC ID# 24X6, PCGS# 40041 Base PCGS# 6873
1799 Draped Bust Dollar, VF25 Scarce B-7, BB-156 Variety
3170
1799 7x6 Stars, B-7, BB-156, R.4, VF25 PCGS. Bowers Die State II]. The obverse die is in its first use, and went on to strike five more 1799 varieties (BB-157, BB-161, BB-162, BB-163, and BB-164), although it was lapped and relapped during that long time in service. The reverse die was used only for BB-156 and must have failed early on, given the scarcity of the die pair and the fact that die cracks were already present on this early die state. Deep bluish- gray toning lightens to silver-gray on the high points for extra eye appeal. Smooth and glossy surfaces show few marks, punctuated by a sharp strike throughout both sides.
NGC ID# 24X7, PCGS# 40048 Base PCGS# 6878
STL
1800 Draped Bust Dollar, AU53 B-19, BB-192, ‘AMERICAI’
1800 AMERICAI, B-19, BB-192, R.2, AU53 PCGS. Bowers Die State II. One of two so-named “AMERICAI” varieties — this one with a backwards J-shaped die break that mimics an “I” after the final A in AMERICA.. Obverse die clashing shows “waves” above and below the date. Iridescent colors play beneath attractive, silver-gray toning on this sharply struck example. Only scattered, tiny marks and a hint of wear account for the About Uncirculated grade. The field stars are uniformly sharp, while strong rims and dentils surround both sides. Eye appeal is excellent.
NGC ID# 24X9, PCGS# 40082 Base PCGS# 6892
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7, 2021 | 1:00 PM CT 39
3412
1802 Silver Dollar, Sharp XF40 Narrow Date, B-6, BB-241
1802 Narrow Date, B-6, BB-241, R.1, XF40 PCGS. CAC. Bowers Die State II]. Original old-silver toning exists throughout both sides of this attractive early dollar. Rich, medium-gray toning yields to light-gray shades at the high points, while only moderate wear is seen on Liberty’s hair strands. The field stars remain sharp and E PLURIBUS UNUM is fully readable and bold within its ribbon. Although the BB-241 ranks among the most available early dollars regardless of date, it is seldom encountered any finer at the XF level, here confirmed by its CAC endorsement. This is an ideal type coin and a prize for any early dollar enthusiast.
NGC ID# 24XB, PCGS# 40088 Base PCGS# 6895
SEATED DOLLARS
1868 Seated Dollar, MS63 Ex: Richmond Collection
3173
1868 MS63 NGC. OC-5, Low R.3. Ex: Richmond Collection. Osburn-Cushing Die State a/a. The paltry annual silver dollar mintages of the Civil War years largely disappeared by 1868, when the Philadelphia Mint struck more than 162,000 pieces. However, few Mint State pieces were set aside by numismatists, leading to the conditional rarity of this issue today in high grade. The present coin is well struck overall (but not completely defined over the highpoints), with gray-blue surfaces that show a significant undertone of rose patina. Identifiable by a series of three milling marks in the right obverse field. Census: 4 in 63, 9 finer (8/21).
Ex: Richmond Collection, Part II (David Lawrence, 11/2004), lot 1493; Dallas Signature (Heritage, 11/2005), lot 2224; ANA Signature (Heritage, 3/2007), lot 934.
NGC ID# 24ZB, PCGS# 6961
40
1872-S Dollar, AU50 Reflective Fields
3174 1872-S AU50 PCGS. OC-1, Low R.3. Osburn-Cushing Die
State a/a. With a mintage of only 9,000 pieces, the 1872-S is one of the semikeys to a Seated dollar set, and it is one of only two collectible San Francisco issues in the series. This About Uncirculated example displays bold detail with little wear, while delicate pastel toning graces each side. The fields are semiprooflike. Population: 25 in 50, 40 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 24ZL, PCGS# 6970
PROOF SEATED DOLLAR
1871 Seated Liberty Dollar, PR62 Attractive Cameo Surfaces
3175 1871 PR62 Cameo PCGS. OC-P1, R.2. Osburn-Cushing Die
State a/a. The mintage of 960 proof Seated Liberty dollars in 1871 was small in absolute terms, but fairly generous in the context of the series. This attractive PR62 example exhibits sharply detailed design elements, with some diagnostic die lumps in shield recess 4. The reflective fields contrast boldly with the frosty devices and the surfaces show only minor signs of contact. Population: 8 in 62 Cameo, 38 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 252T, PCGS# 87019
Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
TRADE DOLLARS
PROOF TRADE DOLLARS
3176
1874-CC Trade Dollar, MS62 Rarely Offered With CAC Approval
~~ 5 it
1874-CC MS62 PCGS. CAC. Satiny luster adorns each side of this Mint State Carson City Trade dollar, yielding brilliant color. Myriad small abrasions define the grade, but none are individually bothersome. A small planchet lamination (as struck) is seen between stars 5 and 6. On the reverse, slight strike softness affects the eagle’s right (facing) leg as usual. Although Mint State 1874- CC Trade dollars are occasionally seen, CAC-approved examples are rare. CAC: 4 in 62, 11 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 2532, PCGS# 7035
DUTe
1875 Trade Dollar, MS64 Seldom Encountered in Higher Grades
1875 Type Two Reverse MS64 PCGS. The 1875 Trade dollar claims a smaller mintage of 218,200 pieces, and few high-quality specimens were saved by contemporary collectors. Attractive specimens in MS64 condition, like the present coin, are seldom encountered in today’s market. The lustrous creamy surfaces of this impressive Choice example show only minor signs of contact and the design elements are sharply detailed throughout. Population: 28 in 64 (4 in 64+), 6 finer (7/21).
Ex: Chicago Signature (Heritage, 4/2014), lot 4599.
PCGS# 40107 Base PCGS# 7037
1875-CC Trade Dollar, MS63 Chop Mark, Berry Under Claw
3178
1875-CC Chop Mark, Type One Reverse, MS63 PCGS. Period after FINE. A berry appears under the eagle’s right (facing) claw. The single chop mark occurs in the field above Liberty’s outstretched branch hand. Slightly dusky gold toning accents
mostly silver surfaces. The obverse exhibits scattered alloy spots.
Characteristically struck and minimally abraded. A pleasing Carson City dollar that showcases its history as a legitimate trade coin. PCGS# 517129 Base PCGS# 7038
1873 Trade Dollar, PR64 Cameo Scarce, First-Year Issue
3179
1873 PR64 Cameo PCGS. Clusters of speckled gold and bluish- gray toning appear on the obverse and reverse, decorating the well-mirrored fields and visiting the richly frosted devices. This is the so called “patched letters” reverse — identified by a raised die lump in the middle of the curved portion of the D of UNITED, and an unfinished area below the eagle’s tail. Heavy die lines thread their way through the lower folds in Liberty’s skirt (just above the feet), and they remain prominent from the ocean’s edge to the bail of cotton. This is a Choice contrasted proof with glassy fields and glimpses of subtle iridescence, seldom exceeded at either service. Population: 16 in 64 (2 in 64+) Cameo, 2 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 27YJ, PCGS# 87053
1874 Trade Dollar, PR63 Cameo 700 Pieces Struck, CAC Approved
3180 1874 PR63 Cameo PCGS. CAC. The Philadelphia Mint struck a
small production of 700 proof Trade dollars for collectors in 1874, the second year of the denomination. This CAC-endorsed Select specimen exhibits sharply detailed design elements throughout, with full star centers and fine definition on Liberty’s head. The well-preserved surfaces include deeply reflective fields that contrast boldly with the frosty devices. Vivid shades of sea-green toning enhance the centers, with a ring of cerulean-blue at the borders. Population: 24 in 63 (2 in 63+) Cameo, 36 finer. CAC: 5 in 63, 18 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 27YK, PCGS# 87054
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7,2021 | 1:00PMCT = 41
3181
1882 Trade Dollar, PR63 Delicate Peripheral Toning
1882 PR63 PCGS. Attractive blue and lilac hues cling to the peripheries of this champagne-tinged proof Trade dollar, complementing the satiny luster of the sharply struck devices. The fields are deeply mirrored, showing light hairlines that are consistent with the grade. A pleasing proof type coin.
NGC ID# 27YU, PCGS# 7062
MORGAN DOLLARS
1878 7/8TF Morgan, MS65 Prooflike VAM-36 Strong
3182
1878 7/8TF Strong, VAM-36, MS65 Prooflike NGC. VAMWorld.com states, “The 1878-P VAM-36 is one of the more common 7 over 8 tailfeather varieties. It often comes with DMPL surfaces.” The present Gem is indeed deeply reflective in the fields, brilliant on each side with pleasing cameo contrast. The strike is sharp, and only a few light grazes in the left obverse field prevent an even finer grade. Seldom offered this fine in the Prooflike category.
PCGS# 40215 Base PCGS# 7079
3183
1878-CC Morgan Dollar, MS66 First-Year Branch Mint Issue
1878-CC MS66 PCGS. This frosty Premium Gem is boldly defined and exhibits brilliant silver surfaces without any toning on either side. It is a stunning piece with exceptional eye appeal. Although rather plentiful in this grade, finer examples are extremely rare; PCGS has only certified six numerically finer pieces (8/21). Ex: Central States Signature (Heritage, 5/2009), lot 2940; Los Angeles Signature (Heritage, 8/2009), lot 1830.
NGC ID# 253M, PCGS# 7080
42
1878-S Dollar, MS67 Swirling Luster, Completely Brilliant
3184
1878-S MS67 NGC. Thickly frosted, wholly untoned surfaces deliver partial contrast on the obverse. The coin has the look of having been struck yesterday, with both sides awash in swirling luster and practically free of field marks. There are a couple of ticks on Liberty’s cheek, but not much else. Only a small handful of the nearly 10 million 1878-S Morgan dollars minted have attained this lofty level. Census: 45 in 67 (2 in 67+, 7 in 67 *), O finer (9/21). NGC ID# 253R, PCGS# 7082
3185
1879-CC Morgan Dollar, MS61 City Key
Low-Mintage Carson
“it
1879-CC MS61 NGC. Wisps of soft-gray toning do not inhibit the strong silver luster that resides beneath the subtle natural patina of this Carson City key issue. This is the Normal Mintmark variety, sometimes underrated in comparison to its Capped Die counterpart, but a necessity for a complete Carson City set nonetheless. Only minor marks are seen on this attractive example, with a only brief blending at its high points. Plentiful eye appeal remains.
NGC ID# 253T, PCGS# 7086
3186
1879-CC Dollar, MS62 Brilliant Nevada Semikey
1879-CC MS62 ANACS. Normal Mintmark. Brilliant surfaces showcase a thick layer of mint frost over each side. A few hints of pale golden color occur along the left reverse border. Strike definition is generally good despite a bit of typical central softness, and, as usual, bagmarks are scattered throughout. A pleasing Mint State example of this semikey Carson City issue (756,000 coins struck).
NGC ID# 253T, PCGS# 7086
Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
1880/79-CC Morgan, MS64 Prooflike Cameo-Contrasted CAC Coin
3187 1880/79-CC Reverse of 1878, VAM-4, MS64 Prooflike PCGS. CAC. A Top 100 Variety. VAM-4 is one of the most important acquisitions for advanced Morgan dollar collectors. The variety shows dramatic 79 underdigits within the loops of the 80 in the date. This Choice Prooflike example is scarce, as most VAM-4 representatives lack reflective fields. Finer Prooflike pieces are rare. Brilliant, frosty devices complement mirrored fields, while each side displays only minimal contact marks.
NGC ID# AP7P, PCGS# 41131 Base PCGS# 7109
1880-CC Morgan Dollar, MS66+ Brilliant and Frosted VAM-8 Example
3188 1880-CC Reverse of 1879, 8/7 Dash, VAM-8, MS66+ PCGS. CAC. A dash below the second 8 and a barely visible nub of an ear is seen at the top of the second 8 in the date. Die lumps occupy the centers of the CC mintmark, and a prominent die scratch through M in AMERICA helps identify the VAM-8 variety. This is a brilliant and richly frosted Premium Gem example, with vibrant mint luster and a sharp strike that lacks full details only at a few hair strands above Liberty’s ear. The PCGS Plus designation and CAC endorsement confirm the coin’s well-deserved high grade, which is among the finest for the variety.
PCGS# 41142 Base PCGS# 7100
1880-O Morgan Dollar, MS64+ Lustrous and Fully White
ag
3189 1880-O MS64+ PCGS. CAC. Micro O. The 1880-O is one of those issues that is very difficult to secure as a Gem. Most advanced collectors try to come as close as possible to that lofty level, and an MS64+ with a CAC seal fits the bill. The present example earns its plus sign and green seal with a bold strike, vibrant white surfaces, and relatively few indications of contact.
NGC ID# 2543, PCGS# 7114
1880/79-O Morgan, MS64+ Prooflike VAM-4, Crossbar Overdate
3190 1880/79-O 80/79 Crossbar, VAM-4, MS64+ Prooflike NGC. A Top 100 Variety. Both sides are equally reflective, complementing the frosty devices and brilliant silver color of this high-end near- Gem. The strike is sharp in the centers, and only a few faint grazes in the left obverse field limit the grade. Prooflike 1880-O Morgan dollars are scarce this fine regardless of variety. VAM-4 is a rarity in this grade. Census: 18 in 64 (3 in 64+ Prooflike, 1 in 64%), 1 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 2543, PCGS# 41287 Base PCGS# 7117
1881 Morgan Dollar, MS66+ Extremely Rare Any Finer
3191 1881 MS66+ PCGS. Although the Philadelphia Mint struck more than 9 million pieces, the San Francisco Mint easily exceeded that mintage by 25%. The P-mint coins also lag behind the 1881-S in quality, with few examples exceeding the Premium Gem level. This coin is an exception, with smoothly frosted surfaces, bright mint luster, a sharp strike, and fantastic eye appeal. A hint of gold toning creeps onto the frost-white surfaces. PCGS has certified nine numerically finer examples (8/21).
NGC ID# 2546, PCGS# 7124
1881-CC Morgan Dollar, MS67 Frosty, Brilliant, and Attractive
3192 1881-CC MS67 PCGS. The 1881-CC claims one of the lowest mintages in the Morgan dollar series, at a meager 296,000 pieces. Fortunately, enough examples turned up in the GSA sales to augment the supply considerably, but the issue is still prohibitively rare above the MS67 grade level. This delightful Superb Gem exhibits sharply detailed design elements, with a rich coat of mint frost, and impeccably preserved lustrous surfaces. Eye appeal is terrific. PCGS has graded five numerically finer examples (8/21). NGC ID# 2547, PCGS# 7126
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7, 2021 | 1:00PMCT = 43
1881-CC Morgan, MS66 Deep Mirror Prooflike Stark Cameo Contrast
1881-CC MS66 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. The 1881- CC Morgan dollar is plentiful — more than 147,000 coins were distributed to collectors through the GSA sales of the 1970s. Nonetheless, examples with Deep Mirror Prooflike fields are scarce finer than MS65. This Premium Gem coin displays stark cameo contrast on champagne-tinted surfaces. A lone toning spot beneath the C in AMERICA serves as a pedigree marker. The sharpness of the strike is outstanding, and each side displays exceptional preservation. Population: 73 in 66 (7 in 66+) Deep Mirror Prooflike, 2 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 2547, PCGS# 97127
1882-CC Morgan Dollar, MS67 Tremendous Quality and Eye Appeal
3193
3194 1882-CC MS67 PCGS. The 1882-CC Morgan dollar claims a sizeable mintage for a Carson City issue, at more than 1.1 million pieces. Still, the 1882-CC is scarce at the MS67 grade level and PCGS has only certified one example in higher numeric grade (8/21). This spectacular Superb Gem displays sharply detailed design elements and impeccably preserved lustrous surfaces, with a sliver of emerald-green peripheral toning on both sides.
NGC ID# 254B, PCGS# 7134
1882-O Morgan Dollar, MS66 Prime Condition Rarity in Finer Grades
3195 1882-O MS66 PCGS. From a substantial mintage of more than 6 million pieces, the 1882-O Morgan dollar is not difficult to locate in lower Mint State grades, but the issue is scarce in MS66, and finer coins are prime condition rarities. This delightful Premium Gem displays sharply detailed design elements and impeccably preserved brilliant surfaces, with vibrant mint luster and terrific eye appeal. Population: 92 in 66 (14 in 66+), 8 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 254C, PCGS# 7136
1882-O Morgan Dollar, MS66 Condition Rarity Any Finer
Hae S isi N
ol
3196 1882-O MS66 PCGS. Although plentiful in lower grades, the 1882-O Morgan is scarce in MS66 and a major rarity any finer. This Premium Gem displays softly frosted cartwheel luster with no obvious abrasions. The strike is above average for the issue, and no mentionable toning is present. Population: 92 in 66 (14 in 66+), 8 finer (8/21). Ex: Dallas Signature (Heritage, 11/2017), lot 17375. NGC ID# 254C, PCGS# 7136
1882-O/S Silver Dollar, MS64 VAM-4 Recessed, CAC-Approved
1882-O/S Recessed, VAM-4, MS64 PCGS. CAC. A Top 100 Variety. It seems counterintuitive, but the late die state VAM-4 shows the O/S mintmark more clearly than the early die state VAM-4, which is much scarcer than the late die state. This near- Gem example is clearly the late die state, with extensive freckling on the eagle from die rust and a pair of diagnostic die lines where the cap meets Liberty’s hair behind the ear. The under-mintmark crossbar of S is recessed yet bold. CAC endorsement rewards the lustrous, satin-smooth surfaces and sharply struck devices. A curved area of blue and gold toning decorates the lower-left obverse, with a larger share of similar toning at the upper-left reverse for strong eye appeal.
NGC ID# 254D, PCGS# 133891 Base PCGS# 7138
1883 Morgan Dollar, MS67+ Conditionally Rare in Finer Grades
3197
3198 1883 MS67+ PCGS. The 1883 Morgan dollar is a plentiful issue in grades up to the MS67 level, thanks to its large mintage of nearly 12.3 million pieces, but finer coins are extremely rare. This Plus- graded Superb Gem exhibits razor-sharp definition on all design elements, with some spidery peripheral die cracks on the obverse. The virtually pristine brilliant surfaces are lustrous and appealing. Population: 44 in 67+, 5 finer (8/21). NGC ID# 254G, PCGS# 7142
44 Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
1883-CC Morgan Dollar, MS66 Deep Mirror Prooflike Example
1884-CC Morgan Dollar, MS67 Vividly Toned Obverse, Frosty Luster
3199 1883-CC MS66 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. The Carson City Mint struck a respectable mintage of 1.2 million Morgan dollars in 1883 and the issue was well-represented in the GSA Sales of the 1970s. As might be expected, the 1883-CC is readily available in high grade today. Even in MS66 Deep Mirror Prooflike the issue can only be called scarce, but PCGS has certified only three numerically finer coins within that designation (8/21). This sharply detailed Premium Gem exhibits virtually flawless brilliant surfaces, with deeply reflective prooflike fields and no mentionable distractions.
NGC ID# 254H, PCGS# 97145
1883-S Morgan Dollar, MS64 A Rarity Any Finer
3200 1883-S MS64 PCGS. CAC. A brilliant, radiantly lustrous near- Gem example of this conditionally scarce San Francisco issue. The strike is sharp and remarkably few abrasions are present. The 1883-S is occasionally available in MS64, but seldom with a CAC green label. Finer coins are rare. PCGS lists only 27 higher-grade non-Prooflike submissions. CAC: 87 in 64, 5 finer (8/21). NGC ID# 254K, PCGS# 7148
1884 Morgan Dollar, MS65 Elusive Deep Mirror Prooflike Specimen
1884 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. The 1884 was a high-mintage issue, but only a tiny percentage of Mint State pieces attain “dimple” status, and most such coins grade between MS62 and MS64. This is a brilliant and lustrous Gem with smooth, flashy
3201
fields and one minor strike-through on Liberty’s lower cheek.
Encapsulated in an old green-label holder. Population: 40 in 65 (3 in 65+) Deep Mirror Prooflike, 9 finer (8/21). NGC ID# 254L, PCGS# 97151
3202 1884-CC MS67 PCGS. Beautiful, original multicolor toning across the obverse produces incredible visual appeal on this 1884- CC dollar, helping it earn Superb Gem classification at PCGS. The devices are well struck, and the mint luster is frosty and vibrant. The reverse of the coin is largely brilliant. Under a loupe a keen eye can see a few minor marks on the obverse, but the preservation is nonetheless pleasing. PCGS lists three numerically finer 1884-CC dollars, all non-Prooflike coins (8/21). NGC ID# 254M, PCGS# 7152
1884-S Dollar, AU58+ Sharp, Attractive, and Conditionally Scarce
3203 1884-S AU58+ NGC. Smooth, unabraded and semireflective surfaces maintain their brilliance at the centers with soft blushes of violet and gold border toning. A bit of color appears around the eagle’s talons, as well. The devices are sharply struck and as close to unworn as can be imagined without qualifying for a Mint State grade. One light tick occurs along Liberty’s jawline.
NGC ID# 254P, PCGS# 7156
1885-CC Morgan Dollar, MS66+ Excellent Branch Mint Type Coin
1885-CC MS66+ PCGS. CAC. Despite a low mintage of 228,000 pieces, the 1885-CC Morgan dollar is readily collectible at the MS66 grade level, thanks to its prominent presence in the GSA sales of the 1970s. This Plus-graded Premium Gem displays sharply detailed design elements and virtually flawless surfaces, with vibrant mint luster and vivid highlights of sea-green and magenta toning.
NGC ID# 2548S, PCGS# 7160
3204
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7,2021 | 1:00PMCT = 45
1885-CC Morgan, MS66+ Prooflike Brilliant Cameo Contrast
3205 1885-CC MS66+ Prooflike NGC. Radiant, untoned mint luster adorns the Premium Gem surfaces of this Plus-graded Prooflike Carson City dollar. Sharp devices glisten with mint frost, while the fields display a balance of reflectivity and cartwheel effect. Only a few tiny marks are visible beneath a loupe. The 1885-CC Morgan is scarce in this Prooflike grade, and such coins are rare finer. Census: 36 in 66 (4 in 66+ Prooflike, 1 in 66%), 4 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 2548S, PCGS# 7161
1885-S Morgan Dollar, MS64 Prooflike
3208 1885-S MS64 Prooflike PCGS. CAC. Ex: Key West Collection. This elusive issue is available at the present grade level from time- to-time, but it is rarely found in finer grades. Both sides are brilliant and sharply defined with bright silver surfaces. Excellent field-to- device contrast appears on both sides. Population: 60 in 64 (3 in 64+) Prooflike, 13 finer. CAC: 11 in 64, 1 finer (8/21).
Ex: Central States Signature (Heritage, 4/2014), lot 4795. NGC ID# 254U, PCGS# 7165
1885-S Morgan Dollar, MS65 CAC-Approved Lustrous Example
3206 1885-S MS65 PCGS. CAC. Mintage of Morgan dollars declined at the San Francisco Mint in 1885, to less than 1.5 million pieces. The 1885-S is readily collectible at the MS65 grade level, but the issue becomes elusive in higher grades. This attractive Gem displays sharp definition on all design elements and the well-preserved surfaces radiate vibrant mint luster, with outstanding eye appeal.
NGC ID# 254U, PCGS# 7164
1885-S Morgan Dollar, MS66 Impressive Registry Set Contender
3207 1885-S MS66 PCGS. From a mintage of nearly 1.5 million pieces, the 1885-S Morgan dollar is an elusive issue at the MS66 grade level, and finer coins are virtually unobtainable. This spectacular Premium Gem exhibits sharply detailed design elements and nearly flawless surfaces, with vibrant mint luster and outstanding eye appeal. Population: 84 in 66 (9 in 66+), 2 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 254U, PCGS# 7164
1886-O Silver Dollar, MS64 Outstanding Luster and Sharpness
1886-O MS64 PCGS. Radiant cartwheel luster rolls across nearly brilliant surfaces on this Choice 1886-O Morgan dollar. Such is rarely seen on the 1886-O, and this piece is also better struck than typical for the issue. Only a few faint grazes on the obverse prevent Gem classification. The 1886-O Morgan is relatively elusive in this grade, and finer pieces are almost uncollectible. PCGS lists only four numerically finer examples, including a lone Deep Mirror Prooflike Superb Gem (8/21).
NGC ID# 254W, PCGS# 7168
1888-O Morgan Dollar, MS62 Popular VAM-1B3, Scarface Variety
3209
3210 1888-O Scarface, VAM-1B3, MS62 NGC. CAC. A Top 100 Variety. From a late state of the dies, this attractive MS62 specimen exhibits the massive die crack across Liberty’s cheek that gives this variety its Scarface nickname. This coin offers well-detailed design elements, with just a touch of the usual softness on the hair above the ear. The lightly marked lustrous surfaces are enhanced by attractive shades of blue, magenta, pale gold, and emerald-green toning.
PCGS# 133918 Base PCGS# 87184
46 Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
1888-S Morgan Dollar, MS65 VAM-13, ‘Gouged Eagle’
1889-CC Dollar, AU50 Natural, Minimally Circulated Example
3211 1888-S Gouged Eagle, VAM-13, MS65 PCGS. CAC. A Hit List 40 Morgan dollar and WOW! VAM variety. This Gouged Eagle and Doubled Left Wreath variety was the VAM Discovery of the Year in 2006 and is considered the the most important die gouge dollar except for the 1890-CC Tailbar VAM. Approximately 30 die gouges of various sizes are seen on the reverse, with the most conspicuous ones at the eagle’s left (facing) lower wing and surrounding the eagle’s leg, talons, and arrow fletchings. Brilliant Gem Uncirculated surfaces are lustrous and semireflective. This sharply struck example is housed in an old green label holder with CAC endorsement — one of the finest Gouged Eagles we have seen, and a splendid 1888-S regardless of the variety.
PCGS# 412613 Base PCGS# 7186
1889 Morgan Dollar, MS66+ Natural, Multicolor Toning
3212 1889 MS66+ PCGS. The Philadelphia Mint produced a huge mintage of 21.7 million Morgan dollars in 1889. As might be expected, the 1889 is easily located in grades up to the MS66 level today, but finer coins are rare. This Plus-graded Premium Gem offers well-detailed design elements, with just a touch of the usual softness on the hair above the ear. The well-preserved lustrous surfaces are blanketed in shades of powder-blue, magenta, and golden-tan toning. PCGS has graded 10 numerically finer examples (8/21).
NGC ID# 2558, PCGS# 7188
3213 1889-CC AU50 NGC. This is a delightful, minimally circulated example of the beloved 1889-CC Morgan dollar — a famous low- mintage key to the series. Stone-gray surfaces display faint glimmers of luster around the devices, as well as traces of antique golden patina. Both sides are equally smooth and well-detailed. As many as 325,000 of the 350,000 coins struck may have been melted, partly explaining the issue’s scarcity and popularity.
NGC ID# 2559, PCGS# 7190
1889-CC Morgan, AU Details Important Carson City Key
3214 1889-CC — Cleaned — NGC Details. AU. A slight glossy appearance in the open areas of the fields and on Liberty’s cheek betrays a light cleaning, although elements of natural luster remain in the protected recesses and fields. A hint of light champagne color tints this piece, complementing the well-detailed devices. A collectible example of the key Carson City issue.
1889-0 Silver Dollar, MS65 Prooflike Rarely Seen So Fine
3215 1889-0 MS65 Prooflike NGC. This New Orleans issue is seldom offered with Prooflike fields, and such coins are decidedly rare at the Gem level, with none finer at NGC. This piece displays brilliant, frosty devices with sharp detail, and the fields are vibrant and reflective. There are a few faint marks in the left obverse quadrant, but Liberty’s cheek is pristine. Eye appeal is outstanding. Census: 4 in 65 Prooflike, 0 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 255A, PCGS# 7193
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7, 2021 | 100PMCT = 47
1889-S Morgan Dollar, MS66 Registry Set Contender
3216 1889-S MS66 PCGS. The San Francisco Mint struck a small production of 700,000 Morgan dollars in 1889. As might be expected, the 1889-S is an elusive issue at the MS66 grade level and only one coin has been certified in higher numeric grades at either of the leading grading services (8/21). This delightful Premium Gem exhibits razor-sharp definition on all design elements and the virtually pristine brilliant surfaces are awash in vibrant mint luster.
NGC ID# 255B, PCGS# 7194
1890 Morgan, MS64+ Deep Mirror Prooflike Well-Contrasted and Brilliant
3217 1890 MS64+ Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. CAC. The powerful silver lobby and complicit politicians were in control in 1890, resulting in huge mintages of silver dollars by all mints. The Philadelphia Mint alone struck well over 16 million Morgan dollars. Among that large production were surprisingly few Prooflike and Deep Mirror Prooflike examples that exist today. This is a brilliant, high-end DMPL survivor that earns both the PCGS Plus designation and CAC endorsement. The mirrored fields show only a tiny bit of chatter, and Liberty’s cheek is smoothly frosted. A sharp strike adds to the excellent eye appeal. Population: 12 in 64+ Deep Mirror Prooflike, 12 finer. CAC: 21 in 64, 0 finer (8/21). NGC ID# 255C, PCGS# 97197
1891 Dollar, MS65
1891 MS65 PCGS. Shades of sea-green, ice-blue, magenta, lemon- yellow, and golden-orange cover the obverse. Conversely, the other side of this Gem remains completely brilliant and frosty. Liberty’s cheek and the fields throughout exhibit few serious flaws. Eye appeal is terrific. The coin would be extremely difficult to upgrade with only seven numerically finer examples at PCGS (8/21).
NGC ID# 255G, PCGS# 7204
3218
1891 Morgan Dollar, MS65+ Rarely Seen Finer
3219 1891 MS65+ PCGS. From a substantial mintage of more than 8.6 million pieces, the 1891 Morgan dollar becomes scarce at the MS65 grade level, and finer coins are condition rarities. This Plus-graded Gem displays sharp definition on all design elements and the well-preserved brilliant surfaces are lustrous and appealing. Population: 29 in 65+, 7 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 255G, PCGS# 7204
1891-O Dollar, Brilliant MS65 One Finer Submission at PCGS
3220 1891-O MS65 PCGS. Gem Uncirculated condition serves as the highest collectible grade level for the 1891-O dollar (7.9 million coins struck). A single example is certified numerically finer at PCGS plus three more at NGC (8/21). This piece features distinctly satiny mint luster that radiates over untoned surfaces. Strike definition is typically uneven for this New Orleans issue.
NGC ID# 255], PCGS# 7208 1891-O Dollar, MS64 Prooflike
; BF 1891-O MS64 Prooflike PCGS. CAC. The 1891-O Morgan,
coming from a mintage approaching 8 million pieces, is readily available through near-Gem. Prooflike examples, however, are scarce. Moreover, this issue typically comes weakly struck. The present offering is, therefore, an infrequent opportunity to acquire a prooflike example that exhibits well-struck centers, areas that are usually ill-defined. Additionally, both sides of this brilliant dollar reveal significant field-motif contrast. Population: 13 in 64 (1 in 64+) Prooflike, 0 finer. CAC: 5 in 64, 0 finer (8/21).
Ex: Houston Signature (Heritage, 12/2013), lot 4172.
NGC ID# 255J, PCGS# 7209
3221
48 Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
1891-S Morgan Dollar, MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike Surfaces
3222 1891-S MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. CAC. The 1891-S Morgan dollar is relatively available in Mint State grades, thanks to its mintage of nearly 5.3 million pieces. However, examples with Deep Mirror Prooflike surfaces are definitely elusive. This attractive Choice specimen exhibits sharply detailed, frosty design elements, with well-preserved surfaces that show a remarkable amount of prooflike reflectivity in the fields. Eye appeal is outstanding. Population: 41 in 64 (4 in 64+) Deep Mirror Prooflike, 6 finer. CAC: 14 in 64, 2 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 255K, PCGS# 97211
1892-CC Morgan Dollar, MS64 Vibrant Mint Luster
1892-CC MS64 PCGS. The 1892-CC Morgan dollar claims a large mintage for a Carson City Mint issue, at 1.3 million pieces, but the issue was not heavily represented in the GSA sales of the 1970s. Accordingly, the 1892-CC can be located in MS64 condition without great difficulty, but the issue is elusive in grades above MS65. This attractive Choice example exhibits sharply detailed design elements and well-preserved brilliant surfaces, with vibrant mint luster throughout.
NGC ID# 255M, PCGS# 7214
1892-CC Dollar, MS64 Vibrant Cartwheel Mint Luster
3223
1892-CC MS64 PCGS. Although the 1892-CC was essentially absent from the GSA sales, numerous undistributed bags were transferred to the San Francisco Mint and made available to collectors through the 1940s. Other bags were released in 1955, and the Redfield Hoard contained between two and three thousand 1892-CC dollars that hit the marketing in the 1970s. This is a carefully preserved, near-Gem example — probably not from LaVere Redfield’s accumulation based on its minimally abraded, richly frosted devices. Brilliant, semireflective fields surround the sharply struck motifs for strong contrast and great eye appeal.
NGC ID# 255M, PCGS# 7214
3224
1892-CC Dollar, MS64 Clean Fields
3225 1892-CC MS64 PCGS. CAC. The 1892-CC did not benefit from the GSA releases of the 1970s. Only a single coin was dispersed through that program. Uncirculated examples that have found their way into collectors’ hands are typically in lower grades with myriad bagmarks. This near-Gem is surprisingly clean. A single set of reeding marks on the cheek stands in the way of a full MS65 assessment. Both sides are brilliant and strongly struck at the centers with cartwheel mint frost.
NGC ID# 255M, PCGS# 7214
1892-S Morgan, AU58 Perceptive Mint State Alternative
1892-S AU58 NGC. While the scarce 1892-S has its greatest claim to fame in Mint State grades, this near-Mint example is the next best thing. Substantial mint luster illuminates smooth and satiny surfaces with a bare minimum of wear or marks. Translucent shades of reddish-gold and pale-orange add eye appeal to attractive, silver-lilac surfaces. Liberty’s cheek is clear of even the most minor marks, showing a mere hint of rub. This coin is arguably more pleasing than some technically Uncirculated coins at the low end of the Mint State range.
NGC ID# 255P, PCGS# 7218
1893-CC Dollar, MS62 Frosty and Minimally Abraded
3226
1893-CC MS62 PCGS. Although the grade might suggest otherwise, the present 1893-CC dollar appears far less baggy than the typical example of this challenging Carson City issue. The coin remains largely brilliant, radiating frosty mint luster from each side. This well-struck MS62 offering is considerably finer than the typical survivor, which grades fractionally lower than XF40.
NGC ID# 2558S, PCGS# 7222
3227
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7,2021 | 1:00PMCT 49
1893-CC Dollar, MS60 Prooflike Strong Contrast, Toned Fields
3228
1893-CC MS60 Prooflike NGC. Bold contrast exists between well-mirrored fields and heavily frosted devices, although tempered to asmall degree by reddish-gold toning and a flurry of tiny bagmarks. The reverse adds a deep-blue crescent to the toning palette. This is an eye-stopping coin for the grade, and an issue that is always in demand for its final-year Carson City origins. The 1893-CC is notably scarce in prooflike format and worth a premium as such.
NGC ID# 2558S, PCGS# 7223
3229
1893-O Morgan Dollar, MS63 Low-Mintage Branch Mint Key
1893-0 MS63 PCGS. With only 300,000 pieces originally struck, the 1893-O has the lowest mintage of any New Orleans Mint Morgan Dollar issue. This is a shimmering, untoned example that has smooth, soft mint frost over each side and there are just a few modest facial scuffs and shallow blemishes to the left of the portrait. As usually encountered, the central details are somewhat weakly defined over Liberty’s ear and on the eagle’s breast.
Ex: Central States Signature (Heritage, 4/2002), lot 6395; FUN Signature (Heritage, 1/2004), lot 8126.
NGC ID# 255T, PCGS# 7224
1893-S Morgan Dollar, VG8 Low-Mintage Key
3230 1893-S VG8 NGC. Only 100,000 Morgan dollars were struck
at the San Francisco Mint in 1893, the smallest business-strike mintage of the series. Most examples seen are in low-mid circulated grades today. This VG8 example shows all design elements complete in outline and some interior detail remains intact. The letters in LIBERTY are fully legible and the lightly abraded surfaces display pleasing shades of lavender-gray toning.
NGC ID# 255U, PCGS# 7226
1893-S Morgan Dollar, VF Details Collectible Example
3231 1893-S — Repaired — PCGS Genuine. VF Details. Affordable
examples of the coveted 1893-S Morgan dollar are never without demand. This VF-level coin displays pleasing detail for the grade, with bright silvery surfaces. Each side is moderately abraded, and there are some faint tool marks in the obverse fields. The coin is otherwise a pleasing collector-grade example.
1894 Morgan Dollar, MS62 Philadelphia Key Issue
1894 MS62 NGC. While the low 110,000-piece mintage attracts legions of Morgan dollar buyers regardless of grade, a Mint State 1894 is the preferred prize among many collectors. This is an ideal coin for that purpose, with gleaming semireflective fields and only a few widely scattered abrasions. A thin veil of iridescent toning does not diminish the lively cartwheel luster that radiates from both sides. A small flat area above the ear is typical of this key Philadelphia Mint issue, one that always commands attention
when clearly Mint State. NGC ID# 255V, PCGS# 7228
50
1894-0 Silver Dollar, MS62 Elusive New Orleans Issue
3233 1894-O MS62 PCGS. VAM-4. The date is narrowly repunched at
an oblique angle, visible below the top serif of 1 and above the tip of 4. Despite a mintage exceeding 1.7 million pieces, the 1894-O is scarce in Mint State grades and it is seldom seen with any degree of eye appeal. This pleasing MS62 example offers above-average luster for the grade and largely brilliant surfaces. Typically soft at the centers, the strike is otherwise bold. Marks are limited to a surprisingly few scattered, shallow abrasions, mostly seen on the obverse. It will be challenging to find a better 1894-O at this grade level.
NGC ID# 255W, PCGS# 7230
Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
1895-O Morgan Dollar, AU58 Low-Mintage Branch Mint Issue
3234 1895-O AU58 PCGS. From a small mintage of 450,000 pieces,
the 1895-O Morgan dollar is an elusive issue in high grade. This impressive near-Mint specimen exhibits just a trace of friction on the well-detailed design elements, which show a touch of the usual softness on the hair above the ear. Some faint peripheral die cracks are evident on the lower left reverse. The surfaces are unusually free of abrasions and significant amounts of original mint luster remain intact.
NGC ID# 255Y, PCGS# 7236
1895-S Morgan Dollar, MS61 Entirely Brilliant
3235 1895-S MS61 NGC. This is the only Morgan dollar issue for the
year 1895 that is somewhat collectible in Mint State. The 1895-O is a major condition rarity, and the 1895 Philadelphia issue only exists in proof format. Both sides are all-brilliant with partial frost around the devices. Roller marks appear over Liberty's ear, but the coin is largely well-struck. Minimally abraded.
NGC ID# 255Z, PCGS# 7238
1895-S Morgan Dollar, MS62 Lightly Toned and Lustrous CAC Endorsed
3236 1895-S MS62 PCGS. CAC. Housed in a previous generation
PCGS holder with a light-blue label (barcode on the back), this CAC-approved 1895-S is one of the few pieces at this grade level to achieve that endorsement. Bagmarks are the bane of surviving examples and this coin has its share, but they are light in nature. The fields are minimally marked and semireflective, with pale- gold toning illuminated by plentiful mint luster. Frosted central elements are sharply struck beneath light abrasions. Substantial eye appeal remains intact.
NGC ID# 255Z, PCGS# 7238
1896 Morgan Dollar, MS67+ Impressive, Lovely Type Coin
3237 1896 MS67+ PCGS. The 1896 was a reasonably high-mintage
issue that followed a proof-only date (1895), and has proven to be a popular selection for type collectors that is readily available up to and including the MS66 grade level. As a Superb Gem this Philadelphia Mint date becomes much scarcer, and the + designation by PCGS further elevates the conditionally impressive status of this lovely example. It is essentially untoned, save for a slight degree of golden-yellow color on the left side of the reverse, with sharply struck design features and remarkably clean surfaces. PCGS has graded only three numerically finer examples (8/21). NGC ID# 2562, PCGS# 7240
1896-S Dollar, Brilliant MS63 Better Date San Francisco Issue
3238 1896-S MS63 PCGS. The fields are more reflective than frosted,
particularly on the obverse of this brilliant and attractive Select Uncirculated dollar. Vivid mint luster flashes from both sides, while a sharp strike exists throughout the central motifs. The 1918 Pittman Act claimed much of the 5 million-piece mintage, making Mint State examples of this San Francisco issue in ever increasing demand. This is a high-end coin for the grade, with a few light bagmarks and luster grazes, but no overly distracting abrasions. Eye appeal is exceptional.
NGC ID# 2564, PCGS# 7244
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7, 2021 | 1:;00PMCT 51
1896-S Morgan Dollar, MS64 Elusive Issue in High Grade
3239 1896-S MS64 PCGS. This California branch mint issue proves much scarcer than its mintage of 5 million pieces indicates. At least half that number are believed to have been melted under the Pittman Act. This brilliant coin exhibits thick, frosted mint luster. A few minor abrasions and luster grazes account for the grade, as well as softness of strike over the centers. PCGS has graded 88 numerically finer examples (8/21).
Ex: Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 9/2007), lot 2796, where it brought $4,168.75. NGC ID# 2564, PCGS# 7244
1901 Morgan Dollar, MS61 Always Challenging in Mint State
3242 1901 MS61 PCGS. To date, PCGS has certified just over 800 Mint State 1901 silver dollars in all Mint State grades — a tiny total, given the vast number of Morgan dollar collectors seeking an Uncirculated example (8/21). Most of the certified Mint State coins fall in the MS61 to MS62 range. This is a brilliant and highly lustrous MS61 with outstanding eye appeal for the grade. The strike is sharp. Vibrant surfaces show a few light abrasions and bagmarks, including tiny nick on the nose and a short pinscratch on the neck. All else suggests an even finer grade.
NGC ID# 256], PCGS# 7272
1897-0 Silver Dollar, MS63 Elusive in Finer Condition
1897-O MS63 PCGS. The 1897-0 is conditionally elusive — much more so than its mintage of more than 4 million coins would suggest. This piece displays softly frosted luster and the faintest tinge of champagne toning, while Liberty’s cheek and the fields exhibit remarkably few abrasions for the grade. Finer 1897-O dollars are decidedly scarce.
NGC ID# 2566, PCGS# 7248
3240
1901-0 Silver Dollar, MS66+ Elusive CAC-Approved Example
waa
3243 1901-O MS66+ PCGS. CAC. Brilliant, frosty mint luster delivers uncommonly attractive cartwheel bands on this New Orleans Morgan dollar. Strike sharpness is outstanding, complementing the absence of distracting abrasions. The 1901-O is collectible in this grade, but seldom is an example seen with a Plus designation and CAC endorsement. Finer pieces are rare.
NGC ID# 256K, PCGS# 7274
1897-O Dollar, MS63 Conditionally Elusive
1897-O MS63 PCGS. Although the New Orleans Mint coined 4 million Morgan dollars in 1897, few if any were preserved in the Treasury vaults, as most of the mintage entered circulation. Few examples have survived in Mint State grades. This Select piece has brilliant-silver surfaces with a lone splash of gold toning at 1 o’clock on the obverse. PCGS has only certified 61 numerically finer examples (8/21).
NGC ID# 2566, PCGS# 7248
3241
1902 Morgan Dollar, MS67 Outstanding Quality and Eye Appeal
3244 1902 MS67 PCGS. More than 7.9 million Morgan dollars were struck at the Philadelphia Mint in 1902, but the issue is still scarce at the MS67 grade level today, and no coins have been certified in higher numeric grades (8/21). This delightful Superb Gem exhibits impeccably preserved surfaces that radiate vibrant mint luster throughout. The design elements are well-detailed and eye appeal is terrific. Population: 59 in 67 (6 in 67+), 0 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 256M, PCGS# 7278
52 Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
1903 Morgan Dollar, MS67 Registry Grade Example
3245 1903 MS67 PCGS. From a mintage of 4.6 million pieces, the 1903 Morgan dollar was a well-produced issue and examples in MS67 condition can only be called scarce today, but PCGS has graded no coins in higher numeric grades (8/21). This spectacular Superb Gem exhibits razor-sharp definition on all design elements and the virtually flawless surfaces are lustrous and appealing.
NGC ID# 256R, PCGS# 7284
1904 Morgan Dollar, MS66 Few Certified This Fine
3248 1904 MS66 PCGS. The 1904 Morgan dollar is conditionally rare in MS66 and nearly unknown finer. No Prooflike or Deep Mirror Prooflike pieces are reported this fine at PCGS. Satiny luster radiates across untoned, exceptionally well-preserved surfaces on this piece, complementing well-struck design elements. Eye appeal is pleasing. Population: 58 in 66 (6 in 66+), 1 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 256U, PCGS# 7290
1903-S Morgan Dollar, MS63 Popular Better Date
1903-S MS63 PCGS. The 1903-S Morgan dollar claims a mintage of 1.2 million pieces, but most of the coins were either heavily circulated or melted under the provisions of the Pittman Act in 1918, making it a better date in the series today. This attractive Select example displays sharply detailed design elements and lightly marked brilliant surfaces, with vibrant mint luster throughout.
NGC ID# 256T, PCGS# 7288
1903-S Dollar, Lightly Toned MS63 Seldom Seen Better at This Grade
3246
3247 1903-S MS63 NGC. The 1903-S seems to run the gamut from overhyped to overlooked, but it is best described as a solid semikey issue in the Morgan dollar series. This is an attractive example with prooflike tendencies beneath glimmers of gold and orange toning. Bagmarks are minimal in number as well as severity, and the strike is satisfyingly sharp on both sides. Flashy mint luster grabs the eye, while overall surface quality confirms this coin’s Select Uncirculated grade.
NGC ID# 256T, PCGS# 7288
1904-O Morgan Dollar, MS67 Registry Grade Example
3249 1904-O MS67 PCGS. From an adequate mintage of 3.7 million pieces, the 1904-O Morgan dollar was well-represented in the Treasury releases of the 1960s. Accordingly, the 1904-O can be found in grades up to the MS66 level with a little patience, but the issue becomes scarce in MS67, and neither of the leading grading services has certified any coins in higher numeric grades (8/21). This spectacular Superb Gem is sharply detailed throughout, An extensive network of peripheral die cracks is evident on the reverse. The virtually flawless surfaces are lustrous and appealing.
NGC ID# 256V, PCGS# 7292
1904-S Morgan Dollar, MS62 Challenging Issue in High Grade
1904-S MS62 PCGS. CAC. The San Francisco Mint struck an adequate mintage of more than 2.3 million Morgan dollars in 1904, but the issue is surprisingly difficult to locate in high grade. This CAC-endorsed MS62 example displays sharply detailed design elements and lustrous, brilliant surfaces, with the expected number of minor contact marks for the grade.
NGC ID# 256W, PCGS# 7294
3250
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7, 2021 | 1:00PMCT — 53
1904-S Morgan Dollar, MS63
Better Late-Series Issue
3251 1904-S MS63 PCGS. The 1904-S is a better date among 20th century Morgans, much more elusive in high grade than its mintage of 2.3 million coins would suggest. This Select example displays brilliant, satiny mint luster and well-struck design elements. Minor slide marks on Liberty’s cheek are all that limit the grade, as the fields are clean, and no major abrasions are seen.
NGC ID# 256W, PCGS# 7294
1904-S Morgan Dollar, MS63 Lustrous and Reflective
1904-S MS63 PCGS. More than 2.3 million pieces were struck in early 1904, the majority of which were subsequently melted during the massive 1918 Pittman Act silver dollar melts. As a result, the 1904-S is a much better issue, and it is also collected as the scarcest of the final-year “traditional” Morgan series dollars. This Select Uncirculated example is brilliant and reflective, with only a faint golden tinge that creeps onto the high-luster, satin-smooth surfaces. Only a handful of exceedingly minor marks exist. The strike is sharp for a 1904-S, showing a mere touch of central weakness that is par for the issue.
NGC ID# 256W, PCGS# 7294
1904-S Dollar, MS64 Luminous and Untoned
3252
3253 1904-S MS64 PCGS. This S-mint issue was a great rarity before
a large quantity was released from the Treasury in the early 1940s.
Still, the 1904-S is scarce in grades higher than the near-Gem Uncirculated example offered here. This piece boasts luminous mint frost over untoned, minimally abraded surfaces with minor field marks left of the portrait. Well-defined.
Ex: Central States Signature (Heritage, 4/2017), lot 4811.
NGC ID# 256W, PCGS# 7294
PROOF MORGAN DOLLARS
1887 Morgan, PR64 Cameo Attractively Toned CAC Coin
3254 1887 PR64 Cameo PCGS. CAC. Appreciable contrast adorns each side of this attractive near-Gem proof, complemented by warm golden interiors toning that cedes to lavender and blue peripheral color. The strike is sharp on this 1887 proof, and the CAC endorsement is well deserved. The 1887 is elusive in all Cameo grades. Population: 11 in 64 Cameo, 20 finer. CAC: 3 in 64, 10 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 27ZG, PCGS# 87322
1889 Morgan Dollar, PR66 Impressive Visual Appeal
1889 PR66 NGC. This delightful Premium Gem is from a proof mintage of 811 pieces. The original brilliance shows just the slightest bit of hazy gray patina on the obverse, but the surfaces are nearly flawless. The devices show a moderate amount of frost, but even this moderate frost shows well against the illimitable depth of mirrored reflectivity seen in the fields. Census: 18 in 66, 7 finer (8/21).
Ex: June Long Beach Sale (Heritage, 6/99), lot 6402, where it brought $9,200; Central States Signature (Heritage, 4/2002), lot 4299.
NGC ID# 27ZJ, PCGS# 7324
3255
1893 Dollar, PR63 Cameo Attractive, Lightly Toned Fields
1893 PR63 Cameo PCGS. This is a nicely contrasted Cameo proof, with smoothly mirrored fields and frost-white central devices. A ting of gold border toning lightens into a translucent golden sheen throughout the reflective fields. Struck by the Mint’s hydraulic coining press, many 1893 proofs show some strike weakness. This Select Cameo example is razor sharp, with only a few faint hairlines beneath the attractive patina that are visible under a strong loupe.
NGC ID# 27ZN, PCGS# 87328
3256
54 Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
1902 Dollar, PR65 Light Golden Patina
3257 1902 PR65 NGC. Scattered golden accents complement this
Gem 1902 proof Morgan dollar — one of only 777 examples manufactured. Full strikes are expected of proof coins but not always found, particularly for this issue. However, the eagle’s breast feathers are razor-sharp here. Only the few curls immediately above Liberty’s ear are trivially incomplete. Contact is practically unseen.
NGC ID# 2822, PCGS# 7337
1903 Dollar, PR64 Pleasing for the Grade
3258 1903 PR64 NGC. A sharp, deeply reflective Choice proof type
coin, showing satiny luster on the devices and delicate champagne toning overall. No obtrusive marks or hairlines are seen. The 1903 proof is unknown with Ultra Cameo surfaces, and Cameo coins are prohibitively rare. Attractive collector-grade non-Cameo proofs such as the present fulfill most collectors’ want lists.
NGC ID# 2823, PCGS# 7338
PEACE DOLLARS
3260
1921 Peace Dollar, MS65 High-End and CAC-Approved
1921 MS65 PCGS. CAC. There has always been a strong base of demand for the first-year 1921 Peace dollars, which were struck to the extent of 1 million coins in High Relief format. Collector interest has surged even higher during this centennial year — deservedly so. This Gem should appeal to those who appreciate originality. Splashes of golden color and frosty luster wash over each side. Strike definition is remarkably bold, and the cheek and fields are clean. High-end for the grade.
NGC ID# 2U4E, PCGS# 7356
1921 Peace Dollar, MS65 Matte Proof Dies, VAM-1F1
3261
1921 Matte Proof Dies, VAM-1F1, MS65 PCGS. An Elite 30 Variety. Although struck for circulation purposes, the present coin is from the same die pair the famous 1921 matte proofs. This lustrous and lightly toned Gem has a smooth cheek and a few delicate field marks near the profile.
Ex: Bob Bisanz U.S. Type Set (Heritage, 1/2001), lot 7680; Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 2/2018), lot 5430.
PCGS# 518799 Base PCGS# 7356
1921 Peace Dollar, MS65 Popular First-Year Type Coin
3259 1921 MS65 PCGS. CAC. A stunning Gem Peace dollar from
the first year of the design, this coin exhibits well-detailed design elements, with just a touch of the usual softness on Liberty’s hair, due to the high relief of the devices. Vibrant mint luster radiates from both sides of this delightful specimen and the brilliant surfaces are impeccably preserved. The quality and eye appeal are confirmed by the CAC sticker.
NGC ID# 2U4E, PCGS# 7356
1922 Dollar, Frosty MS67 Ideal for a Top Registry Set
3262
1922 MS67 PCGS. After the Mint’s difficulties striking the 1921 High Relief Peace dollars, designer Anthony de Francisci produced a number of low relief models more suitable for mass production. More than 51 million pieces were struck. This Superb Gem coin is frosty and lustrous, with intermittent deep-brown toning at the rims framing smooth, snow-white surfaces. A pair of faint die cracks cross the neck truncation. Despite the huge mintage, Superb Gem 1922 examples are scarce. No numerically finer examples are reported at either service. Population: 43 in 67, 0 finer (8/21). From The James E. Blake Collection.
NGC ID# 257C, PCGS# 7357
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7,2021 | 1:00PMCT — 55
3263
1924 Peace Dollar, MS67 Clean Cheek, Smooth Fields
1924 MS67 PCGS. This Superb Gem displays minimal abrasions and no heavy marks to help earn its high numeric grade. Mint bloom glows across the finely grained, golden-gray surfaces, with a few deep-gray speckles above Liberty’s tiara. The strike is softened by die wear that exists in varying degrees on both sides. Strong eye appeal remains intact, a tribute to the unabraded, natural surfaces illuminated by strong, pearlescent-silver luster.
From The James E. Blake Collection.
NGC ID# 257J, PCGS# 7363
1925 Peace Dollar, MS67 Captivating Fresh Mint Bloom
3264
1925 MS67 NGC. CAC. A strikingly superb type coin, this MS67 1925 Peace dollar is about as eye-appealing as possible for this series. Spectacular, vibrant cartwheel luster illuminates heavily frosted surfaces and distinctly captivating sun-gold hues that swirl over each side. The strike is sharp, and the surfaces are devoid of distractions. A seemingly unsurpassable representative not only of this date, but of the Peace dollar type in general. NGC has certified one numerically finer example. CAC: 53 in 67, 0 finer (8/21).
Ex: FUN Signature (Heritage, 1/2015), lot 6255.
NGC ID# 257L, PCGS# 7365
3265
1926-D Peace Dollar, MS66+ Registry Set Contender
—
1926-D MS66+ PCGS. CAC. From a mintage of 2.3 million pieces, this Denver issue is not difficult to locate in MS66, but finer coins are condition rarities, making Plus-graded examples extremely popular with Registry Set enthusiasts. This Plus-graded Premium Gem exhibits sharply detailed design elements throughout and the impeccably preserved lustrous surfaces show attractive highlights of lavender-gray and russet toning. PCGS has graded 13 numerically finer examples. CAC: 92 in 66, 3 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 257P, PCGS# 7368
56
EISENHOWER DOLLAR
1971 Eisenhower Dollar, MS66+ Tied for Second Finest Certified
3266 1971 MS66+ PCGS. CAC. Set Registry collectors will be excited at the opportunity to bid on, and acquire, a top-quality example of the first-year Eisenhower dollar. This impressive Premium Gem exhibits full cartwheel luster beneath vibrant emerald-green and light blue toning.
Ex: New York Signature (Heritage, 10-11/2016), lot 5428, where it brought $3,525. NGC ID# 2584, PCGS# 7406
GOLD DOLLARS
1851 Gold Dollar, MS65 CAC-Approved Type Coin
3267 1851 MS65 PCGS. CAC. The 1851 is among the more plentiful Type One gold dollars, ideal for type representation. This Gem example is vibrantly luster and CAC endorsed, showing rich straw- gold and blond-yellow coloration with minimal contact marks. Slight strike softness is noted on Liberty’s central hair curls. Eye
appeal is excellent. From The Diane & Arnie Schaffer Collection. NGC ID# 25BK, PCGS# 7513
1854-S Gold Dollar, MS61
First-Year San Francisco Product
ie
1854-S MS61 NGC. This wonderful gold dollar was struck during the San Francisco Mint’s first year of operation and is one of only 14,632 pieces manufactured. Coincidentally, NGC and PCGS each report 152 total submissions excluding Details coins (8/21), but a more reasonable survival estimate might be in the range of 200 or so examples. The devices exhibit full strike definition, and both sides feature luminous orange-gold color with partial frosty mint luster. A lovely Gold Rush-era souvenir.
NGC ID# 25C2, PCGS# 7527
3268
Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
1856 Gold Dollar, MS66+ CAC-Approved Slanted 5 Coin
1880 Gold Dollar, MS67 Prooflike Deeply Reflective, CAC Approved
3269 1856 Slanted 5 MS66+ PCGS. CAC. The Slanted 5 1856 gold dollar is the more plentiful of the two date logotypes, and examples grading as fine as MS64 are available for type collectors. Nonetheless, Gem representatives are rare, and finer pieces are exceedingly so. This Premium Gem is high-end and CAC endorsed. Frosty wheat-gold luster glistens without abrasion on each side, and the strike is sharp. Eye appeal is outstanding. Population: 14 in 66 (3 in 66+), 5 finer. CAC: 5 in 66, 1 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 25C9, PCGS# 7540
1857-D Gold Dollar, AU53 Only 3,533 Coins Struck
3270 1857-D AU53 PCGS. CAC. Variety 9-L. The 1857-D gold dollar is an underrated issue from a paltry mintage of 3,533 pieces. This attractive AU53 example offers well-detailed design elements, with just a touch of wear on the high points. The orange-gold surfaces are lightly abraded and retain traces of original mint luster in sheltered areas. The high quality within the grade is confirmed by the CAC sticker. Population: 12 in 53, 58 finer. CAC: 2 in 53, 13 finer (8/21). NGC ID# 25CEF, PCGS# 7546
1859 Gold Dollar, MS66 Extremely Rare Any Finer
1859 MS66 PCGS. CAC. A pre-Civil War strike seldom seen finer than the present Premium Gem, the 1859 gold dollar saw a production exceeding 168,000 circulation strikes. This piece is nearly pristine in terms of contact marks, although some clash marks appear on each side. The strike is sharp throughout, save for the first L in DOLLAR and the 85 of the date below. Population: 13 in 66 (3 in 66+), 6 finer. CAC: 8 in 66, 5 finer (8/21).
Ex: Chicago Signature (Heritage, 8/2011), lot 5333.
NGC ID# 25CL, PCGS# 7551
3271
3272 1880 MS67 Prooflike NGC. CAC. A conditionally rare Prooflike example of this low-mintage issue (1,600 pieces struck). Blond-gold surfaces yield nearly flawless preservation and deep reflectivity, with frosty luster on the devices. Struck from lapped dies, with upper portion of the wreath weakened by polishing. Eye appeal is outstanding, as the CAC endorsement suggests. Census: 18 in 67 (5 in 67* Prooflike, 1 in 67+), 1 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 25DJ, PCGS# 77581
1887 Gold Dollar, MS66+ Prooflike Sole Prooflike Coin at PCGS
1887 MS66+ Prooflike PCGS. Many 1887 gold dollars are semiprooflike, a product of the low 7,500-coin mintage, however, examples with deep enough mirroring to warrant a Prooflike designation are moderately scarce. Until recently, only NGC awarded Prooflike designations to Mint State gold dollars, and that service lists 41 such pieces in all grades, including three Premium Gems and seven Superb Gems finer. PCGS has thus far only designated a single 1887 gold dollar Prooflike, the present MS66+ example (8/21). The coin is fully struck and bright yellow-gold in color, with stark cameo contrast. A thin line in the planchet from Liberty’s brow to the first S in STATES is mint made. Population: 1 in 66 (1 in 66+) Prooflike, 0 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 25DS, PCGS# 87588 Base PCGS# 7588
3273
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7, 2021 | 1:00PMCT — 57
1889 Gold Dollar, MS67 Exemplary Type Coin
3274 1889 MS67 PCGS. CAC. The 1889 gold dollar is extremely
popular with type collectors because it is readily available in high grades. Even at the Superb Gem level the issue can be located with patience, but anything finer is very rare. The present coin is a magnificent Superb Gem, with explosive, frosty luster and an exquisite strike. The outstanding visual appeal is confirmed by the CAC sticker. PCGS has graded 15 numerically finer examples. CAC: 84 in 67, 4 finer (8/21).
Ex: Summer FUN Signature (Heritage, 7/2010), lot 4524.
From The Ed’s Treasures Collection.
NGC ID# 25DU, PCGS# 7590
EARLY QUARTER EAGLES
1806/4 Quarter Eagle, XF Details BD-1, 8x5 Stars
3275 1806/4 8x5 Stars, BD-1, High R.4 — Cleaning — PCGS
Genuine. XF Details. Bass-Dannreuther Die State b/b. The 8x5 Stars alignment is all that is needed to confirm the BD-1 variety, although the 6 over 4 in the date is prominent on this example. The reverse die was carried over from 1805, as confirmed by repunching of field star 11 — the same reverse die was also used to strike 150,000 dimes dated 1807. The overdated obverse utilized an unused 1804 die. This coin is bright from Cleaning, with numerous accompanying hairlines. A soft strike at the centers is sharper at the peripheries, with glimpses of luster at the margins.
58
3276
1825 BD-2 Two and a Half AU Sharpness
Wye 2 >
1825 BD-2, High R.4 — Surfaces Tooled — PCGS Genuine. AU Details. Bass-Dannreuther Die State a/a. The 5 sits low in the date, tilts left, with its flag recut. 1 and 2 are away from the fraction bar, while a large D defines the denomination. This is a radiant sun-gold example with semireflective fields and sharp motifs. Several areas of obscure tooling appear on both sides — noticeably in the left obverse field near stars 3 and 4, but elsewhere as well. Light hairlines accompany a scattering of tiny marks.
1830 BD-1 Quarter Eagle, AU Details Scarce Low-Mintage Issue
3277
1830 BD-1, R.4 — Surfaces Smoothed — PCGS Genuine. AU Details. Bass-Dannreuther Die State a/a. A single die pair (BD-1) was used to strike 4,540 pieces, of which the Bass-Dannreuther reference estimate 80 to 100 pieces are known today. This example has bright-yellow surfaces with areas of smoothing — most obviously, over and around the eagle’s head. A hint of reddish- gold toning remains at the margins. Both sides demonstrate About Uncirculated sharpness from dies that show no clashing, lapping, or die cracks. Despite the surface “improvements,” this is a reasonably attractive example of a popular and in-demand date.
CLASSIC QUARTER EAGLE
1834 Classic Head Quarter Eagle, MS62 CAC Approval, Extraordinary Eye Appeal
3278 1834 Large Head, HM-2, R.3, MS62 PCGS. CAC. This variety
(HM-2) features the letters AM in AMERICA spaced widely apart. Daryl Haynor estimates 425 coins survive from this set of dies and notes that some examples come with prooflike surfaces. This high-end MS62 certainly displays partial contrast, and the outer design elements are razor-sharp. Minor softness is limited to Liberty’s middle curls. Orange-gold color deeps slightly toward the peripheries. Eye appeal is extraordinary.
PCGS# 764688 Base PCGS# 7692
Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
LIBERTY QUARTER EAGLES
PROOF LIBERTY QUARTER EAGLE
3279
1850-D Liberty Quarter Eagle, AU55 Lightly Abraded Surfaces
1850-D AU55 PCGS. CAC. Variety 13-N. From a mintage of 12,148 pieces, the 1850-D Liberty quarter eagle is not a rare issue in the context of the series, but it is definitely elusive at the AU55 grade level, with a CAC endorsement. This attractive Choice AU specimen shows only light wear on the well-detailed design elements, with just a touch of the usual softness on the eagle’s claws and leg. The pleasing orange-gold surfaces are remarkably free of large abrasions, but a few minor rim dings show on both sides. Population: 20 in 55 (1 in 55+), 28 finer. CAC: 11 in 55, 8 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 25HJ, PCGS# 7757
3280
1905 Liberty Quarter Eagle, MS67 Outstanding Type Coin
—
1905 MS67 PCGS. From a business-strike mintage of 217,800 pieces, the 1905 Liberty quarter eagle is an available issue in high grade, making it a popular choice with type collectors. Even at the lofty MS67 grade level, the 1905 remains collectible, but finer coins are virtually unobtainable. This delightful Superb Gem exhibits sharply detailed design elements and virtually flawless surfaces, with vibrant mint luster and terrific eye appeal. PCGS has certified only five numerically finer examples (8/21).
NGC ID# 25LW, PCGS# 7857
1872 Liberty Quarter Eagle, PR63 Rare Deep Cameo Specimen
3281 1872 PR63 Deep Cameo PCGS. JD-1, High R.6. Only 30
proof Liberty quarter eagles were struck in 1872, with all the coins delivered on February 3. A single die pair was used to strike all the proofs. This was the only use of the obverse die, but the reverse was used to strike at least some proof quarter eagles every year from 1868 through 1878. The proofs have the date positioned higher in the field and further left than on the business strikes, making it easy to differentiate between the two formats. John Dannreuther estimates the surviving population at 12-14 examples in all grades. The present coin is an attractive Select proof, with sharply detailed design elements and deeply mirrored fields that contrast profoundly with the frosty devices to produce a startling Deep Cameo effect. The pleasing yellow-gold surfaces are lightly marked, with a curving lintmark above the top arrowhead that serves as a pedigree marker. Eye appeal is outstanding. Population: 1 in 63 Deep Cameo, 5 finer (8/21). NGC ID# 287T, PCGS# 97898
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7, 2021 | 1:00 PM CT 59
INDIAN QUARTER EAGLES
1911-D Two and a Half, AU50 Sought-After Denver Issue
3282 1911-D AU50 PCGS. Rich orange-gold and yellow colors adorn
the satiny surfaces of this About Uncirculated 1911-D quarter eagle. Little evidence of wear is present, and the mintmark remains clear. With a mintage of only 55,680 pieces, the 1911-D is the sole overall key date in the popular Indian quarter eagle series. About Uncirculated pieces with natural patina such as this are in high demand.
NGC ID# 2894, PCGS# 7943
1911-D Indian Quarter Eagle, AU53 Strong D, Colorful Surfaces
3283 1911-D AU53 PCGS. Strong D. The 1911-D Indian quarter
eagle is the acknowledged key to the series, from a series-low business-strike mintage of 55,680 pieces. This attractive AU53 example shows some minor rub on the design elements, but the all-important D mintmark remains legible and the lustrous orange- gold surfaces are lightly abraded.
NGC ID# 2894, PCGS# 7943
THREE DOLLAR GOLD PIECES
1854-O Three Dollar Gold, AU50 Only O-Mint Three
3284 1854-O AU50 PCGS. Variety 2. From a mintage of 24,000 pieces,
the 1854-O three dollar gold piece is an elusive issue in high grade and the only coin of this denomination from the New Orleans Mint. This impressive AU specimen shows some light wear on the design elements and the yellow and orange-gold surfaces exhibit the expected number of minor abrasions for the grade.
NGC ID# 25M5, PCGS# 7971
60
1859 Three Dollar Gold, MS63 Elusive This Fine
3285
1859 MS63 PCGS. CAC. From a mintage of 15,500 pieces, the 1859 three dollar gold piece is occasionally seen in lower Mint State grades, but the issue becomes elusive at the MS63 grade level. This attractive Select example offers well-detailed design elements and the well-preserved peach-gold surfaces are lustrous and appealing. Population: 33 in 63 (1 in 63+), 27 finer. CAC: 3 in 63, 11 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 25MD, PCGS# 7979
3286
1865 Three Dollar, AU50 Scarce Low-Mintage Issue
1865 AU50 PCGS. From a mintage of only 1,140 pieces and struck during an era when few gold coins were preserved for numismatic purposes, the 1865 three dollar coin is scarce in all grades. This About Uncirculated example displays original olive-gold patina with deeper orange-gold hues in the peripheral fields. Little wear is present, and slight softness on the wreath bowknot is due largely to minor strike softness. Population: 10 in 50, 53 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 25ML, PCGS# 7986
EARLY HALF EAGLES
1804 Half Eagle, AU Sharpness Small 8, BD-3
3287 1804 Small 8, BD-3, R.5 — Repaired — PCGS Genuine. AU
Details. Bass-Dannreuther Die State c/i. The wings are lustrous on this lightly circulated Heraldic Eagle representative. BD-3 is a very scarce die marriage with a small 18 in the date, though the 4 is large. The glossy green-gold surfaces show occasional marks, such as a line in the field near obverse star 3.
Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
1805 BD-1 Half Eagle, AU Details Well-Defined Type Coin
3288
1805 BD-1, High R.3 — Edge, Rim Damage — PCGS Genuine. AU Details. Bass-Dannreuther Die State a/a. Struck from perfect dies, with no obverse die cracks and no signs of a die crack at U of UNITED. The coin is bright with faint hair lines, but displays pleasing rich-gold color and only a few tiny, scattered marks. Bold definition exists throughout the motifs, suggesting an even finer technical grade. No edge or rim damage is seen, although it may be hidden by the previous generation PCGS holder (light-blue label). The eagle’s right (facing) wing as well as the branch, leaves, and eagle’s tail show bold strike doubling. There is much to recommend this sharp and pleasing BD-1 half eagle despite the decision by PCGS to withhold a numeric grade.
3289
1811 Half Eagle, AU50O Small 5, BD-2
1811 Small 5, BD-2, R.3, AU50 PCGS. Bass-Dannreuther Die State d/a, without reverse clashmarks. The Small 5 variant is marginally more collectible than its Tall 5 counterpart, with John Dannreuther estimating 225 to 300 pieces extant. Original luster glows around the devices. The exposed areas are bright yellow-gold with a thin layer of rub over the highest points of the design. Abrasions are peppered throughout, but none are especially noteworthy. A pleasing Capped Bust half eagle.
NGC ID# BFXR, PCGS# 507599 Base PCGS# 8109
3290
1812 Five Dollar, XF Sharpness BD-1, Wide 5D
1812 BD-1, Wide 5D, R.3 — Cleaning — PCGS Genuine. XF Details. Bass-Dannreuther Die State a/a. The Bass-Dannreuther reference notes that some curious reverse die lines are seen on some BD-1 half eagles, and they are present on this coin. One begins at 2 o’clock on the reverse rim and passes just left of AMERICA before ending in the wing. Another curves through the horizontal shield lines. These anomalies are of Mint origin. This is a pleasing 1812 example, slightly subdued by a faint cleaning, but sharply defined for the XF designation. Significant eye appeal remains.
3291
1813 BD-1 Half Eagle, AU Details Collectible Early Gold Type Coin
1813 BD-1, R.2 — Repaired — PCGS Genuine. AU Details. Bass-Dannreuther Die State a/a, without clash marks. The BD-1 die marriage shares an obverse with the only other variety for the year (BD-2). This reverse is distinguished by the placement of the first S in STATES far right over the E below. The present AU Details coin is a collectible Capped Bust Left half eagle made all the more obtainable because of the noted repair. Bright yellow- gold surfaces show considerable evidence of tooling in the fields to remove abrasions, though definition remains strong.
1813 Half Eagle, AU Sharpness Scarcer BD-2 Variety
3292
1813 BD-2, R.4 — Surfaces Tooled — PCGS Genuine. AU Details. Bass-Dannreuther Die State d/b. Light die cracks on both the obverse and reverse indicate the late die state, which is the one usually seen for the scarce BD-2 variety. A modicum of original mint luster remains at the margins of this medium-gold example, augmented by traces of orange-gold at the stars and legends. Some skillful smoothing is seen on Liberty’s cheek, and other areas of tooling may exist, not easily discerned. This remains a pleasing coin with considerable merit in spite of the handwork, and it is the scarcer of two 1813 varieties known for the issue.
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7, 2021 | 1:00 PM CT 61
LIBERTY HALF EAGLES
1839-C Liberty Half Eagle, XF45
Elusive Obverse Mintmark Issue
3293 1839-C XF45 PCGS. Variety 1. From a small mintage of 17,205 pieces, the 1839-C is the only Liberty half eagle from the Charlotte Mint that features a prominent obverse mintmark, an important consideration for type purposes. This attractive Choice XF specimen exhibits only light wear on the well-detailed design elements. The pleasing orange-gold surfaces are lightly abraded, but several minor rim dings are evident on both sides. Population: 15 in 45, 37 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 25S8, PCGS# 8192
1845-D Liberty Half Eagle, AU55 Sought-After Branch Mint Type Issue
1845-D AU55 NGC. Variety 13-H. This Dahlonega issue is relatively available through lower About Uncirculated grades, but becomes scarce in AU55 or finer grades from a mintage of 90,629 pieces. This a sharply defined Choice AU example. Reflective fields attract light marks and minor chatter, but there are no heavy abrasions seen on either side, and soft luster remains visible throughout the pleasing, greenish-gold surfaces.
NGC ID# 25TC, PCGS# 8224
3294
1845-D Liberty Half Eagle, AU58 Popular Dahlonega Type Issue
3295 1845-D AU58 PCGS. CAC. Variety 14-H. The date is positioned high, and to the left, identifying the rare Variety 14-H. The Dahlonega Mint struck a substantial production of 90,629 Liberty half eagles in 1845. As might be expected, the 1845-D is one of the more available issues from the Dahlonega facility and is always popular with branch mint type collectors. This attractive near-Mint specimen exhibits just a trace of friction on the strongly impressed design elements and the lightly abraded orange-gold surfaces retain traces of original mint luster. Population: 32 in 58, 22 finer. CAC: 5 in 58, 3 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 25TC, PCGS# 8224
1850-D Five Dollar, AU55 Above Average Quality for the Issue
3296 1850-D AU55 PCGS. CAC. Variety 28-S. The 1850-D is conditionally rare, given its median grade of XF45 at PCGS. The present Choice AU Dahlonega example has lemon-gold surfaces with portions of mint luster surrounding the devices on each side. An above average strike is seen on each side, and no marks are noticeable aside from a single diagonal line on the cheek. Population: 15 in 55, 13 finer. CAC: 4 in 55, 1 finer (8/21).
Ex: Central States Signature (Heritage, 4/2006), lot 2703; Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 9/2009), lot 1576; Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 6/2013), lot 4770.
NGC ID# 25U3, PCGS# 8245
1853-C Liberty Half Eagle, XF40 Popular Branch Mint Type Coin
Ta
3297 1853-C XF40 NGC. Variety 2. The date is positioned to the left and there is a dramatic die break below the denomination on the reverse, identifying the rare Variety 2. The Charlotte Mint struck 65,571 half eagles in 1853, making the issue relatively available today. This impressive XF specimen shows only light wear on the design elements and the lightly abraded greenish-gold surfaces retain traces of original mint luster in sheltered areas.
NGC ID# 25UE, PCGS# 8254
62 Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
1855-D Half Eagle, Pleasing AU55 Medium D, Scarce Dahlonega Date
1882-CC Five Dollar, AU58+ Few Graded Finer
3298
1855-D Medium D AU55 PCGS. CAC. Variety 38-CC. Rare in all grades, the 1855 Dahlonega five is seldom seen above the XF level. Choice examples such as this AU55 coin with CAC endorsement are in great demand among branch mint gold specialists. This pleasing Medium D representative displays attractive, still-lustrous orange-gold color. The central strike is above average for the issue, which is nearly always weak at the eagle’s neck and at Liberty’s head. Here, the hair curls are bolder than normally seen. This attractive 1855-D is sure to find a home in a high-grade Dahlonega set. Population: 6 in 55, 5 finer. CAC: 1 in 55, 2 finer (8/21).
PCGS# 98263
1857-D Liberty Half Eagle, AU58
Elusive, Underrated Issue
3299
1857-D AU58 PCGS. CAC. Variety 41-HH. From a modest mintage of 17,046 pieces, the 1857-D is an undervalued issue and Doug Winter considers it one of the scarcest late-series half eagles from the Dahlonega Mint. This impressive near-Mint representative displays a better-than-average strike for the issue, with just a trace of friction on the high points of the design elements. The pleasing orange-gold surfaces are free of large or distracting abrasions. Population: 14 in 58, 12 finer. CAC: 4 in 58, 1 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 25V4, PCGS# 8273
1857-S Half Eagle, AU58 Strong Strike
3300 1857-S AU58 PCGS. Remaining mint frost glows around the
borders and devices of this near-Uncirculated Liberty Head half eagle. Strike definition is surprisingly strong on the stars, curls, feathers, talons, and olive leaves with the relief elements showing little trace of friction. Orange-gold surfaces are lightly abraded with a few hairlines. An impeccable example of this conditionally challenging early S-mint issue (87,000 coins struck). Population: 21 in 58, 14 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 25V6, PCGS# 8275
3301 1882-CC AU58+ NGC. Variety 1-A. Frosty mint luster rolls
around the borders of this borderline-Uncirculated Carson City half eagle. The surfaces are overwhelmingly yellow-gold with a few deeper reddish or orange accents. Each side is well-defined with hardly a trace of friction. Abrasions are peppered throughout. The 1882-CC five dollar claims a mintage of 82,817 coins. Few survive in higher grades, with only 26 graded finer at NGC (8/21).
NGC ID# 25XH, PCGS# 8359
1891-CC Liberty Half Eagle, MS62 Popular Branch Mint Type Coin
3302 1891-CC MS62 NGC. CAC. Variety 1-A. A die crack from star
1 easily identifies the variety. Rose-gold coloration and vibrant luster imbue the well-struck surfaces with excellent eye appeal. The moderate availability of this Carson City issue makes it appropriate for type purposes. From a mintage of 208,000 pieces. CAC: 66 in 62, 67 finer (8/21).
Ex: Summer FUN Signature (Heritage, 7/2014), lot 4618.
NGC ID# 25Y5, PCGS# 8378
1891-CC Five Dollar Liberty, MS63 Lustrous and Well Struck
3303 1891-CC MS63 PCGS. CAC. Variety 2-A. The 1891-CC
Liberty half eagle claims a substantial mintage of 208,000 pieces, making it an available issue and a popular choice with branch mint type collectors. This impressive Select specimen displays sharply detailed design elements and lightly marked orange-gold surfaces, with vibrant mint luster and outstanding eye appeal.
NGC ID# 25Y5, PCGS# 8378
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7,2021 | 1:00PMCT 63
1901-S Half Eagle, MS66+ Few Pieces Known Finer
1916-S Half Eagle, MS63 Final S-Mint Indian Head Five
3304
1901-S MS66+ PCGS. The availability of the 1901-S half eagle overall makes it popular with type collectors, but the date is conditionally rare at the Superb Gem grade level. This high-end Premium Gem boasts significant eye appeal, with sharp motifs and frosty wheat-gold luster. Neither side exhibits bothersome abrasions. Population: 96 in 66 (16 in 66+), 6 finer (8/21).
From The Ed’s Treasures Collection.
NGC ID# 25YX, PCGS# 8404
INDIAN HALF EAGLES
3305
1909-0 Indian Half Eagle, XF45 ul
1909-O XF45 NGC. Variety 1. The New Orleans Mint struck coins for the last time in 1909, when a small mintage of 34,200 Indian half eagles was accomplished. The 1909-O is the only Indian half eagle struck at the famous Southern mint and the low mintage makes it an elusive key in the series. This Choice XF specimen shows only light wear on the design elements and the pleasing orange-gold surfaces are lightly abraded, outside of a few gouges in the reverse field.
NGC ID# 25ZK, PCGS# 8515
1911-D Indian Half Eagle, AU55 Challenging, Low-Mintage Issue
3306
1911-D AU55 PCGS. From a small mintage of 72,500 pieces, the 1911-D Indian half eagle is one of the most challenging issues of the series. This attractive Choice AU specimen exhibits only light wear on the lightly abraded orange-gold surfaces, which retain much of their original mint luster intact. The strike is bold and the overall presentation is most attractive.
NGC ID# 28DR, PCGS# 8521
64
3307
1916-S MS63 PCGS. CAC. This Select Uncirculated 1916- S displays lustrous, orange-gold surfaces, with minor, hair-thin abrasions and a few tiny marks. The strike is sharp throughout both sides, with full plumage at the eagle’s shoulder and well-defined feathers in the chief’s headdress. A bold mintmark is seen, although it is partially filled and rounded. Despite a healthy 240,000-piece mintage, the 1916-S becomes conditionally scarce in the middle Uncirculated grades, and it is rare in Gem condition. CAC endorsement confirms the high quality of this attractive MS63 coin.
NGC ID# 28DY, PCGS# 8532
EARLY EAGLES
3308
1801 BD-2 Ten Dollar, AU Details Smoothed and Polished Obverse
1801 BD-2, R.2 — Surfaces Smoothed — PCGS Genuine. AU Details. Bass-Dannreuther Die State b/b. Vertical spines in cap. A concerted effort was made to eliminate small marks from the obverse fields and Liberty’s portrait, resulting in a polished, mirrorlike surface, with numerous hairlines that run in all directions throughout the obverse. The reverse is reflective as well, but more naturally so. A shallow rim bump is noted at 5 o’clock. The 1801 BD-2 issue is readily available in nearly all grades. This is a Genuine example, with its bright-gold surfaces offering About Uncirculated sharpness, but with the obverse extensively smoothed.
Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
1803 Ten Dollar, AU50 Details Rare BD-4 Variety Small Reverse Stars
3309 1803 Small Reverse Stars, BD-4, R.6, — Scratched, Cleaned — ANACS. AU50 Details. Bass-Dannreuther Die State d/c. BD-4 is the third rarest of six 1803 ten dollar varieties, with only 25 to 30 pieces believed known. This example displays pleasing detail and rich orange-gold coloration. A thin old scratch through the top of Liberty’s cap is only seen with a loupe, while hairlines over each side betray cleaning. Visually pleasing to the unaided eye.
LIBERTY EAGLES
1845-O Liberty Eagle, AU58 Challenging Issue in High Grade
3310 1845-O AU58 NGC. Variety 6. Variety 6, with the date placed high and widely repunched to the south and the mintmark placed over the left side of N in TEN. From a smallish mintage of 47,500 pieces, the 1845-O Liberty eagle is rare in high grade, despite the
discovery of a small hoard of EF-AU examples in the early 1990s.
This attractive near-Mint specimen exhibits just a trace of friction on the well-detailed design elements, with a touch of the usual softness on Liberty’s curls and the eagle’s leg. The lightly abraded orange-gold surfaces retain traces of original mint luster. Census: 23 in 58, 7 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 262V, PCGS# 8593
1849 Liberty Eagle, MS61+ Semiprooflike Fields, Sharp Strike
1849 MS61+ NGC. Breen-6886, Repunched 1. Always a favored date for No Motto Liberty Head type, the 1849 eagle boasts a plentiful mintage of 653,618 pieces. This Mint State example was struck from polished dies, with partially prooflike surfaces and a sharp strike. Only stars 1 and 2 lack their central details. The 1 in the date shows obvious repunching, with remnants of a previous 1 extending from the lower-left upright. Rich, yellow-gold surfaces are brightly lustrous and mildly abraded. Census: 1 in 61+, 20 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 2635, PCGS# 8601
1854-O Liberty Eagle, AU53 Distinctive Large Date Variety
3311
3312 1854-O Large Date AU53 PCGS. CAC. Variety-3. The 1854-O Liberty eagle with the Large Date is seen more often today than its Small Date counterpart. The Large Date resulted from using the date punch for the silver dollar on the smaller gold denomination. This attractive AU53 example displays a bold strike, with only light wear on the design elements, and the pleasing orange-gold surfaces are lightly abraded throughout. The high quality within the grade is confirmed by the CAC sticker. Population: 22 in 53, 42 finer. CAC: 6 in 53, 18 finer (8/21). NGC ID# 263], PCGS# 98614
1854-S Liberty Eagle, AU55 First San Francisco Mint Ten
3313 1854-S AU55 PCGS. CAC. The San Francisco Mint began coinage operations in 1854 and struck a substantial mintage of 123,826 Liberty eagles. The 1854-S is always popular with branch mint type collectors, as well as series specialists. This attractive Choice AU specimen offers well-detailed design elements, with only light wear on the high points of the devices. The pleasing orange-gold surfaces are lightly abraded, with the high quality and eye appeal within the grade confirmed by the CAC sticker. Population: 31 in 55, 31 finer. CAC: 11 in 55, 14 finer (8/21). NGC ID# 263k, PCGS# 8615
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7,2021 | 1:000PMCT 65
1854-S Eagle, AUS8
First San Francisco Issue
3314 1854-S AU58 NGC. CAC. In the first year of operation, the San Francisco Mint coined five different gold denominations, although only the eagle and double eagle are regularly seen today. The gold dollar is scarce, while the quarter eagle and half eagle issues are major rarities. This example has considerable luster on its greenish- yellow surfaces with slight wear on the high points. Census: 61 in 58, 8 finer. CAC: 12 in 58, 2 finer (8/21).
Ex: Central States Signature (Heritage, 4/2014), lot 6592. NGC ID# 263K, PCGS# 8615
1869-S Liberty Eagle, AU50 Elusive, Low-Mintage Issue
1869-S AU50 PCGS. CAC. The San Francisco Mint struck a minuscule mintage of 6,430 Liberty eagles in 1869 and few high- quality examples were saved for numismatic purposes. Accordingly, The 1869-S is an elusive issue in all grades today. This impressive AU specimen exhibits only light wear on the design elements and the pleasing yellow-gold surfaces show some minor chatter in the fields, with prooflike reflectivity in sheltered areas. Population: 9 in 50, 18 finer. CAC: 3 in 50, 6 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 2648, PCGS# 8656
1870 Liberty Eagle, AU53 Popular Low-Mintage Issue
3315
3316 1870 AU53 NGC. The 1870 Liberty eagle claims a minuscule business-strike mintage of 3,990 pieces, making it an elusive issue in all grades. This impressive AU53 specimen shows some light wear on the high points of the design elements, like the curl below the ear and the arrow fletching, but most interior detail remains intact. The yellow-gold surfaces exhibit some minor abrasions and chatter, but traces of prooflike reflectivity are evident in sheltered areas around the devices. Census: 12 in 53, 22 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 264T, PCGS# 8657
1871 Liberty Eagle, AU53 Merely 100 to 125 Coins Extant
ee
3317 1871 AU53 NGC. Liberty eagles of this period have been underrated in the past. Today, they benefit from an appreciative collector base that recognizes their absolute scarcity. In the case of the 1871, only 1,790 circulation strikes were manufactured (plus 30 proofs). About 100 to 125 examples survive in all grades, and only one or two are known in Mint State (MS60). This minimally circulated AU53 representative boasts rich red-gold color. The surfaces maintain traces of field reflectivity despite scattered abrasions. Well-struck with light high-point friction.
NGC ID# 264W, PCGS# 8660
1877-S Liberty Eagle, AU55 Scarce Low-Mintage Issue
3318 1877-S AU55 PCGS. The 1877-S Liberty eagle boasts a small mintage of 17,000 pieces and few examples were saved for numismatic purposes. As might be expected, the issue is rarely encountered in high grade. This attractive Choice AU specimen offers strongly impressed design elements, with just a touch of wear on the high points. The orange-gold surfaces show the expected number of minor abrasions, with traces of original mint luster in sheltered areas. Population: 8 in 55 (1 in 55+), 7 finer (8/21). NGC ID# 265H, PCGS# 8679
1884-CC Ten Dollar, AU55 Sharp Reverse Detail
3319 1884-CC AU55 PCGS. Variety 1-A. Fewer than 10,000 eagles were struck at the Carson City Mint in 1884 — 9,925 to be exact. Rusty Goe proposes that 200 to 235 coins survive in his recently published reference, The Confident Carson City Coin Collector, Volume 2 (2020). Reddish accents complement wheat-gold surfaces. The coin maintains partial frost and impressive detail despite a brief stay in circulation. The eagle’s plumage and talons are tack-sharp. Population: 30 in 55, 34 finer (8/21). NGC ID# 266B, PCGS# 8704
66 Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
3320
1891 Ten Dollar, MS61 Deep Prooflike Deeply Mirrored Fields, Frosted Motifs
1891 MS61 Deep Prooflike NGC. While the occasional prooflike 1891 eagle is seen in one of our auctions, this is the first Deep Prooflike example we have handled. Mirrorlike surfaces adjoin razor-sharp, well-frosted motifs, and considerable white-on-black contrast exists when viewed at the proper angle. Although myriad tiny marks dot the surfaces, but they do little to diminish the obvious reflectivity of the fields, nor do they exceed the assigned numeric grade. Gleaming orange-gold surfaces provide plenty of eye appeal. Census: 2 in 61 Deep Prooflike, 1 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 266T, PCGS# 78719
1891-CC Liberty Eagle, MS63 Rare Issue Any Finer
3321
1891-CC MS63 PCGS. Variety 1-A. From a substantial mintage of 103,732 pieces, the 1891-CC is the most available Liberty eagle from the Carson City Mint, and a favorite choice of branch mint type collectors. This attractive Select specimen exhibits sharply detailed design elements and lightly marked orange-gold surfaces, with vibrant mint luster throughout. PCGS has graded only six numerically finer examples (8/21).
NGC ID# 266U, PCGS# 8720
3322
1901-S Ten Dollar, MS65 Ideal Liberty Head Type Coin
1901-S MS65 NGC. CAC. A coppery alloy spot appears in the left obverse field (a much smaller one occurs left of the E in AMERICA), while the remaining surfaces exhibit luminous peach and yellow-gold color. Swirling mint frost completes the appeal. Tack-sharp and perfect to represent the Liberty Head eagle type. Housed in a former generation, pre-hologram holder.
NGC ID# 2678S, PCGS# 8749
1901-S Ten Dollar, MS66 Rarely Seen Finer
3323 1901-S MS66 NGC. Vibrant, frosty original luster engulfs this Premium Gem 1901-S in rich straw-gold hues. Only a few microscopic field marks prevent an even finer grade. The 1901-S Liberty eagle is generally available, even as fine as MS66, and it is popular with type collectors. NGC lists only two dozen finer pieces (8/21).
From The Diane & Arnie Schaffer Collection. NGC ID# 2678S, PCGS# 8749
1901-S Liberty Eagle, MS66+ Exceptional Type Coin
3324 1901-S MS66+ PCGS. CAC. From a large mintage of more than 2.8 million pieces, the 1901-S Liberty eagle is an available issue in all grades up to the MS66 level, but finer coins are virtually unobtainable. This Plus-graded Premium Gem features razor-sharp definition on all design elements, with some spidery peripheral die cracks on the reverse. The impeccably preserved orange-gold surfaces are awash in vibrant mint luster and eye appeal is terrific. Population: 23 in 66+, 3 finer. CAC: 47 in 66, 1 finer (8/21). NGC ID# 267S, PCGS# 8749
INDIAN EAGLES
1908 Indian Eagle, MS64+ First Year With Motto
3325 1908 Motto MS64+ PCGS. The design of the Indian eagle was modified to include the motto INGOD WE TRUST on the reverse part way through the year in 1908. This Plus-graded Choice example exhibits sharply detailed design elements, with fine definition on Liberty’s curls and the headdress feathers. The pleasing orange-gold surfaces are well-preserved and lustrous, with outstanding eye appeal.
NGC ID# 28GJ, PCGS# 8859
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7,2021 | 1:00PMCT 67
1911-D Indian Eagle, AU55 Rarely Seen in High Grade
3326 1911-D AU55 NGC. From a small mintage of 30,100 pieces,
David Akers called the 1911-D “the leading condition rarity in the Indian Eagle series” and “one of the rarest 20th century U.S. gold coins.” This impressive Choice AU specimen shows only light wear on the well-detailed design elements and the lightly abraded orange-gold surfaces retain significant amounts of original mint luster.
NGC ID# 28GU, PCGS# 8869
1852 Liberty Twenty, AU58 Collectible Early Series Issue
3329
1852 AU58 NGC. Like most Type One Liberty double eagles that were not well-represented in modern shipwreck finds, the 1852 is seldom encountered in high grade. This attractive near-Mint specimen shows just a trace of friction on the strongly impressed design elements and the lustrous yellow and rose-gold surfaces are relatively lightly abraded.
From The Wabash Collection of Liberty Double Eagles.
NGC ID# 268K, PCGS# 8906
LIBERTY DOUBLE EAGLES
1850 Liberty Double Eagle, AU53
3327 1850 AU53 NGC. An attractive Liberty double eagle with
abundant reddish-golden color and a bold strike. The wingtips and Liberty’s curls show light wear, and the left obverse field has a few relatively minor abrasions. Always popular as the first year of the denomination. From a mintage of more than 1.1 million pieces. Ex: Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 1/2004), lot 7217.
From The Wabash Collection of Liberty Double Eagles.
NGC ID# 268F, PCGS# 8902
1851 Liberty Double Eagle, AU55 Early Type One Issue
3328 1851 AU55 NGC. The Philadelphia Mint struck a huge mintage
of more than 2 million Liberty double eagles in 1851, thanks to massive shipments of gold from the California mines. Unfortunately, most of the coins circulated heavily at the time of issue, making high-grade examples quite elusive today. This attractive Choice AU specimen displays only light wear on the high points of the design elements and the lustrous yellow and rose-gold surfaces show the expected number of minor abrasions.
From The Wabash Collection of Liberty Double Eagles.
NGC ID# 268H, PCGS# 8904
68
1852-O Liberty Double Eagle, AU50 Popular Branch Mint Type Coin
3330
1852-0 AU50 NGC. Variety 1. The New Orleans Mint was still receiving large shipments of gold from the California mines in 1852, since the San Francisco Mint would not be ready for operations until 1854. A relatively large mintage of 190,000 Liberty double eagles was accomplished in 1852, making the 1852-O the second- most available New Orleans double eagle. This attractive AU specimen is lightly worn and lightly abraded, and the orange-gold surfaces retain traces of original mint luster.
From The Wabash Collection of Liberty Double Eagles.
NGC ID# 268L, PCGS# 8907
1853 Liberty Double Eagle, AU55 Lustrous, Colorful Surfaces
3331
1853 AU55 NGC. Before the San Francisco Mint opened in 1854, much of the gold from the California gold fields was shipped back East for coinage. Accordingly, the Philadelphia Mint struck a large mintage of 1.2 million Liberty double eagles in 1853. This lustrous Choice AU example exhibits fewer abrasions than expected on the pleasing yellow and orange-gold surfaces, and the strongly impressed design elements show only minor wear on the high points.
From The Wabash Collection of Liberty Double Eagles.
NGC ID# 268M, PCGS# 8908
Visit HA.com/1334 to read full descriptions, check graded population data and auction comparable results, view enlargeable images, and bid online.
1854 Liberty Twenty, AU58 Popular Small Date Variety
3332 1854 Small Date AU58 NGC. The 1854 Liberty double eagle with a Small Date is more available than its Large Date counterpart. This lightly circulated example exhibits a normal yellow-gold color with part of its natural luster intact. It exhibits wear and circulation marks as a lightly circulated large gold coin would. There is one larger scratch underlining the D of UNITED on the reverse. Overall eye appeal is quite strong. NGC has graded 35 numerically finer examples (8/21).
Ex: Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 1/2004), lot 7238. From The Wabash Collection of Liberty Double Eagles. NGC ID# 268P, PCGS# 8911
1855 Double Eagle, AU55 Ex: Fairmont Collection CAC Endorsed Original Surfaces
1855 AU55 PCGS. CAC. Ex: The Fairmont Collection. Gold coins from The Fairmont Collection come from a massive overseas bank hoard that reportedly contains tens of thousands of coins, most of which have been off the market for 75 to 125+ years. The coins pre-date all modern shipwreck recoveries, and display natural color acquired during decades of vault storage. This 1855 double eagle displays Choice About Uncirculated definition and rich, orange- gold toning. Light field chatter exists, but there are no heavy marks seen. Mint luster remains around the raised elements. This is a moderately available Type One twenty that quickly becomes scarce with each step up the grading ladder. CAC endorsement confirms this coin’s original eye appeal and surface quality. Population: 55 in 55, 84 finer. CAC: 15 in 55, 25 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 268V, PCGS# 8914
3333
1855-S Liberty Double Eagle, AU58 Attractive Type One, Branch Mint Issue
3334 1855-S AU58 NGC. Medium S mintmark. Before the discovery and salvage of the S.S. Central America, the 1855-S Liberty double eagle was virtually unknown in high grade. This attractive near- Mint specimen exhibits lightly abraded surfaces, with vivid orange- gold color and much original mint luster. Only a trace of wear is evident on the strongly impressed design elements. NGC has graded 32 numerically finer examples (8/21).
From The Wabash Collection of Liberty Double Eagles. NGC ID# 268X, PCGS# 8916
1856-S Liberty Double Eagle, AU58 Attractive Type One Twenty
3335 1856-S AU58 NGC. A nice, high-end example of this issue, with considerable luster over original surfaces. While not particularly rare in AU, this date is quite scarce in Mint State, so it will be hard to find one nicer, and a better one would be very expensive. The surfaces are unusually smooth and free of mentionable abrasions that so often plague these issues. NGC has certified 41 numerically finer examples (8/21).
Ex: Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 1/2004), lot 7249. From The Wabash Collection of Liberty Double Eagles. NGC ID# 2692, PCGS# 8919
Session One, Auction #1334 | Thursday, October 7, 2021 | 1:00 PM CT 69
3336
1856-S Liberty Twenty, AU55 Choice SSCA Shipwreck Recovery
,
eee dlls ee. cee
@
1856-S Variety 17F, Full Serif, Low S, AU55 PCGS. CAC. Ex: S.S. Central America, SSCA 5847. Compared to the number of 1857-S double eagles recovered from the S.S. Central America shipwreck, the 1856-S double eagle finds were outnumbered about 5 to 1. This example is the scarce 17F die marriage, which has a full left serif on U of UNITED, and a Low S mintmark. Gleaming rich-gold surfaces show a scattering of small marks and abrasions — none severe — across reflective fields and lightly frosted motifs. A pinpoint-sharp strike and significant mint luster remain intact. CAC endorsement signifies above-average quality for the assigned Choice About Uncirculated grade. This attractive coin is housed in its original PCGS SSCA holder with its gold foil label.
PCGS# 70015 Base PCGS# 8919
1857 No Motto Twenty Dollar, MS61 Rare in Mint State
3337
1857 MS61 PCGS. While the 1857-S serves as the most available No Motto double eagle in Mint State thanks to S.S. Central America recoveries, this Philadelphia issue proves much more challenging. Doug Winter estimates only 40 to 60 pieces survive in Uncirculated condition. This MS61 offering is one of them. It features partial remaining mint frost that glistens over yellow and peach-gold surfaces. The stars are full and Liberty’s curls are mostly crisp. Expectedly abraded with two small digs left of the 1 in the date. Population: 34 in 61, 38 finer (8/21).
NGC ID# 2693, PCGS# 8920
70
1857-S Twenty Dollar, MS64 Ex: S.S. Central America
3338
1857-S Bold S, Variety 20B, MS64 PCGS. Ex: S.S. Central America, SSCA 0105. At least eight different die varieties were identified among the more than 5,000 1857-S double eagles that were salvaged from the Central America shipwreck. The Bold S variety is one of the less often represented of these. The present near-Gem displays a sharp strike and radiant, frosty mint luster. The characteristic orange-gold halo around the periphery beautifully frames rose-gold interiors. A small planchet lamination between stars 10 and 11 is the only mentionable strike flaw.
Ex: FUN Signature (Heritage, 1/2017), lot 7063.
PCGS# 70001 Base PCGS# 8922
1857-S Double Eagle, Unc Details S.S.C.A. Second Recovery, With Pinch ‘Narrow Serif on U’ Variety
3339
1857-S Narrow Serif, Variety 20C, S.S. Central America With Pinch — Damage — PCGS Genuine. Unc Details. Bob Evans